Recent Related Items:

40 Comments


Psyko says:

“As for the complaint about Mike and Sarah having a separate oxygen supply and not suffocating when the fire does, they still could if they were in the vacuum chamber when their separate supply ran out. I don’t see a huge plot hole there.”

The trouble here is that Billy (funny how that was his name in BSG too) specifically notes that the heroes can’t breath without air when they come up with the idea of putting them in the vacuum camber.

Charles Graiman: “We’ll bring them into the tunnel. We’ll shut the emergency doors; suck out all the air. Without oxygen, the fire can’t breathe.”

Billy Morgan: “Without oxygen, they can’t breathe either.”

You can argue that Billy wasn’t talking about the oxygen running out due to a vacuum, but it’d be a huge stretch.

And, as for the special abilities, I’m cool with them. I don’t mind the VTOL and all that jazz. I just wish they didn’t make the CG so painful to watch.

Ninja31 says:

Vic,

That was a very fair review of the show, I have a friend who is on that show and watched it to support’em and had similiar thoughts. The cast was upgraded from the pilot and that was nice to see, it was also good to see a more serious side of the lead instead of the one liners from the pilot. I really hope the best for this show and it would appear as if they have the right pieces in place to make it a while. If they make the (w)right changes!

Thanks for at least being fair Vic.

FlameStrike says:

Fair point, Psyko. I don’t really remember who said what and when.

In any case, it may all come down to how much attention Billy was paying to the conversation and the events around him.

@Ninja31

Thanks, although you should see some of my reviews when I really tear into something, lol. :-P

Vic

After watching the premiere, no wonder they released it a week early on the internet, then replayed it within a few days over on The Sci-Fi Channel.

Eesh. I don’t think you’re too far off on this one Vic!

Lana says:

This show totally sucks!!! Bad plots, terrible acting, unbelievably corny lines, awful music…the worst show in history. I can’t believe people actually paid money for this remake. It is nothing like the original…can’t compare at all!!!

John "Kahless" Taylor says:

Well, I actually liked last night’s episode. I thought the plot was very similar to the Data and Lore plot from Star Trek: Next Generation. Can’t wait to see KAR in action.

arnhem yannick says:

the serie is wonderfull me and family like it I’m enjoying it everyweek is the serie going to contuned wer are loking at it from Suriname I small country with mix culture

Page 2 of 2«12
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.