Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

Published 3 years ago by

2011 Oscars Best Cinematography The Kings Speech Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

This year’s crop of nominees for Best Cinematography all bring something unique to the visual table. Some went with a traditional hand-held approach, while others show vast landscapes and the characters within. Only one can walk away with the Oscar, but each is deserving of a nomination.

Four established cinematographers challenge a relative newcomer, but the crop is filled with pure talent. Each film approached the visual aesthetic in a different way and the result is a compilation of films that stand out from one another, but make for an inspiring year in cinematography.

While each of the five nominees are deserving, some snubs deserve mention. Robert Richardson’s cinematography in Shutter Island helped it stand out, but the lengthy gap between its release and the Oscars may have hurt its chances. Enter the Void is arguably the most inspired cinematography of the decade, let alone the year. Unfortunately, its controversial subject matter and arduous pacing may have hurt its opportunity for worldwide recognition.

The Academy tends to vote for imagery over technical creativity. While films like Inception pushed the envelope of modern cinematography with rotating hallways and tilting rooms, it doesn’t have lasting images like True Grit or The King’s Speech. It would be a surprise if the Academy changed its approach this year, but all five nominees have every right to walk away with an Oscar.

Black Swan

Black Swan cinematography Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

Director of Photography Mattew Libatique finds a way to make every movie he shoots unique with a less-is-more approach. While his approach to Black Swan owes a lot of gratitude to the advancements in visual effects, the hand-held camera approach was essential to the feel of the film.

Libatique spends much of Black Swan in rooms loaded with mirrors. Obviously, this poses a problem for a camera operator running around an actress. Luckily, the visual effects team had the capability to digitally erase him from the reflection. This gave Libatique free range to film the scene in the most realistic style possible. It is because of this documentary-style visual component that Black Swan continues to pummel its realism on the audience, even amidst its supernatural story arc.

Black Swan deserves its nomination for not only its approach, but also its relevance to the narrative structure. Yet it lacks the visual punch we’ve seen in so many past winners in this category. It reminds me of The Hurt Locker, which earned a nomination for its style, but lost to a more visually stunning movie, Avatar.

Inception

Inception rotating hallway Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

Innovation is the best word to describe Wally Pfister’s cinematography. Rarely does the cinematographer work so closely with so many departments in a film, but Christopher Nolan’s unique vision for multiple dreamscapes required the collaborative effort. Cameras were rigged in places they never dare to go and pushed the technical requirements to the brink.

Few question the fortitude of Inception‘s cinematography. It is fresh from a technical perspective, using the latest technology to give the audience an immersive visual experience without falling into the 3D revolution. As advanced as the execution may be, it still lacks the imagery that the Academy tends to favor. For instance, the hallway fight scene is a true testament to the film’s creativity, but many would be hard-pressed to compare the actual imagery to the film’s competition this year.

Wally Pfister has shot all of Christopher Nolan’s films, with the exception of Following. This relationship has turned into one of the most revered in movies today, even though they rarely dip into the atmospheric imagery that many get from films like True Grit or The King’s Speech. Yet, there is a gritty reality fused into Pfister’s photography that brings a visual aesthetic consistent throughout much of Nolan’s work.

The King’s Speech

The Kings Speech cinematography Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

Danny Cohen may not be as well-known as others on this year’s ballot, but his cinematography is at the top of the list of reasons why The King’s Speech is one of 2010′s most heralded films. If Inception was technically innovative, The King’s Speech is creatively innovative. The camera does not perform any tricks, but simply rests in positions that wow the viewer with sensationally memorable imagery.

A round of applause is due for the production design team, which created an environment that popped on camera. But without Cohen’s effort to present the film’s main character in a way that supplements the story, The King’s Speech might be less appreciated.

From the first frame to the last, The King’s Speech never forgets it is a movie. It doesn’t try to be hyper-realistic, even though it is. The camera accents the riveting story that unfolds in front of it by pushing its characters to the corner of the frame and enhancing every emotion that pours from the Oscar-nominated performances. If The King’s Speech does not win Best Cinematography, many viewers will likely sit in shock – I know I will.

The Social Network

The Social Network Timberlake Eisenberg Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

As renowned cinematographers usher in the digital age of filmmaking, Jeff Cronenworth leads the charge with this nominated presentation of a story just as modern as the digital revolution itself. The Social Network is a dark tale and its cinematography pushes that upon the audience with dull color tones and crisp visuals.

The film doesn’t provide Cronenworth ample opportunity to get creative with his imagery, so he took a more simple approach and explored the use of color to supplement the character motivations. One standout scene includes strobe lighting and deep colors as Mark Zuckerberg (Jesse Eisenberg) and Sean Parker (Justin Timberlake) talk at a loud bar.

Overall, the film’s cinematography is subdued and distant. It tries to be invisible, while also creating a subtle visual accent for the story on screen. It most likely won’t win Best Cinematography, but it’s nice to see the Academy giving a shout out to digital cinematography yet again.

True Grit

True Grit cinematography Oscars 2011 Spotlight: Best Cinematography

If any film has a chance to compete with the cinematography of The King’s Speech, it is Roger Deakins and his wonderfully atmospheric imagery in True Grit. The celebrated cinematographer presented the latest film by The Coen Bros. with jaw-dropping visuals that expose the beauty of the Old West.

Deakins’ use of silhouettes and vast landscapes are typically what the Academy votes for, but it does lack a certain creativity that makes The King’s Speech so engaging. Still, True Grit gives audiences a classic approach to cinematography that works for the narrative. Even though the story stays true to the people involved, it is a road movie (in a way) and explores the massive space of the Old West.

One scene that particularly stood out (even though it was enhanced with visual effects) was the opening scene in which snow slowly falls onto a dead body. It is a typical Coen Bros. opening, but visually grabs the audience from the opening frame.

Who do you think deserves the 2011 Oscar for Best Cinematography? Did any of your favorites get snubbed?

TAGS: black swan, inception, oscars, the king's speech, the social network, true grit

16 Comments

Post a Comment

  1. I know alot of people like to think they know what they are talking about, but come on!!!! True Grit or The King’s Speech over Inception, Really!!!!
    If either of those win over Inception this year,I just give up.
    Like 2001: A Space Odessy or Batman Begins, Nolan film’s deserve some kind of recogintion with the Acamedy

    • Have you seen True Grit or TKS? I’m sorry, but their cinematography is better, I think you are confusing terms.

      • Agreed. Inception looked great but compared to TG and TKS it isn’t even the same league.

    • “Like 2001: A Space Odessy or Batman Begins, Nolan film’s…”
      Ummm…

  2. It’s good to see that inventive use of coloring is also taken into consideration. Because I actually care about this award, (and the other technical categories), it’s interesting to see the development of cinematography through the years. Shots The King’s Speech and True Grit are both hauntingly beautiful yet inspiring. Inception gets props for its sleek and stylish variations on dull and bright colors. Haven’t seen enough of Black Swan but it sounds like it deserved the nomination. Jeff Cronenworth has been exceptional in shooting David Fincher’s films and The Social Network is no exception: dark, moody, yet gristly and distant.

    The article is spot on.

  3. True Grit is going to win. Mark my words.

  4. I guess that cinematography speaks on a different level to different folks with different like. The King’s Speech is one of those with an awesome Director of Photography, so has True Grit and Inception. My vote would be either of the latter two. Wally Pfister stunned me with the work on Inception. Roger Deakins has proved time and time again that he knows what he’s doin dudes. I will want him to walk away with that Oscar if not Wally.

    • Agreed with your choices. Pfister and Deakins are two of my favorite working DP’s working today.

      Not saying either one will win, because rarely do the ones I feel are most deserving actually get the awards, but they are the best we’ve got, I think.

  5. True Grit seems to be everyone’s favorite. Its the most praised cinematography of the nominees, and Roger Deakins has gotten 9 nomination and 0 wins, a lot of people are his due for a win.

    But my personal pick is The King’s Speech, I loved its use of close ups and wide angles and how it reflected Bertie’s sense of suffocation and being scared of his position as heir to the throne, I could actually feel that reflected across the screen!

    But an upset could happen in the form of Inception, which won the American Society of Cinematographers award for best cinematography.

  6. Black swan hands down. There’s no comparison.

  7. Pfister all the way.

    • I agree, Agent Tom: Pfister all the way!

  8. The King’s Speech….True Grit….Inception….Black Swan are my picks in that order. Just beautifully shot. ( IMHO Inception should win as pointed out by the ASC.)

    Network gets nothing from me.

  9. Deakins should win. He is one of the best cinematographers out there. He deserves an oscar by now. Plus the landscapes in TG were just fantastic.

    • i totally agree with you!! roger deakins is a phenomenal cinematographer, who has been snubbed too many times by the academy! he is long due his win!

  10. True grit could win.

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

Be Social, Follow Us!!