• Ash Ali
    It's kinda funny really, the actor is getting younger each regeneration all the while the character is getting much older. This will be interesting. I'm excited, but the poor boy is going to have to be good. Or else he'll be forever compared to Tennant.
  • That's a most fascinating observation Ash Ali. Marketing is driving a curious conundrum of sorts!
  • What was weird was the twitter buzz, I was twittering like hell when the program was on and someone twittered to me that Matt Smith was the Doctor before it was announced! infact it was on the wiki entry for him.
  • Initial reaction was oh no ... but then after reading more it was this guy can do it.

    When the doctor was regenerating and we thought that was it we have someone new - we were all prepared then for David Tennants replacement.
  • Thandrale
    I don't know. Is a 26 year old going to be able to project the confident, worldly persona of The Doctor?

    That could be a story point though. Older people not wanting to take orders from him.

    I wouldn't mind an older fatherly Doctor. Having the constant sexual tension between The Doctor and his companions is distracting as well as disturbing.

    After all he is an alien being. If he ever were to bed one of them it could be dangerous.
  • Kyle
    I like the idea of the Doctor becoming younger with each regeneration. If this is what they're going for, then the twelfth could be drinking age, and the thirteenth would probably be a teenager. That'd be pretty interesting.
  • T
    De-aging as a Progressing theme? So would that mean the planet Galifrey is actually ORK from Mork and Mindy fame as they too "aged backward". Well whatever, until he has to trade the Sonic Screwdriver for a Sonic Pacifier...
  • Balabanto
    Wow. He's...too poufy.

    David Tennant was like the absolute limit of the skinny, poufy Doctor as far as I was concerned.

    They really needed someone beefier, maybe even a fat, jolly guy. This was not what I imagined or desired.
  • @Joshi Representing the UK massive =p

    I love the hate going round on the internet at the moment surrounding this guy I really don't think its necessary, we need to see him in action first then judge.
  • Chi
    He IS pretty skinny, but he seems cute enough :) I'm sure as soon as I see him as The Doctor, his looks will skyrocket to total hotness :D
  • Mike Esposito
    Thanks for telling me I dont get it, because I think a 26yr old playing the part is ridiculous.
    Who would have thought that I have spent 30 years watching the show and all along I didnt 'Get it'.
    Thanks for pointing that out to me.
  • Is Matt's middle name John, perchance ?
    That would be too good to be true, wouldn't it ?!!!

    My initial reaction was that he was too young and the role needed an older person, but I also thought David Tennant was too young and he's turned out to be the best Doctor ever...

    So I'll wait and see what Matt does with the role before passing judgement.

    It was interesting to see how the BBC made the announcement, doing it in a way that would have dented ITV's ratings for the FA Cup third-round tie between Preston and Liverpool, something that ITV have only recently poached off the BBC...
  • David
    Everyone seems to be more concerned about this guy's age than weather or not he can act! Being from the colonies, I don't know this guy from Adam, but I am encouraged by the lack of doubt about Smith's ability to become the Doctor.

    That being said, I am just as surprised by the choice of such a young guy to fill the roll. To me, it spells almost certainly there will be romance in the air (god, I hope not!) for the good Doctor and his next traveling companion! One of the surest ways to doom a show is to take the tension between two main characters and turn it into a romance. For Doctor Who it would destroy the universe.

    Question: Does anyone know who the next Doctor Who companion is going to be?
  • David
    Sorry Bruce, I didn't read the last paragraph of your article before posting.

    Still, anyone have any good ideas of who she could be?
  • BV
    My only concern with such a young and "fashionable" choice is that writers will be tempted to write endless romantic and sexually charged stories. One of the refreshing things with Doctor Who was the lack of TV romance plots for the most part save for some close calls during Tennants run.

    We can only hope they put the new actor in an asexually un-fashionable costume. Short of this I fear that the new direction for Doctor Who will "Gossip Girl" with time travel.
  • crocky
    lammmmmmmmeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!! choice,why does everything have to be a 1st these days!the oldest,the youngest,the hairest,the fattest.poor choice.robert caryle perfect choice.charisma packed,established actor.please reconsider the people of......bbc or whoever
  • The Big Dentist
    I'd never heard of Matt Smith until the BBC ran an interview with him and some clips of previous things he'd been in, and I have to say I was sold on the spot. Don't let the skinny foppish thing fool you, this is NOT another Peter Davison.
  • glenn kirkaldy
    matt smith has got to be the worst choice ever. haw can enybody relate to a child as the 900 year old time lord ? this is a case of very bad casting. i am a big doctor who fan and have been all my life. i fear that this skinny pale faced ponce will be the deth of the show. i will take this regeneration the same way i did when peter davidson took over from tom baker. switch it off and pretend it does not egsist. and whats with his hair ? what are they thinking ?
  • Stormy
    Who cares how old he is? The important thing is ACTING ABILITY, not age. Good grief people, get a grip.
  • Ash Ali
    @ glenn kirkaldy.

    How you ask? It's a little thing called, "suspension of disbelief." That's how we're all gonna believe he's a 900 year old Time Lord.
  • I do believe the franchise should not be written off by first impressions in production choices such as who plays the Doctor.

    My first take was similar in nature... eh? Then thought to myself, well, let's see what they do with it.

    The franchise understands what has worked in the past, what worked with this present rendition and we can only hope they retain that formula as they employ whom they think will fulfill that particular set of expectations.

    That's why I said some wont get it. It's about a mutating / regenerating time lord. It should not matter what they look like as long as the core of the character remains the same.

    I wrote in a different post here on Screen Rant that the Dr Who franchise is famous for reeling in non-scifi fans into the show because of the compelling writing / plot lines. The story telling.

    With that in mind, I say we just wait and see. Let's give it a chance.

    Thanks for visiting here everyone.
    -Bruce
  • @Joshi

    I don't know why some comments get "flagged" but I do continually check the spam area for valid ones that get caught.

    Vic
  • So so so young. I can only imagine that they're gonna cast a 12-year-old companion.

    They almost have to, to make this guy look like he has some wisdom.

    I would have preferred Paterson Joseph.

    http://iamatvjunkie.typepad.com/i_am_a_tv_junki...
  • Pepe Le Pew
    Hey who really is going to argue with Steven Moffatt who wrote some brilliant episodes.
    Not me for sure
  • foodandart
    Hey, this man might not be so bad.. I just caught some clips of his interview from Confidential. He's got a young face that can go old in a heartbeat and from the little bit I can find, it appears he can act. The Robert Smith big emo hair is a bit over the top for me but he's not started work so until he gets ready to shoot, NO one knows what any part of the production will look like. I'm hoping for shorter hair but beyond that, I'll take what comes and hope it's as good as it's always been!

    Deb.
  • the Lady
    He doesn't look to bad but we'll have to
    wait and see if he can be the Doctor
    everyone loves. The Doctor now needs to
    be young, someone who can grab your hand
    and say 'run' like the 9th and 10th docter. :)
  • crocky
    in 1yrs time when they realised what a poor choice matt smith is.bbc will be glad to announce will be..........frankie muniz(the tit from malcom in middle).or if you dont like that how about someone who is old like sean connery they could mix it up with bond elements,who doctor who.u might laugh now but they might desperate for the ratings.if and i say if...will, matt smith bombs
  • crocky
    its the hair,that matt smith has that dorky floppy hugh grant hair,if u look at all the doctors they had unique hair.i think the doctor should have a ponytail or a shaved head,tom baker wore the curly afro well that made him,and the cool scarf.floppy hair wont cut it.picky i know but its a sacred thing
  • David
    Just a thought: How about an older lady, think 'Golden Girls', for the new companion? It could be like 'Harold and Maude' traveling the stars! ;)
  • To all the people saying we have no right to an opinion until we've seen him act - is that how you vote during an election? Of course not, sometimes you know instinctively something isn't right!

    Now if they were making "Son of Dr Who" for CBeebies, then fine - but he is totally too young for the role of the Doctor himself! What's he going to wear? A hoodie? Hey, there's a thought - change the name to Doctor Whoodie!!!

    What I'm getting at is, take Daniel Radcliffe. He is a fine actor and you couldn't imagine anyone else playing Harry Potter - but you sure as hell wouldn't cast him as James Bond!

    I've watched the Doc since the mid 60's and been a huge fan. Books, videos, DVDs, audio CD's, magazines, fanzines, American merch, autographs - you name it. But I won't be watching after Tennant leaves.

    I don't want to watch "Boy Who" and his Tardis posse, innit....
blog comments powered by Disqus