• Cody
    I don't even want to see Black Cat in the movie lol
  • JessSayin
    I just read that Anne Hathaway was actually offered the part.
    Probably another in a long list of internet rumors.
  • While I think you may be smoking something that was handed to to you from Cheech and Chong for even remotely suggesting Anne Hathaway was good in Bride Wars from earlier this year...

    If it wasn't for the July Garland bio-pic I'd actually think Anne Hathaway would be nothing short of a slam dunk.

    But I'm not for Tricia Hefler. Only reason she's mentioned is because she had her hair blonde in Galactica. That's why folks can't see Hathaway- "because she's a brunette'. Can I gag now? Heck, we might as well toss in Hathaway's 'Bride Wars' co-star Kate Hudson.

    I'd love Anne (don't we all) but I see more Lake Bell or Jill Wagner.
  • Evan
    @Cody

    I agree with you. I am still hoping that there is no Black Cat, honestly.

    If she is in the movie, I hope she is just Felecia Hardy and not Black Cat yet.

    BUT I want Morbius and the Lizard. That is the next movie. C'mon Rami!
  • Cody
    I don't mind Felicia Hardy/Black Cat as a character, but I think that they could do so much better in coming up with a villian to use. Especially if Spiderman 4 will be the last film of the current Spidey film series.
  • jeremy
    just out hathaway in there she is hotter then most the other choices. well except hefler she is hot but i still think that hathaway makes the best choice.
  • Richard
    you dont think rachel mcadams is hot? lol.
  • Vincent
    I agree with Evan and Cody. I'm really hoping that Black Cat won't be the primary villain, or Peter's new love interest. If this is going to be the end of the Raimi Spiderman films, then it should go out with a bang, an interesting villain, and a proper resolution to the love story they've been feeding us for 3 films.
  • Jason
    Anne Hathaway, in my opinion, would be too much celebrity for the movie. I don't think people would see Black Cat, they'd see Anne Hathaway playing some comic book hottie. As for Tricia Helfer, who was extremely good on an episode of CSI - long before BSG fame, I think she's more of a small-screen actress than a big screen. It wouldn't be fair to put the pressure of a big budget movie on her shoulders, so to speak. I seem to remember Jessica Biel being mentioned in the past and, while I think she'd make an interesting Batgirl, I'm not sure she wouldn't be better going up against Tobey Maguire than the other actresses.

    If we're considering unknowns, though, I'd like to throw Katheryn Winnick's name to the list. She has all the range the character would need and isn't typecast. I think she would be one of those performers who could make the role interesting simply because an audience wouldn't know what to expect from her.
  • the old man
    Well Kofi on this one I think you have plenty of merit... AHEMM... However I'm going to throw a curve into this mix and say we get double trouble with the female villain Viper as well! Perhaps the real villain here is Spiderman!! Just because he's in good with New York city doesn't mean that can't all go south when the Feds represented by SHIELD get involved. With Black Cat getting in the way of old-web heads catching Viper in the act of stealing SHIELD secrets, and getting framed for the snatch, we could very well see which good guy wins as the race comes down to the wire... and while were at it we'll show some lizard lips and bonus tale. Just wait, you'll have to see it to believe it! Wow I feel like Stan Lee pitching to the fans...
  • Lord Garth, Formerly of Izar
    shatner
  • M-Cat
    She should be played by an unknown if Black Cat has to be in it. And Raimi should play an actual director.
  • neontiger21
    I think Hathaway seems to "nice girl" to be a villain. I do admit I have not seen either Brokeback or Rachel Getting Married though. I like Rachel McAdams best of those choices if Black Cat is in it. But my ideal villains for Spider-Man 4 would be The Chameleon and Kraven the Hunter.
  • Reaper
    If they do decide to have the Black Cat then they had better now hire Stiles for it, I can't think of anyone worse. In fact if they did hire Stiles I'm not how keen I'd be to see the film, just because she starred with Ledger in 10 Things I hate, doesn't mean she's as good an actress.
  • Chris O
    Here's another name I'm tossing out there, Jessica Alba. Though I could see Jessica Biel as Felicia/Black Cat. Though personally prefer Eliza Dushku.
  • Ken J
    @neontiger

    Go rent "Havoc" then tell me how much of a "nice girl" you think she is... Um, you can thank me later for that one...

    @Chri O

    I think it might be better if they went with someone who can act. That means Megan Fox and Jessica Alba are both out of the running...
  • Tricia Helfer..wow, GREAT THINKING. I thought Anne Hathaway was good choice, and she is, but Helfer would blow the role out of the water based on what she showed in Battlestar Galactica.
  • Domon
    Another reason Helfer would be good... she's already played the Black Cat, in the Spectacular Spiderman cartoon. I think she'd be an awesome choice.
  • propnut
    Personally, I'm hoping that this is all just hype (like before the last movie) and Black Cat is not in it at all!
    Good character for the comics and animated series, but not for a film.
  • chrisj
    My opinion of which actress should play the BLack cat role would be in this order.

    1. Rachel McAdams- Deleted now
    2. Elisha Cuthbert
    3. Julia Stiles
    4. Mila Kunis
    5. Eliza Dushku
    6. Anne Hathaway
  • chrisj
    Even though she wasnt on the list, I think Laura Vandervoort would be perfect.
  • @ chrisj

    I agree, Elisha Cuthbert would be a nice choice.
  • But more importantly when are they going to get e decent actor in for Spiderman, and a director who has the faintest idea of what people actually want to see in this movie? Now thats a bigger question.
  • chrisj
    @ Dr.SamBeckett
    Yeah. I hoping Rachel McAdams would consider the role. Oh well, I dont see how Eliza Dushku be right for the part and Anne Hathaway is good actress but seems too goody good and too sweet. From the Comics & 90's animated series i would say McAdams & Elisha Cuthbert would be perfect with the way ive seen them smile and i bet they could be seductive towards Spidey. Im more curious if Lizard will be in the film, at the sametime hoping Bruce Campbell is indeed Mysterio.
  • SK-47
    The perfect choice for Black Cat is Scarlet Johansson.
    Unfortunately she is the Widow which is just wrong for her. Emily Blunt should have taken that role, or even a good Russian actress since Widow is Russian.
    Out of the list, Anne hathaway is the best choice I guess.
    Julia Stiles seems more MJ type.
    The real problem is that the comic artists always draw Black Cat as this smoking hot girl with porn-star curves and bust. Scarlet is the only female actress I know that fits to how Felicia Hardy is drawn. All the other girls, although very nice to look at, are just skinny models who can act.
    And there is nothing wrong with that.
  • It is a massive shame Rachel Mcadams has passed on the role, because if she had been in this film, then there is the tiniest of chances I might have been able to get excited about the project.

    Anyone else think that Mcadams would be perfect for Lois Lane in new Superman????
  • rich
    hey again...

    horrible idea.. black cat? who in the f*** wants to see MORE mushy mashy crap between someone and TOBEY maguire

    GIVE ME A VILLIAN DAMMIT

    ledger handed these idiots the blueprint for a good comic book film

    its not the hero these days that makes a film, its his opposition
  • @rich

    And that sort of thinking is what makes me like TDK less and less.
    Ledger gave the performance of a lifetime in that movie, but for me I have never seen a Superhero film where the hero is actually the main character. And that annoys me, I want to see these comic book heroes on screen, not the villains!
  • the_old_man
    Well her facial structure and lip to eye width is not as good as Margot Kidder's. Would you say she can act better than Margot did? Who else you got?
  • While I voted for Julia Stiles to play Black Cat I'd also like to throw in a couple of names that were not in the mix, and while they may sound cheesey or corny I think they would bring an interesting twist to the Black Cat character! I'd like to add to the list Christina Applegate and Brooke Shields I could see either one of these ladies playing Black Cat. Wonder what you guys have to say???? God speed and happy trails....
blog comments powered by Disqus