‘Machine Gun Preacher’ Review

Published 2 years ago by

Machine Gun Preacher Review Machine Gun Preacher Review

Screen Rant’s Ben Kendrick reviews Machine Gun Preacher

At first glance, for many moviegoers, Machine Gun Preacher might have sounded like some obscure graphic novel adaptation – especially considering the film stars kick-butt action man Gerard Butler. That said, for anyone unfamiliar with the real-life name Sam Childers, or the numerous non-profit organizations he’s founded, the story of Machine Gun Preacher is wrought with just as much danger and human drama as the pages of a superhero comic book.

That said, while Sam Childers and the story captured in his book, Another Man’s War are no doubt larger-than-life, that doesn’t automatically mean that Machine Gun Preacher is going to be a worthwhile film adaptation. Is director Marc Forster’s (Monster’s Ball, The Kite Runner) “based on a true story” movie a compelling and inspiring representation of Childers’ experiences – or an over-stuffed biopic that gets lost in the twist and turns of real life?

Unfortunately, while Machine Gun Preacher definitely has a lot going for it – the film also routinely falls short of finding a good balance between the development of Childers’ worldview and on-the-nose dramatic beats that attempt to “explain” key moments in his evolution. The real life Childers’ story takes some sharp turns, and subsequently, the movie has to cover a myriad of events in a short period of time. As a result, Machine Gun Preacher is a pretty jumbled and drawn-out film that focuses on a series of important snapshots in Childers’ life, instead of telling a concise, focused, and thoroughly developed throughline of the overarching story.

Machine Gun Preacher Michelle Monaghan Gerard Butler Machine Gun Preacher Review

Michelle Monaghan, Madeline Carroll, and Gerard Butler in 'Machine Gun Preacher'

The Hollywood version of Childers depicts a reckless and hate-filled ex-con and drug addict who, upon his release, continues his destructive downward spiral – until a rock bottom moment causes Childers to reject his prior life and embrace the values of the Christian church. While on a construction trip in North Africa (to build a mission church), Childers is exposed to the horrors of the Second Sudanese Civil War – specifically the large-scale murders and abductions of children. Upon returning home, Childers embarks on what becomes a life-long project: to rescue and protect children in warring nations. It’s a journey that rocks the foundation of his faith and threatens the stability of his home life – as well as bringing Childers face to face with the terrors of war-torn Sudan: assassination attempts, ruthless mercenaries, and child soldiers (among others).

The movie covers a lot of ground (about ten years in fictional time) that actually accounts for about thirty years of Childers’ actual life. As a result, Machine Gun Preacher takes a lot of liberties in an attempt to streamline the narrative – omitting Childers’ son entirely from the story as well as combining a number of people into single composites such as Childers’ “best friend” Donnie (played by Michael Shannon). However, despite attempts at tightening the story, the film is still a bloated and bumpy experience – with nearly every scene forcing a not-so-subtle story beat onto moviegoers.

As a result, each step in Childers’ evolution from drug-dealing biker to an impassioned “freedom fighter” appears to happen in a flash: his conversion to Christianity (which actually took years) practically occurs overnight and his growing frustration with American consumer culture (juxtaposed with the needs of the Sudanese children) comes to a head at a posh dinner party. It’s not that the scenes themselves aren’t interesting – it’s just that throughout the film many of these moments lack much buildup, as if each one is supposed to communicate a larger moral or act as a galvanizing experience to propel Childers forward. There are very few scenes that simply allow the audience to absorb what is happening – without throttling the story forward to the next “defining” set piece.

Machine Gun Preacher Gerard Butler Machine Gun Preacher Review

Gerard Butler as Sam Childers

That said, a lot these moments are still powerful – even if they don’t come together to form a competent overarching story. Butler delivers a number of especially engrossing moments as Childers – and successfully transitions the man from a despicable and disappointing human being to someone the audience will want to root for, even when his actions challenge preconceived ideas of a “hero.” The supporting cast, which includes Michelle Monaghan as Lynn Childers, also rises to the occasion – even if the narrative sometimes bungles their contributions.

Machine Gun Preacher offers an interesting set of juxtapositions, i.e. a God-loving guy kills mercenaries to free children and becomes so overwhelmed by the horror around him that he loses faith in humanity and God; however, only some of the scenes are successfully able to make sense of the underlying thematic material. Surprisingly, for a movie about the power of human will in combination with faith, some of the more religious elements come across as caricature, not individuated examples of Christian communities. This cliched portrayal of Christianity is most noticeable when Butler has to deliver a lot of “preachy” dialogue.

Side note: The film is pretty violent (earning the biopic an R-rating) and featuring a number of graphic moments that will not no doubt be challenging for some moviegoers. The Machine Gun Preacher tone is actually pretty fitting, considering the have-gun-will-travel attitude of Childers, but audience members who are expecting a more straightforward story about faith-in-action might be overwhelmed – and will be confronted several times by especially disturbing scenes.

There’s no doubt Sam Childers is an intriguing lens through which to view the horrors of Joseph Kony and the LRA’s campaign in Sudan but some audiences are no doubt going to find that despite a competent leading man, Machine Gun Preacher tackles way too much material to present a cohesive onscreen experience. Anyone who is especially interested in the source story will probably find Machine Gun Preacher to be worth the price of admission, but not a standout experience. The film will definitely help raise awareness for Childers’ continuing work around the world but many moviegoers may want to just visit MachineGunPreacher.org instead – and then wait for Childers’ upcoming, and hopefully superior, documentary.

If you’re still on the fence about Machine Gun Preacher, check out the trailer below:

-

[poll id="199"]

-

Follow me on Twitter @benkendrick - and let us know what you thought of the film below.

Machine Gun Preacher is now in theaters.

Our Rating:

3 out of 5
(Good)

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:
TAGS: machine gun preacher

9 Comments

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

  1. This movie is not in any theater around 75 miles around me. That blows

  2. Distribution issues here in New York too.

    The film is playing in only one theater in Manhattan
    which is most unusual for a new “major” release.
    Great review of what to expect, Ben, and
    I do intend to catch this somehow.

  3. So is this about a guy spreading word to African people who have no idea what Christianity is? If so why would he do that? If they are ignorant about the religion then they are guaranteed to go to heaven but if he tells them about it then there is a chance they will go to hell. Seems bit of odd thing to go to great lengths to do.

    • That’s not actually how Christianity works. Both because Christianity doesn’t necessarily care why you don’t believe in Jesus. Also, many Christians feel obligated to spread the “good word”, because it brings joy to their day to day life.

      Or something like that. Sunday School was many years ago.

      As far as the movie.. looks like an interesting story. The review didn’t seem very positive for a 3-star rating though. I may have to check it out.. I usually enjoy this sort of thing.

    • This movie is not really trying to convey a strong religious message but a more powerful message of what’s really going on in other part of the world which this world has always ignored it.

      It still depends on how you look at this movie. I think it shows and explains our duty to help those people and bring them out of these problems without looking at out religion.

  4. hm. sounds interesting…might check this one out.

  5. It sounds worth a watch. >.> I’m highly intrigued. I like Butler and it’s been a while since I’ve seen a decent movie portray Christians in a positive light. I’m not counting movies made by Christians for Christians like “Fireproof.” I liked Fireproof, but I think it’s just because I’m a Christian. :P

  6. Quite a great movie! See our review too please: http://newmoviesreviewed.wordpress.com/2012/05/04/machine-gun-preacher/

  7. I wanted to compose you this very little note
    just to say thanks a lot again on your magnificent opinions
    you’ve discussed above. This is unbelievably generous of people like you to supply without restraint all many of us would’ve offered for an e book to get some
    cash for themselves, most importantly since you could possibly
    have tried it if you considered necessary. These
    tips also worked as the easy way to be certain that other
    people have a similar desire really like my own to know the truth more and more
    concerning this condition. I’m sure there are thousands of more fun instances up front for individuals that view your website.

Be Social, Follow Us!!