Related Posts:

34 Comments


Gravatar
John "Kahless" Taylor said,
August 22nd, 2008 

Ah man! Bruce, you all have to stop giving us all this bad news! :o)

For the last couple of seasons, I hadn’t gotten into SG: Atlantis but I have for this season…and now they’re dropping it! Well, let’s hope SG: Universe is as good or better than it’s 2 predecessors.

Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 
John “Kahless” Taylor: Sorry. I know how you feel. I’ll take a trip down there and smack some people around… Maybe I can knock some sense into them!

There’s an interesting tidbit out there about this cancellation:

The premise is that Sci-Fi probably did not want to cancel Atlantis. It is one of their better rated shows, but then once the shows go to DVD, MGM doesn’t have to share it’s profits.

It’s conjecture, and an interesting one at that!

On the other hand, they’re going out while the show is still pulling in fair to good numbers.

Gravatar
Rob said,
August 22nd, 2008 

I’m surprised its cancelled, when I read it yesterday it hit me.

But the new show sounds interesting

Gravatar
Ash Ali said,
August 22nd, 2008 

Oh what the bloody f*****g hell!!!

This. Royally. Bites. Arse.

Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 

Yeah, this is truly bizarre news. I thought the show was really coming into it’s own, and now they dump it.

My entire family is bummed.

Yeesh.

Vic

Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 

My interest in the show kinda waned last season when they hyped the return of Carter as the new commander at Atlantis, only to have her shunted to the side for nearly every episode I tuned in for. Then she’s out replaced by Woolsey.

I can appreciate a show that takes bold steps in changing it’s regulars up, but you can get too much of a good thing, and in this case, it made it harder for me to adjust to all of the adjustments. More balance would have helped.

Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 

Yeah, I thought adding her to the show was done in a pretty half-hearted way and honestly, I was not sad to see her go. I was actually really looking forward to seeing Woolsey develop beyond this season.

Vic

Gravatar
Gary said,
August 22nd, 2008 

It seemed to me this show was always trying to find its footing.
I did admire the cast though.

Gravatar
Ash Ali said,
August 22nd, 2008 

I had always hoped that instead of Amanda Tapping, they should have brought back Michael Shanks. His character always had more interest in Atlantis and might have brought in a bigger draw in terms of ratings.

Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 
Daniel Jackson, Teal’c & Ronon. Wouldn’t that be a great spinoff!?
Gravatar
August 22nd, 2008 

Just watched the two latest episodes. I’m more annoyed than ever that they are ending this series. It has at least another couple of years left in it.

Vic

Gravatar
Andy said,
August 22nd, 2008 

I agree Vic. This is bogus. This is one of my favorite shows and a staple of my Friday nights. What the hell is it with networks dopes who cancel shows that people LIKE?!?!?! What’s next? Dr. Who? Probably since I love that show, too!

GRRRRR……

I wonder if we get everyone on this and all the other movie/tv sites to flood SciFi with emails to save the show if it will have any effect.

Gravatar
the old man said,
August 22nd, 2008 

Yeah Andy, they’ll probably send us E-mails about their new Friday line up.. retreads, like “Lost” episodes. I thought I would be up for “Jeremiah,” because I dropped HBO when it was just a few episodes in. After all these years it just didn’t hold any allure.

Gravatar
Rob said,
August 23rd, 2008 

I wonder how many cast members will get on the new show?

They always find a way

Gravatar
steven the git said,
August 24th, 2008 

That’s exactly what they should do, just get the cast of both cancelled shows and stick them in the new one.
Maybe SciFi won’t notice. ;)

Gravatar
Ken J said,
August 24th, 2008 

You know, it’s weird that they will end this series as soon as it got its footing, while with SG1, it lost its footing as soon as RDA left but they tried to keep it going, but in the end, it just wasn’t the same without “Jack.”

They should do a movie with the full cast of both SG1 and Atlantis, that would be interesting. Although having to split attention in so many directions will not give any of the stars the attention they deserve.

Gravatar
Mat D. said,
August 24th, 2008 

I have recently gotten into stargate via reruns and had been watching Atlantis this season…better to go out on top I’d guess….I see it this way, there is 15 seasons worth of Stargate to watch…that’s not bad IMO

Gravatar
Ken J said,
August 24th, 2008 

Don’t even bother waiting for them to come on tv, or renting, just go ahead and buy the first 7 seasons of Stargate SG1, you won’t be sorry. Amazon.com has them for buy one get one free, so you can get the whole set for half the price. Don’t buy the complete series set, I heard they packaged the discs real badly and they usually arrive all scratched up.

Gravatar
August 24th, 2008 

Yeah, SG-1 should have ended when RDJ left the show… maybe it IS better that they go out while Atlantis is still good, but really, I thought they had at least one more good season left in there.

Vic

Gravatar
darkbhudda said,
August 25th, 2008 

They are deliberately aiming the new Stargate Universe series at a “younger audience.” *shudder* That’s usually TV exec talk for pretty faces, wooden acting and bad soap opera.

Gravatar
Ken J said,
August 25th, 2008 

Oh yes, I’m sure you’ve all seen the 200th episode of SG1 where they mock the typical “younger hipper” movement in new tv shows right? LMAO! That was the best part next to the Team America spoof… The Farscape spoof is right up there too, especially since two of them are former cast members, lol.

Gravatar
steven the git said,
August 25th, 2008 

I loved the 100th and 200th episodes.
Again, showed the sense of humour and awareness the show had.

Gravatar
790 said,
August 25th, 2008 

This show never really got Atlantis right. :-(

Gravatar
Gillian Thompson said,
September 13th, 2008 

I have been a loyal follower of stargate sg-1 and atlantis from day one after all these years how can I live without them.
Someone better come up with something, with guest stars from the old gang of both series, they are like my family I will realy miss them, but of course I knew this day was coming it’s just hard when it does. It’s not often that a series comes along and is so good you can’t wait for the next episode. Oh well one can only hope.

Gravatar
Ken J said,
September 13th, 2008 

Yah, that’s how I felt about SG-1, never got into Atlantis as much. But since SG-1, I’ve really gotten into Rome (through the DVDs) and just finished the finale yesterday, now I’m sad again… Titus Pullo!!!!!!! lol

Gravatar
the old man said,
September 13th, 2008 

“stargate sg-1″ “Alice Thru The Looking Glass” meets Egyptian mythology.

“SG Atlantis” Alice Thru The looking Glass” meets “The Vampires”

Gravatar
Mila_me said,
September 17th, 2008 

I am going to cry. First they get rid of SG1 which was really coming to terms with the lost of RDA. Yes it was different but it was still very good. The addition of Val to the team whilest not producing some horrible two alpha female situation where they compete was fantastic. They both had their own niche.

So no SG1, no atlantis, very soon no Battlestar (and don’t get me started on the second half of the last season to be shown next year) They have taken away Start trek. Where are we meant to go next? Heroes, which while good, is not forfilling in the way that the others are its ‘pop sci fi’. Doctor who - that far to fluffy and blatantly moral with emotional group hugs at the end of each show?

How are we to forfill our need to travel to other worlds, understand new civilisation discover that people everywhere while different are the same.
Learn about no existant ancient peoples? Have deep and meaningful political discussion about religious zelots (the ori was enspired)

So MGM above is a list of what we require from the new SG Universe. What we do not want is SG county, Hollygate or god forbid bigbrother in space.

Please include old members of SG1 and atlantis. If you make it and we will watch.

Gravatar
September 17th, 2008 

@Mila

Yeah, I hear you. Seems like sci fi fans won’t have anything space-related to watch after Summer 2009. I hadn’t thought about that!

Vic

Gravatar
Mike said,
September 23rd, 2008 

I am totally bummed!!

i just watched ‘the queen’ and it totally kicked ass!

what about a spin off on the wraith? or maybe tayla as there wraith leader? that would be a nice one…

and for god sake! put Ted on the steady team!! give him a little stargate outfit and let him join in!

cheers and respect from holland!

Gravatar
September 23rd, 2008 
Hey Mike!

Thanks for visiting us all the way from Holland!!

Yes… I’m totally bummed too. This new… (Maybe I should rephrase that since most developments seem to be in the planning stages for a period of time)

This development put extra pressure on the creative forces that they had better produce something pretty dang good in the next stargate rendition.

They need to retain us, the viewers who liked characters from SG or Atlantis, they need to be careful how they extend the SG mythos and they need to make it unique enough to not mirror the character mix we’e seen duplicated from SG to SGA.

Gravatar
John "Kahless" Taylor said,
October 20th, 2008 

I had totally forgotten about this thread. I had come across an article on scifi.com and thought it would be great to post it on Screen Rant. Vic had to remind me Bruce already posted it. I think a Wraith must have sucked all the juice out of me and that’s why I can’t remember a fracking thing! :-)

Gravatar
JMT said,
November 14th, 2008 

That’s it I’m D-O-N-E.

I have avoided buying or renting the other “closures” for the 1st series as I viewed them as pure $$$$$$ grabs & so I will also do with this.

I already pay for my tv access via my DishNetwork pkg which includes the Sci-Fi Channel so if the “closures” don’t show-up on my tv then I won’t see them.

If I had not already been an Atlantis watcher when they pulled this “closure” crap with the 1st show I wouldn’t have watched the 2nd. And now since they pulled this $ grab crap again BUT this time BEFORE the next series starts then I’m NOT going to watch the 3rd. Screw-em!

Star Trek folks never pulled this (which is a series of series that Stargate has stolen story ideas from MANY times, BTW) $ grab crap by trying to “blackmail” ppl into paying $ to see movies for “closure”. ST did their closures on TV (well, except the original but that WAS canceled B/C of ratings) for their series & the movies were BONUSES NOT “CLOSURES”.

LONG LIVE TORCHWOOD! :)-

What's your opinion? Leave a comment!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.