‘Outlander’ Takes Claire on the Hunt

Published 8 months ago by

outlander season 1 episode 4 dougal Outlander Takes Claire on the Hunt

[This is a review of Outlander season 1, episode 4. There will be SPOILERS.] 


Any series, even one as well-produced as Outlander, is nothing without a strong cast to hold up its foundation. In this week’s episode, titled ‘The Gathering,’ the men take center stage proving that they have the chops to keep this sprawling story from collapsing under the pressure of its own grandiose weight.

Claire continues to be brilliantly portrayed by Caitriona Balfe, with Ronald D. Moore and his team of writers crafting one of the better female characters currently onscreen. Ms. Balfe, like Tatiana Maslany from BBC America’s hit-series Orphan Black, is a welcomed newcomer to the world of dramatic television. Do you agree?

Okay, so let’s get back to the men of Outlander; specifically Dougal MacKenzie. Actor Graham McTavish (The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies) possesses a wonderfully ambiguous strength, which makes his character difficult to read. ‘The Gathering’ shows us several versions of who this man might be. When drunk, he turns into a cliched brutish pig of a man who thinks only with the wrong extremities, as he attempts to sexually assault Claire in a darkened hallway.

In contrast, toward the episode’s conclusion, after seeing Claire gracefully usher one of his fellow comrades into the afterlife, Dougal does his best to “apologize,” or at least thank her for her kindness. So, which instance better fits the man? Perhaps a little of both? It will be interesting to see what happens between Dougal and Claire on their trip.

outlander season 1 episode 4 jamie Outlander Takes Claire on the Hunt

With any good drama, like Game of Thrones or even Mad Men, characters who choose to live in the “gray” moral spectrum are far more interesting than those clearly marked as good and evil. Thankfully, Outlander has chosen this path for its diverse set of characters. Jamie is another player in this story whose motivations still remain shrouded. What is our handsome young Scotsman looking for?

From the very first time we witness Jamie’s thrashing while trying to defend his sister’s honor, it’s clear that he’s no ordinary man. He’s highly educated, as he speaks fluent French to Claire this week, and his skills at politics are also keenly sharpened.

The scene when Jamie had to choose between pledging fealty to Colum or choosing not to was well-directed. Jamie’s choice to honor Clan MacKenzie the way he did was a smart move. Colum now adores him more than ever and Dougal no longer sees him as a threat to become the new leader. Dougal and Jamie’s fight at the end of the episode was heartwarming, as the two seemed to put their complicated pasts behind them, for now. How long do you think their peace will last?

With Claire, Jamie and Dougal all going on a “road trip” next week, there should be some exciting adventures on the horizon. Will Claire get any closer to the stones at Craigh na Dun? Also, what did you think of the cameos by author Diana Galbadon and creator/executive producer Ronald D. Moore?

Outlander continues with ‘Rent’ next Saturday @9pm on Starz. Below is a special look at Diana Galbadon’s cameo:

Follow David Griffin on Twitter @griffinde
TAGS: Outlander
Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. I have this on my Netflix list, since I do not subscribe to Starz Network. I have been hearing good things about this series, and it appears mildly interesting.

    • You can check out the first episode for free on Starz official YouTube page.

  2. Another really good review.

    Television really has been the place for great leading roles for women. Allison Tolman (Fargo), Eva Green (Penny Dreadful), and the extraordinary Tatiana Maslany (Orphan Black) have given us some great performances. Caitriona Balfe is certainly one that is moving up the ranks.
    Much like Tolman’s role in Fargo, Balfe’s performance is much more nuanced than the others I mentioned. A lesser actor might not be able to convince me that she is a person out of time. But Balfe conveys that without words.
    I’m looking forward to next week’s ‘road trip’.

    • Thanks! Eva Green is having a terrific year. It’s nice to know that we’ll be getting a second season of ‘Penny Dreadful’.

  3. This show moves soooo slowly I don’t see the emotional investment people claim to have in it? I’m guessing that investment comes from the folks that read the books. But when people claim it’s a sweeping tale of characters like Game of Thrones I laugh because Thrones sucks you in from start to finish. This isn’t nearly as interesting. In other words… This show belongs on the Lifetime Network. Its a women’s show. As a guy it doesn’t do anything for me.

  4. Didn’t even know there were cameos of those guys !
    Guess it’s for the hardcore geeks and fans and not for the normal watcher ! :)

  5. Did you just actually put this series in the same line with Mad Men and Game of Thrones to make a point??? Surely you jest! Mad Men and Thrones knocked it out of the park by the pilot. This is level 3 fare at best, not level 1 fare.

    So far, this is actually a downright awful series, full of plodding pacing, moronic supporting characters, and only a few decent cast members. I’ve sat through all 4 episodes so far because I love the girl (Caitriona), and Tobias Menzies is in it. Though after the pilot, I haven’t seen much of him.

    I’ve sat through worse, but not recently. Thinking about Diana Galbadon sharing a panel with George RR Martin is almost laughable. I did actually enjoy her lines on that panel though, lol, so I’ll give her that. This is pretty awful stuff so far though!

    On the plus side, it is pretty nicely shot, so there are a few nice locations that pop here and there.

    I love the girl, so I’ll endure more, and hope it improves.