Comments on: Smallville Season 8 Finale Review & Discussion

By: ssf

ssf — Tue, 20 Oct 2009 03:20:21 +0000

ok- so I want this to make it to 500 comments, so let me share with y’all a dream I had inspired by the finale.

I had a dream about the Doomsday/Superman fight, but Doomsday was a short dude who looked like a turkey and had little needly things protruding from his face. And he basically tried to slap Superman until Superman said “Stop It.”

Digging Season 9 so far.

By: Brian

Brian — Thu, 15 Oct 2009 06:46:46 +0000

Foopher,

I realize that you are way more into this whole comic book/sci-fi/Superman/Smallville thing than I am. I wanted to thank you for letting me rant about my disappointments with season 8 back on June 24, 2009. Your opinion and views are valued since you are obviously such an intelligent man and never look past the obvious for the absurd. Your tolerance of other people’s views speak well to your humility, keeping in mind that your thoughts on any subject are perfect and with out contest, which all of us are keenly aware of. Yet you still let us speak without judgment or and without being condescending. How nice of you.

I’m sorry for wanting something different than you from the series. How stupid of me to express free will and personal thought. My arrogance does get the best of me at times. I will be careful to keep my silence around such a great man like you, so perfect and sound in all things. Clearly, I was wrong for not only expressing that thought but for thinking it too. How foolish. I hope you can overlook my shame.

I have to end this now. You see, I have a life. I wish I didn’t so that I could be more like you but I just can’t bring myself to to your level of existence. The thought alone is terrifying to say the least. I wish you well in your blogs and hope that you continue to enrich the rest of humanity with your deep insights. I will continue to read them for the same the reason that I read Far Side comics… They are just so amusing and delightful.

By: Smallville – The Complete Eighth Season DVD – Win Yours Here!

Smallville – The Complete Eighth Season DVD – Win Yours Here! — Wed, 07 Oct 2009 14:47:59 +0000

[...] Smallville Season 8 Finale Review and Discussion (screenrant.com) [...]

By: Smallville fan

Smallville fan — Tue, 22 Sep 2009 12:52:24 +0000

up until season 8 i have been really happy with smallville.. now im not as educated with the comics as most of you but i do know the mythology of superman and i do know about doomsday. i have watched every episode of smallville and listen for the most part season 8 was fine. the ending was not. the episode titled doomsday was a disgrace.. i do understand budget issues but what the hell were the writers thinking? i wonder if the really crap[ ending had anyhting to do with the absence of the shows original creators?
i liked what they did with doomsday, smallville has always done things there own way thats fine. the fight though, man that was really disappointing, i mean so disppointing that i dont know if im going to watch it again. you build an entire season up to this moment and its impotent and thats being nice.. the jimmy thing, ok i get it his brother is the REAL jimmy olsen, cool. the death or the burial of doomsday i dont get and i dont know if anyone picked this up but how the hell did the JLA get out of there and clark getting out of there without a scratch huh? what about it being his greatest battle ie myhtology? and clark saying before he loses faith in humanity that Oliver and the rest didnt make it out yet he must of saw them at the funeral? and yes clark should of died, that would of been the proper ending to smallville season 8, season 9 then could of delved a little deeper into the mythology, .. instead we have Zod again? didnt this guy get banished to the phantom zone for good? all in all i would love to know what drugs the writers are on, i guess it was to good to last..

By: Foopher

Foopher — Mon, 07 Sep 2009 16:08:57 +0000

Doomsday isn’t dead. Clark knew that. He’s just trapped underground.

By: Daniel

Daniel — Mon, 07 Sep 2009 07:10:08 +0000

Okay so I have read the Death of Superman story arc and can I tell you I was stoked for Doomsday in this season. I mean that’s a huge story in the Superman lore and what do the writers of Smallville do? They minimize the story so much that I can’t think straight. Who hired these people?
If you decide to bring up the character of Doomsday, fine, but Superman has to die while in combat with him and then be resurrected. Yes, I understand that they did the same thing without the whole dying thing… At least as far as we know. After a whole 22 episodes of waiting we don’t even get to see one of the biggest bads in the universe get killed?
All of that makes me think that Doomsday isn’t dead. It is too convenient to have him go away and Clark not knowing what exactly happened. I’m sorry but the writers aren’t good enough for me not to expect any more from them.
I did like the idea of Clark now being disillusioned with humanity. It is nice to see the boy in blue going through some more character development.
Also I just want to say that I really appreciate that the creators of this show have not used Batman. To ruin the mythos of Bruce Wayne by trying to make him a teenager or a twenty something that would associate with any of the other characters on this show would be beyond anyone’s ability to forgive. But I digress.
Season 8, not a good season. Let’s hope that season 9 is the end of our pain. Either in that the season is actually good, or it is the final death rattle of this god forsaken series.

By: Foopher

Foopher — Wed, 26 Aug 2009 19:36:18 +0000

Holy Crap!!! A post! lol.

Yes just say Lex is wearing a wig. Whatever it takes. Just get Michael back on the show. He’s awesomeeeeeeeee!!!

By: Zoraya

Zoraya — Wed, 26 Aug 2009 15:15:29 +0000

Yes, Smallville is a rethinking of a classic. Its a ballsy and totally different way to go about this but thats also exactly why we cant all expect this show to happen like in the comics. This is their own version. To SSF: I think you’re right! I never thought about it that way. So Clark better hurry up and get his training! To Jim Spector: I also think that bringing in classic DC characters would be fantastic. The little hints at Clark being Superman are great but also meeting characters we’ve grown up with would be fantastic.
Oh and my fingers are also crossed for a Mike Rosenbaum reappearance! Even if it was just one episode, my world would be a little better for it! C=

By: Foopher

Foopher — Wed, 12 Aug 2009 20:25:06 +0000

mhmm. yeah. about the hole with doomsday and “with the explosions going on as soon as he got there he couldnt have got him all the way down there”…. gravity. the explosions just sealed the hole. gravity got him to the bottom.

They did the thing with jimmy so that people like you who know the comics would be satisfied with his age.

They actually explain that everything they did in the finale was to line it up with the comics to please all the comic fans.

Smallville is a rethinking of an american classic. RETHINKING

By: eric

eric — Sun, 09 Aug 2009 18:09:52 +0000

I agree with person who set this up whole heartedly. Im a big superman fan so naturally ima big smallville fan and overall i love the show though if like me you know about superman i mean really know about the comics not jus liking the character this show spits in your face repeatedly. Between fighting and killing all his famous enemies which inturn made him famous before he puts on the suit. wrong origin stories for almost all characters and way to much kryptonite. The problems of the show were exceptable but the season 8 finale i couldnt take i agree with you a 100% doomsday’s origin was garbage. the show built up this whole clash of the titans feel, the whole draw of the season without lex luther making you cant wait to see the fight and the fight was 25 secs they spit in our face with jimmy olsen if that wasn’t the real jimmy then he shouldn’t have been in the show especially for mulitple seasons that was poor writting and really smallville didnt show how doomsday got beat. i know what was suppose to happen clark was to put him at the bottom of that like 3 mile hole and then explode it an leave him down there but as soon as he grabbed him an took him there the buildin exploded, with the explosions going on as soon as he got there he couldnt have got him all the way down there if by some bs he did how did clark get out it makes no since that finale was sad to say jus trash

By: ssf

ssf — Sun, 02 Aug 2009 10:49:29 +0000

Clark never officially went through his Kryptonian training, did he? I remember he was going to do that in Season 6, but he had to capture all the phantoms first. Then in Season 7, Jor El told him his training would begin with him watching over Kara. So if my memory serves correct, Clark has not had his training. Does he need to have that before he can officially become Superman?

By: Jim Spector

Jim Spector — Sun, 02 Aug 2009 00:56:21 +0000

Smallville is one of my favorite shows. I am 58 and have been part of the DC universe since I was 5. The best episode was the legion. It was Pre Superman , very bold for the writers, and yet, I always had a feeling the writers would someday do it. It is the best kind of Smallville episode , because it stays with the original concept. Clark meeting Lois, Jimmy, and some of the other charactors before he becomes Superman is strange, but the writers dealt pretty well with things, I myself like the epic moments like fist meetings with other DC People and all. I hope they include some fantasy episodes where Clark goes into the future and sees himself as Superman, I hope also other members of the JLA make appearences too. And some others like the challengers, naybe Adam Strange, and where Clark finds himself in other universe’s and on other worlds. These kind of things to me are better then a whole year of a boring love triangle. Lets see more of Krypton, and finally see Jor El,and please if we go to Krypton, make it more then a world of ice castles. Fire falls, The Scarlet Jungle, ect. If done right Smallville could easily go a few more seasons.

By: Aaron

Aaron — Sat, 01 Aug 2009 19:47:00 +0000

I love smallville it’s my favorite show but I am very disappointed with how s8 ended & the still no flying thing. There is so much they could do with this show they should never have to do the stupid episodes like “stiletto” or other filler eps. It’s about time Clark start to act like a hero & quit whinning to chloe all the time. & the whole thing with kryptonite being all over the place & every bad guy has some jewelry convienently made of a rare meteor is really old. Come writers this is a genre full of great storys. AND PLEASE LET CLARK FLY!!!!!

By: Foopher

Foopher — Fri, 31 Jul 2009 00:48:52 +0000

no that was for tasouli

By: ssf

ssf — Sun, 26 Jul 2009 20:20:01 +0000

Not sure if that was directed at me, as I do watch and rewatch the show alot. I am not disappointed in anything Smallville wise- I just would like, if they are going to focus on Oliver this season, to see Green Arrow and Black Canary get together, and lay off the Lois/Ollie thing. It would be an added bonus if Lois could see the future Daily Planet with real Jimmy Olsen and Perry White.
New spoilers on Kryptonsite- fingers crossed for a Michael Rosenbaum return.

By: Foopher

Foopher — Sat, 25 Jul 2009 16:11:40 +0000

Have you watched the show. The entire season finale was to try to please the fans and line stuff up with the comics. Same withh all the little gags with clark in glasses and hints at other supermanish things throughout the show. So yeah. Sorry to burst your bubble of disappointment

By: tasouli

tasouli — Tue, 21 Jul 2009 19:47:16 +0000

@ SSF

I like your thoughts here, but unfortunately the Smallville writers NEVER give the fans what they want.

By: ssf

ssf — Tue, 21 Jul 2009 19:24:32 +0000

It would be cool to see Green Arrow and Black Canary get together like in the comics. I hope they don’t put him with Lois again. Zoraya, I’d also like to see Perry White come on board and would love it if Michael Mckean(season 3) reprised the role.

What would also be cool (sorry to be dreaming here) would be if the future Lois goes to with the ring is her future, with grown up real Jimmy Olsen, Clark in glasses (but not seeing him in tights, as Superman), maybe a hint at Chloe’s future. I just think that would be cool.

By: Zoraya

Zoraya — Tue, 21 Jul 2009 16:36:08 +0000

Oh! ANd I think it would be fantastic for Perry White to finally make his permanent appearance on Smallville!

Ps. Just read that Lois comes back in the first episode (called Savior) and might resume her old relationship with Oliver (ugh) and John Corben (aka Metallo (uh-oh)) might be replacing the “dead” Clark Kent…I dont know how I feel about all that just yet..

By: Zoraya

Zoraya — Tue, 21 Jul 2009 16:28:39 +0000

Okay, so I agree with most of your opinions on the season finale. It was good and strange, I think. If Season 9 can explain it, I think I’d like the whole Jimmy’s little brother continuing in his big bro’s footsteps and becoming the real Jimmy Olsen. I think/hope that when Lois somehow gets back to the present time she”l know about her future with Clark and maybe do something to make it happen faster? I dunno, just guessing out loud here. I would love to bring in more Justice League characters next season, especially Cyborg since we already got a little taste of him. Zod being back would be the bad guy for Season 9, so Clark would have to start becoming more Superman-ish if he doesnt want to be both Clark and Superman. Chloe should help him out with all that and become the whatever she was hinted at being for the Justice League full-time. Oh right, and I totally agree that Clark rediscovering his feelings for Lois as he mourns her disappearance is a super great idea!
And I guess I just have this to say too: Dont give up on Smallville just yet! The finale was strange but I read that they had planned on this being the last season originally but hten last minute decisions made that a no-no. So maybe next season will be good because they have more ideas to expand upon or something. I also read here on ScreenRant that someone suggested the idea for Metropolis as the follow-up to Smallvile, and I love it! Of course poor Tom Welling might not be up for a whole new show continuing his role as grown-up Superman (of course, I personaly think Tom Welling is the best live-action Superman ever casted). But if he’d be up for it, I think it would be a wonderful thing.
C=