‘Mad Men’ Season 5, Episode 4: ‘Mystery Date’ Recap

Published 3 years ago by

Jon Hamm Mad Men Mystery Date Mad Men Season 5, Episode 4: Mystery Date Recap

Taking a cue from a singular, horrific event that captivated the country in 1966, Mad Men threads the murder of eight student nurses in Chicago into the overall narrative of ‘Mystery Date,’ and creates an undercurrent of paranoia throughout the episode.

As Pauline Francis (Pamela Dunlap) describes her upbringing to Sally (Kiernan Shipka), in which she was kicked across the room by her father and later told, “That was for nothing, so look out,” it largely sums up the feeling that part of being an adult is waiting for horrible things to happen, and having a certain amount of preparedness to combat them. But the horrible things don’t just come in the form of mass murder; they come as any number of grievances issued from one person to another. Which is why when a sick and feverish Don (Jon Hamm) is reluctantly forced to introduce his new wife Megan (Jessica Paré), to a woman named Andrea – whom Don had an affair with while married to Betty – that Megan begins to fear she married a man who is a slave to his urges.

The parallels between Don and a psychopath aside, ‘Mystery Date’ also plays on the idea that people can dehumanize an event long enough to satiate their curiosity about it, and then return to the fear that something similar would happen to them. This is evident when Joyce Ramsey (Zosia Mamet) shows up with unpublished photos from the grisly crime scene, Peggy (Elisabeth Moss), Stan (Jay R. Ferguson) and new hire Michael Ginsburg (Ben Feldman) all take a salacious peek, but only Michael later objects on what seems to be moral grounds.

And later, when Sally is unable to sleep after having learned the gruesome details of the crime, Pauline, scared enough to armed herself with a butcher knife, seems to want to use the event as an example for Sally to learn by. However, when pressed for answers as to why the murdered women didn’t fight back, Pauline simply insinuates the victims had settled for one awful fate, not thinking it would end much, much worse. Since Pauline’s handling of situation is already epically bad, she tops it off by giving Sally a Seconal to help her sleep.

Earlier, Don, Michael and Ken Cosgrove (Aaron Staton) are making a pitch to some pantyhose reps and they seem to like the idea, until Michael pitches them the notion of “Cinderella,” but really its of a woman being stalked down a dark street by a stranger – an idea the pantyhose guys seem to really be interested in. Afterwards, Don has some harsh words for Michael, which he takes to be some kind of guidance by Don, and even pooh-poohs Ken’s assertion that the newbie copywriter very nearly lost his job. What that says about Michael is unclear, but it reiterates a common thread that everyone is, in someway or another, fascinated by victimization.

Even Peggy’s not immune to its effects. After bilking Roger out of $400 to come up with some material for Mohawk – who avoided the ongoing mechanics strike – she finds herself alone in the SCDP offices; only this time – spurred on by the news – Peggy goes through a mini strange-noise-in-the-office horror film sequence that results in Don’s new secretary Dawn (Marie Anderson) crashing on Peggy’s couch for the night. At first, Peggy scoffs at Dawn’s unwillingness to go home, telling her she needn’t worry because she’s not a nurse, but immediately realizes the problem doesn’t stem from the hot-topic of the day, but rather the less sensationalized civil rights violence popping up near Manhattan.

Peggy opens up to Dawn after finding out she doesn’t want to be a copywriter like her or Megan, and drunkenly forces her doubts and concerns over how she’s perceived on the temporarily displaced young woman. Then later, Peggy awkwardly tries to mask concern over leaving her purse in the same room as Dawn overnight by cleaning up her empties.

Christina Hendricks Mad Men Mystery Date Mad Men Season 5, Episode 4: Mystery Date Recap

Meanwhile, Joan (Christina Hendricks) nervously welcomes her husband Greg (Sam Page) home from Vietnam with the expectation that their life together will basically start over since he’s now the proud father of Roger Sterling’s child. After being home for just a little while, Greg informs Joan he’s going back to the war for another year, but conveniently leaves out the part where he volunteered to do so. When Joan finally picks up that fact, it happens to play out during a gloriously awkward in-law-filled dinner at an Italian restaurant – complete with an annoying tableside accordionist. Having considered Greg’s reenlistment, and considering some of his past misdeeds, Joan throws him out, and apparently ends their marriage.

Finally, flipping the theme of invasion and victimization a bit, Don, wracked with fever, is visited by Andrea, who is certain Don is still the man he once was and all but insists the two pick up where they left off. Fearing Megan’s discovery of the aggressive intruder, Don ushers her out the service entrance, and returns to bed. Later, Andrea wakes Don, and after a brief trip down memory lane, manages to get him into the sack. Later, Don’s guilt, compounded by Andrea’s insistence this not be a one-time thing, forces him to strangle her and haphazardly push her underneath the bed.

Of course, it’s all just a fever dream and, perhaps, a showing that Don Draper has finally killed off his urges – or at least succeeded in pushing them haphazardly under the bed.


Mad Men returns next Sunday with ‘Signal 30′ @10pm on AMC.

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. Kevin Yeoman, please get your facts straight before penning your report. First of all, the client that Don, Ken and Michael were pitching to was not a pantyhose company,it was a shoe company. Secondly, Peggy found Dawn crashing on Don’s couch not hers.

    • Pretty sure it was a pantyhose company ala the illustrator dude wearing them on his head and they were talking about them being visible or invisible, ‘you won’t know and neither will they’ Pretty sure they weren’t invisible shoes

    • You should really read more carefully before you criticize. The report clearly says that Peggy finds Dawn and it RESULTS in Dawn crashing on Peggy’s couch. Meaning later. I think the show has more important things to discuss than shoes and couches and the report gets that right.

  2. It was for Butler shoes (hence the Cinderella’s slipper references). Stan may have been just fooling around with the pantyhose or the client wanted the model to use transparent hose to not distract from the shoes – in 1966, colored and patterned hosiery were quite common to wear with the shorter skirts.

  3. i had a question about the note dawn left peggy. what was the last sentence of it? i couldn’t read the one word

    • It said: “Thank you for your hospitality. Sorry for putting you out.”

      I wondered if the purpose of the note was not only a means to say “thanks”, but also to make Peggy feel terrible for pausing a few beats the night before when she realized she was leaving her purse – fresh with $400 – in the same room Dawn would be left alone in.

      Can I just give a shout out to Joan for kicking Greg to the curb? I wanted to smack him each time he said “they need me over there.” Maybe your family needs you HERE more, genius.

      I thought the pitch Michael/Ken/Don gave was to Butler shoes. In the room they gave the pitch, there were shoes on display on the wall behind Michael just before he told the executives the dark Cinderella theme.

      • Well, since Joan is forcing him to take care of another man’s baby, I don’t know who to route for in this scenario. I don’t think he really “has a family” with Joan, being that she screwed around on him while he put is life on the line saving others during the war. I change my mind. She’s kind of a jerk and deserves what’s coming. She’s a smart cookie though. She’ll figure it out.

        • Why does everyone forget he basically raped her? Did he really put his life on the line? He’s not in combat

          • Back when they first met…

  4. Last night’s episode was wow. When I saw Don do what he did (no spoilers here), I knew it had to be a dream or fever induced hallucination, but it was still gasp-worthy.

    • that was a WTF! for me too!

  5. “Sorry for putting you out. -Dawn”

  6. Thanks a lot! I was unable to read it all, too, and have been searching the net for an hour!

  7. The thing is that if the person sitting on the cough was not black, Peggy would probably taken her purse to the bedroom without any hesitation. It’s just common sense to take your purse and wallet with you. It was Dawn sitting there that Peggy afraid she would offend the secretary, so she hesitated.

  8. Please. Joan’s husband is a pig and a rapist. I certainly have no sympathy for him. He keeps crapping on her, gives her no say in important decisions and it’s about time she kicked him to the curb, I couldn’t understand why she ever married the creep after the rape incident.
    The client was a shoe company. Michael didn’t “get it” when Don was angry about his big mouth. He just seems unable to “listen” to anyone, remember when Peggy was trying to get through to him? What is that, ADD?
    Don was trying to end “kill” his old behaviory of just following his urges, figuratively. He would like to turn over a new leaf? Be loyal to Megan and start over -a new way of life? Has he told her about his true identity yet?
    I want to see more of Sally, she is the best character on this program, what a brilliant little actress she is! She shines! Is this new Grandma going to set her up to popping pills? Whats up w/all that do you think?

    • Don did tell Megan all about him, before they got married I think. She referenced that already this season.

  9. What precisely does the “I’m sorry for putting you out” mean? Something like “Sorry for causing you trouble”?

    Hadn’t looked at it from the perspective of a centreal theme being victimization, but it’s an interesting thought.

  10. This episode was surely a shocker. I, for one, am glad that Joan kicked Greg out; he was a disrespectful pig. He used to beat her, talk her down, and he did rape her (at the office no less), all while being the crappiest surgeon alive. Also, I think that Don was trying to “kill” his urges and decide to be loyal and faithful to his wife.

  11. put out
    1. To extinguish: put out a fire.
    2. Nautical To leave, as a port or harbor; depart.
    3. To expel: put out a drunk.
    4. To publish: put out a weekly newsletter.
    a. To inconvenience: Did our early arrival put you out?
    b. To offend or irritate: I was put out by his attention to the television set.
    6. To make an effort.
    7. Baseball To retire a runner.
    8. Vulgar Slang To be sexually active. Used of a woman.