Related Posts:

18 Comments


Gravatar
Max said,
August 1st, 2008 

“However bad the writing, however…”

This made me laugh. Sorry if it wasn’t intentional

Gravatar
The Big Dentist said,
August 1st, 2008 

It certainly ain’t good. And “opening pageS”?? What is it, in 20-point type or something? What a gyp.

And what the HELL is going on with Robert Pattinson’s hair??

Let the onslaught begin…

Gravatar
MTR said,
August 1st, 2008 

First off…It’s Stephenie Meyer (minus the “S”).

Secondly, don’t diss it unless you read it. You too WILL get sucked into her incredible writing.

MTR

Gravatar
greenknight333 said,
August 1st, 2008 

@ MTR

Total romanticized crapola of the worst kind..Like I said before I tried to read one of the books twice…and I HATE to start a book that I don’t finish….but I had to toss it aside as it was unmitigated garbage!! IMO :)

Gravatar
August 1st, 2008 

MTR, thanks, the article has been corrected.

Vic

Gravatar
greenknight333 said,
August 1st, 2008 

and before the fangirls and “boys” start…I find her writing to be overly wordy in that she over uses adjectives and adverbs to make her dialogue seem more deep that it actually is…Poor Ed the tragic hero caught in the existential and “timeless” struggle that is basically a metaphor for teen angst and teen sexual fustration. Will he make her “Vampire” or won’t he…Cripers even the quote Meyer uses at the beginning of the book is from Genesis and represents how “choice” should be individualistic…WOW that’s real deep…Over simplified teeny-bopper romantic stuff… Now that’s a screen rant ;)

Gravatar
Kofi said,
August 1st, 2008 

to MTR

MTR, first, let me apologize for the name mistake. I really pushed this article so that it could go up today. Second, I read half of Twilight, as I try to stay on top of all the latest trends in pop literature. I don’t think Mrs. Meyer is a TERRIBLE writer, just that she, like Rowling did, could stand to improve her craft. Her success speaks for itself, and should put the opinion of myself and others who echo it in the minority perspective we clearly hold. Enjoy Breaking Dawn, and the film.

Gravatar
790 said,
August 2nd, 2008 

Isn’t this just a “Lost Boys” inspired Buffy the Vampire Slayer revision more or less based on a book yeah ok. Uuhmm

Turning off “Notify me of followup comments. ;-)

Gravatar
LN said,
August 17th, 2008 

The book is incredible u just cant judge it before you even finish it. jeez ppl…. It’s an AMAZING book

ppl who don’t get sucked into the story is just to dumb to understand it.

and what’s up with the rival abotu HARRY POTTER and twilight fans going against eachother that’s stupid…it’s just a book
DONT start a WAR over something like moving the movie DATE!!!

Gravatar
LN said,
August 17th, 2008 

oh and haha

BELLA GETS PREGNANT!!!!!
with a VAMPIRE/MORTAL BABY!!!
SHE ALSO BECOMES A VAMPIRE.
ALICE AND JASPER LEAVES>>>FOR A WHILE…
SPOILER haha

Gravatar
Tamara said,
September 18th, 2008 

I agree, Ms. Meyer isn’t a perfect writer, but she has obviously managed to create a fictional world that attracted millions of readers. We have to give her some credit for that. How many writers can generate such sustained interest and sales figures? Not too many, if you ask me. I also don’t think that her aspirations include a Nobel prize in literature, so we can just give her a break. For a mass-market book, it’s still pretty okay.

I have no problems with you criticizing Ms. Meyer and her literary shortcomings, but I found your comment about “stifled housewives, still age eighteen in their heads” incredibly arrogant and judgmental. I can easily accept the fact that you don’t like the Twilight series, but I don’t like your condescending attitude toward people who do. Reading and enjoying Twilight doesn’t automatically make them imbeciles.

Gravatar
September 18th, 2008 

@Tamara

I searched this entire page and nowhere do I see a comment or in the post itself a reference to “stifled housewives, still age eighteen in their heads.”

Vic

Gravatar
E said,
September 19th, 2008 

To Vic

Open your eyes dude, look at the top of the page and you shall see clearly “stifled housewives, still age eighteen in their heads”.

Also it’s AnnE Rice with an E!

E.

Gravatar
September 19th, 2008 

Ah, ok. I didn’t notice this was a two-page post.

Well this is an opinion site and that was my writer’s opinion (although I probably wouldn’t have said that, myself).

BTW, I corrected the spelling on Anne Rice.

Vic

Gravatar
September 19th, 2008 

@ Tamara:

I concede. Truth be told, the story of a young girl falling for a young lad, with vampirism, thrown in as an innovative metaphor for sex and sexual desire, is an intriguing concept that can–no should– appeal to readers either young or adult, or any one else able to find delight in reading such a story. There are millions of examples to corroborate that claim. A housewife by no means has to be “stifled” (what does that even mean???) in order to appreciate the deep resonence–on a human level–of Bella and Edwards’ forbidden love.

I formally apologize.

Gravatar
pink ribbon said,
September 20th, 2008 

LN, you wrote: “ppl who don’t get sucked into the story IS just TO dumb to understand it.” Bad usage aside, don’t you think you’re being a bit rude and presumptive? It’s as if you said, “anybody who doesn’t like these books is stupid.” Erm. . . how about matters of personal taste? Also, since Meyer has all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, I think most people who read the books “get it.” Just because they “get it” doesn’t mean they like it.

I have read too many excellent books by too many excellent authors to have anything nice to say about Meyer’s clunky prose, her sloppy pacing (especially in the first book), her overdone detail, her melodramatic dialogue, and her shallow characterizations. By the end of Eclipse, her pacing has improved somewhat. But, IMO, her pacing is the only thing that has improved.

Yes, in spite of Meyer’s fingernails-on-a-chalkboard prose style, I’ve read the first three novels. I did get sucked in by the story, particularly by the backstory of the Cullens, and by story of the werewolf boys of the nearby Native American tribe.

I just wish the story had been in the hands of a more capable writer. Kofi, you make an excellent point about the forbidden love angle, as well as about the sexual metaphor. Adult women I’ve talked with about the books have said they identified with Bella, that they were taken right back to being seventeen again.

Speaking of forbidden love, New Moon references Romeo and Juliet throughout the book. Eclipse references Wuthering Heights (it fits–Bella is as annoying a character as Cathy is–I found them both whiny and selfish).

Books like these are snacks–Twinkies, fluffy with creme filling and easy to swallow. Nothing wrong with having a Twinkie once in awhile. Just don’t try to pass it off as tarte tropezienne.

Respectfully,
pr

What's your opinion? Leave a comment!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have gotten caught in our trusty (but occasionally overly ambitious) spam filter. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.