Where to start with this one? A sense of anxiety would be a good place... as in the feeling I had come upon me from the very first frame of United 93, lasting all the way through to the very last frame of the film where the screen abruptly goes black.

" /> Where to start with this one? A sense of anxiety would be a good place... as in the feeling I had come upon me from the very first frame of United 93, lasting all the way through to the very last frame of the film where the screen abruptly goes black.

" />

Review: United 93

Published 8 years ago by

By Vic Holtreman

Short version: A gripping, realistic portrayal of the events of 9/11 centered on the passengers of United Airlines flight 93 that’s hard to watch but must be seen.

united93 Review: United 93Where to start with this one? A sense of anxiety would be a good place… as in the feeling I had come upon me from the very first frame of United 93, lasting all the way through to the very last frame of the film where the screen abruptly goes black.

There’s no question that this is a very powerful, and important film covering what happened on September 11th, 2001 and focusing on the passengers and crew of the one airliner that did not make it to its intended target. Some have said that it’s too soon for a movie depicting these events, but I disagree. It seems to me that just enough time has passed to where the events of that day… the crystal clear memories of the emotions we felt, have started to fade. Sure, we all remember what happened, but the raw emotion of it has been blunted by the passage of time. No, this is the right time for this film, as both a tribute to those who died and their families, and a kick-in-the-gut reminder to the rest of us of what that day felt like.


The film opens showing the perpetrators in their hotel room, preparing for what lies ahead through prayer and ritual. At this point I hesitate to use the word “terrorists” to describe them, because they are not portrayed as such… yet. What the director, Paul Greengrass has managed to do here is to create real, believable human beings on both sides of the event, and as much as is possible considering the events the film plays things out from a neutral vantage point. This is quite a feat. Not having the terrorists portrayed as evil caricatures must have been, I think, very difficult.

Everything is very mundane at first (as things usually are at an airport), showing folks sitting around waiting for their flights, talking on cell phones, working on laptops, etc. We see the arrival of the four Muslims at the airport and watch them go through security. One of them is shown to be carrying a knife, and he somehow gets through without a problem.

We catch little bits of conversation from passengers and crew, all very trivial, but that adds to the sense of reality about it all. Watching and listening to them talk about their plans for later on was for me, physically painful… knowing what was to come and that none of them would survive the day.

At the airport, the runway is backed up and they have approximately a 30 minute wait on the tarmac, which stresses the leader of the terrorists, since timing was critical to them on that day in order to terrorize everyone to maximum effect. The film takes place aboard the plane, at a central traffic control hub and at air traffic control at multiple locations. Also, part of it takes place at NORAD, where a training exercise is about to take place.

The events of the film seem to unfold in slow motion, as the first hints of a hijacking come to light to one of the air traffic controllers at first as a possible technical glitch, then a communications problem and then a bit of cockpit conversation heard that bodes ill and must be verified. At the time there had not been a hijacking in what? Two decades? So no one jumped up and scrambled on this, although it certainly was not taken lightly.

Seeing the World Trade Center towers in the skyline was gut-wrenching, knowing they would fall that day.

What becomes painfully clear is the lack of a pre-thought-out system to coordinate communications between the various agencies which had a need to know about this, including the military. The awareness of the seriousness of the situation seems to take a long time to build, although it was in reality probably less than an hour or so before everyone got in the groove.

Eventually we see the dreaded takeover of the flight, as the terrorists murder the pilot and co-pilot, and stab a passenger just to show they’re serious. The frustration of the commanders at NORAD really comes across, as it seems that they might have been able to counter what was going on more quickly if channels had been more open. Yes, this might have involved shooting down the planes, and it’s abundantly clear the anguish that possible decision had on those in charge. We also see the realization of the passengers that this is a suicide mission, and that if they’re going to die they may as well try and take the plane.

We all know what happened, and as I stated, that makes the film that much more difficult to watch, but watch it we must, in order to remind us of what we are up against. Yes, I know there are some whack jobs scattered out there who think that the government blew up the WTC and shot down that plane, but they can go pack sand. Greengrass did extensive research on this and was in touch with as many family members as possible in order to properly pay homage to those men and women and to make this as accurate a portrayal as possible considering the circumstances.

You can feel the seriousness with which the actors took their roles, on both sides. This was no Die Hard take on the events: It was solemnly and tastefully done. As I sat through the credits I was astonished to see the number of people who portrayed themselves in the film, both at the air traffic control locations and at NORAD.

You need to go see this film. No, it’s not fun… it’s important.

Our Rating:

5 out of 5
(Masterpiece)

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:
TAGS: 5 star movies

6 Comments

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

  1. It was a 5 star review as well. I was very taken with the writing and although I will wait for the DVD release, I will watch this. It may take that long to work up the courage (not the right word, but I don’t quite know the right word… the absence of dread?). Thanks.

  2. Hey Randy, thanks so much for the compliment… it’s definitely appreciated.

    Best,

    Vic

  3. Another movie on 911 – even better than this one

    You should see for yourself what a couple of average joes managed to make with ingenious use of the internet (g*o*o*g*l*e among others)

    Just search for 911 Loose Change in g*o*o*g*l*e and you can watch it for free.
    My advice for this movie is sit through it until the end, pay attention, and be objective!

    I thought this film was the biggest pile of non-sense I have ever seen. It encourages xenophobia, makes people want a bigger and better army, and fails to portray a sense of this realism everyone is speaking about. But mainly, all it does, is make one look at an arab twice. It would be good if only arabs were affected, but europeans and people from the USA can’t tell the difference between a brown guy (could be egyptian)and a brown guy (could be indian). The main thing is, since when can you use a mobile phone on the plane? and something else: you couldn’t take an electric battery let alone knives into the cabin of an airplane before the 11th of September anyway. But I’m not going to get into any small (yet key) details, i would advise you to watch this one but not get sentimental – try and analize the facts, but if you can’t then don’t it will make you cringe every time you will hear “Allah o Akbar”.
    It’s a just a shame our governments (yours and mine) can’t just come clean and leave the poorest countries in the world alone.

  4. Jack,

    Yours is the first and last “conspiracy nut” post I will allow on this site. It stuns and amazes me that people who live in the U.S. actually think that the government would orchestrate the murder of thousands of it’s own citizena when all you have to do is turn on the news to see radical Islamic terrorists calling for death to America. Any conspiracy theory out there is based on half-truths and faulty information, no matter how convincingly it is presented.

    If you can be bothered to take the time to read it, I suggest that you go here:

    http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/defense/1227842.html

    Where these whack-job theories are debunked one by one.

    Oh, and you might want to visit http://MichaelSavage.com to see images and videos of what these terrorist murders have done to innocent civilians. Nothing like a real video of a bunch of hooded terrorists sawing the head off an innocent man as he screams his last breath on camera to clear your head of these idiotic notions.

    On a final note, Osama bin Laden ADMITTED that he was responsible.

    Vic

  5. I just saw this the other day on DVD, and I couldn’t agree more with your review. What a riveting, powerful movie… Greengrass truly hit this one out of the park. If this doesn’t deserve a five-star rating, I don’t know what does.

    Brian

  6. This movie was fully inspiring LIES. I am not a true 9/11 conspirator. A lot of the accounts on that are all assumed. I do believe that the people on that plane were gonna try take it back. But they didn’t even come close. The plane was shot down by two F-18s. Vice President Chaney gave the order to shoot down any plane still in the sky after the other planes were told land. Plus it’s real interesting how “All of a sudden” those short conversations became long drawn out execution plans on how the passengers were going to take back the plane. So it can’t be a true story if don’t know for sure what happen. Oh yeah about the plane being shot down. I know a guy in the Air Force who confirmed that the planes were shot down. So in all I could not watch this movie knowing it was One Big Lie!!!!

Be Social, Follow Us!!