Actually, my first title for this was going to be “Is Smallville Swirling In The Toilet?”, but I thought that might be a bit much.
If you read this site regularly, you’ll know that I’m actually quite a fan of Smallville. But when I like something I tend to hold it to a high standard. Granted, this isn’t high brow entertainment, but it has been fun to watch over the years as Clark has matured from a geeky high school student to a man of responsibility. Also great has been seeing the slide into darkness of Lex Luthor.
However one thing that really drives me nuts is when a TV series hangs on too long. This was the case with the most excellent Stargate SG-1, which should have ended when Richard Dean Anderson left the show and before the wretched Ori storyline began.
Now Smallville is entering “should’ve quit while they were ahead” territory.
| |
The last couple of episodes have been probably the worst of the entire series.
First we had “Siren”, a couple of weeks ago. The episode introduced the Black Canary, a DC universe super-heroine who in the comics is romantically involved with Green Arrow. In the opening minutes of the show, it was so incredibly cheesy that I thought it was some sort of wierd parody of the show or strange dream sequence.
I kid you not.
When the episode just kept going from there, I was stunned. It was the most cornball thing I’d seen in a long time, complete with cringe-inducing dialog. The romantic exchanges between Lois and Oliver Queen were also really awful.
It was actually painful to sit through and felt like it lasted about 3 hours to me. Even my daughter who loves superhero-related stuff thought it was terrible.
And then last week we had the episode titled “Fracture,” where Lex tracks down amnesia-ridden Kara, Clark’s Kryptonian cousin, and while trying to bring her back to Metropolis suffers a gunshot wound right between the eyes – and survives!
I almost turned it off when they cut to the hospital room and said he was in a coma. A gunshot to the forehead, dead straight on, and he’s just in a coma.
Wow.
Anyway, Clark had to use experimental technology to get inside Lex’s subconscious in order to find out where Kara and Lois are being held in Detroit. He discovers a little boy in there who is the final remnant of what good is left in Lex.
In the end Chloe once again manifests her super-duper lifesaving powers to heal Lex completely.
They’ve brought in too many Kryptonians, Clark still can’t fly, Lana has been turned into this dark, twisted character and they gave Chloe super-powers so I suppose she’d be more relevant to the show.
If the next couple of episodes don’t improve, things are going to get really bad. And on top of all this, they’re planning on continuing the show with an eighth season despite the fact that Michael Rosenbaum (who plays Lex) is leaving the show and the only actor committed to returning at this point is Tom Welling (Clark).
I always bring up the TV series Seinfeld as an example of a show that bit the bullet and quit while it was at the peak of it’s popularity. Sure, it’s tough, but now it will always be remembered as a great show and not one that slid into mediocrity towards the end.
CW, I know you’re hurting for ratings and a hit show, but if this is any indication, season 8 of Smallville is going to be horrifically awful.
Quit, while you still can.




39 Comments
Vic, Black Canary is the only black character in smallville for years. (wink)
Rosenbaum portrays the only Lex Luthor I’ve ever taken seriously. With the progression of his character, I completely expected the Inner Lex to nearly do away with his Inner Child in that episode. Instead of seeing further darkness fall on the guy who just murdered his clone-brother, we see a reason for Clark to use “Inner Kid Gloves” on his enemy.
Not sure about “the one place I can hide” inner child memory.
I do hope the Kryptonian that Brainiac apparently took out, sheds light on the cave drawings from earlier seasons.
Unfortunately I missed last week’s episode due to cable issues, but I don’t think the show has been THAT bad, Vic. Even mediocre Smallville is better than 95% of the dreck that is on TV right now. Go on and tell me you would rather watch “American Idol,” “The Next Supermodel”, “Survivor”, “American Gladiators”, “CSI: Wherever”, or any of the endless realitycr*p that is cluttering the airwaves. NO thanks, I will take Smallville, even with it’s current flaws.
Didn’t they do thise before wher a girl was working at the daily planet but then it turns out she was a superhero or somthing. I am a big fan of the show I even bought all the DVD’s but the way thise show is coing I hope that at least we get a good series finaly.
Thanks for posting this. I needed to be cheered up. Hearing that a show I have hated since before it premiered is well on its way to becoming a laughing stock made my day. Seeing it live past the days when people considered it good might actually be better than it being canceled, but I’m not sure.
The sad thing is…Smallville is so far down that I would almost rather watch reality television.
What could have been a great, 21st-century take on the Superman mythos…is degenerating into bad Gossip Girl-esque shenanigans. Leaps in logic, slightly off-kilter plotting…and more importantly, Clark is still on the frickin’ farm.
I’m hoping that there is no season 8…but I sincerely doubt it.
@endri
You’re referring to the episode Vengeance, with the character of Andrea Rojas.
Andy,
I’m sorry but that’s no way to look at things. I don’t compare TV shows and movies to the worst out there, I compare them to the best.
Vic
The way I look at it Vic, is that if you’re TOO critical of things, then eventually EVERYTHING is going to be bad. Now I am not saying you do that, quite the contrary. For the short time that I have been here, I have admired your approach to your reviews. I tend to agree with MOST of your opinions (and a review really is nothing more than that, right?), but I think when there is SUCH awful programming out there as all the reality dreck, I will cut Smallville a break because it’s been so good for so long. I’d much rather have the current incarnation of Smallville than ANOTHER “Biggest Loser” or “Gilmore Girls.” I just hope they show more shots of Lois in a bikini!
I’m considering switching my DVR to record ABC’s “enhanced” LOST episodes, in the same time slot.
dont forget they ripped off the movie “the cell” pretty bad in that last episode
Andy, I continue to disagree. Check out the Mike Judge film Idiocracy for an idea of what would happen if we keep “settling.” I thought it was hysterical.
Vic
Since I’ve been a fan of the show from the very beginning I seriously doubt that smallville has gone downhill.Every tv show has its little flaws, but each year smallville tends to get better and better.Sure, it’s been seven years but my opinion is that smallville is still terific.Just because smallville doesn’t take the credit it deserves that doesn’t mean that it is worse than other more acclaimed shows.
Helen,
Are you in Europe? If so you haven’t seen season 7 yet (is that right?) and are basing your statement on the show up to season 6, which I think was the best season for the series.
Having said that, I welcome your opinion, of course!
Vic
Vic,
Yes I am from Europe and I live in Greece. But I’ve seen all the episodes of season seven so far, because i have downloaded them from the internet.I think that apart from the supergirl arc, smallville is highly enjoyable, ESPECIALLY in the last three episodes!(persona, siren,fracture)!But of course,I respect your opinion!
Well thanks for visiting from Greece!
Vic
Good to see that I’m not the only European Screen Ranter!!
Niall
Same Here.
As a Superman purist,I dislike this show. However I do like Tom Welling and hope he plays Superman in the JLA film….probably won’t happen though.
This show was a bad idea from the start,IMO. No flights or costume…no secret identity,it’s a Superman show without Superman,IMO. I personally can’t wait till it’s off the air.
Maybe then we’ll get a descent superhero show…..
I can’t believe what they did to Black Canary! She really looks skanky. Sheesh….
Well I gotta say Vic I agree with you on certain things like the fact that there’s too many kryptonians in the show and the fact that Clark doesn’t fly yet and everyone who seems to get powers can fly right away for the most part. BUT I still now and always will love the show.
I have collected every season on dvd over the years. And I will eventually have every season up to 8. I will never get tired of this show!!
Also Kel this isn’t really a superman show. He wasn’t superman then. He was just a farm boy Clark Kent. Superman developed after he had left smallville and before he started at the Daily Planet. So I disagree with you on that part.
However I do belive that he should have been flying be now on a constant basis. Cause in the movie he learned in high school or shortly after high school. But needless to say despite all those details I still love the show
and I can’t wait for season 8 and the rest of this season. This show is so fantastic.
Jessica,I have to agree with you. Smallville really ISN’T a Superman show cuz Superman is pretty much non existant in it. It’s not even accurate with the comix,Clark didn’t become Superman until AFTER he left Smallville, he also DIDN’T meet Braniac,Luthor,Lois,Jimmy,Perry,work at the Planet,etc until he was SUPERMAN and had left Smallville to live in Metropolis. And he certainly didn’t help form a premature JLA when he lived in Smallville. Matter of fact, the whole show is premature as far as Superman is concerned.
And of course he should be flying!
But that’s the thing about Smallville,anything iconic about Superman (flying,costume,secret identity,etc) is FORSAKEN. As I said,it’s Superman without Superman. They don’t even have intentions of having actual Superman (costume,cape,etc) EVER on the show! So what we have now on the show is pretty much as close to the Superman that we know and love as the show’s gonna get.
It’s just another outlet that WB uses to crap on Superman,guys. They screwed his continuity up in comix and made him a deadbeat,out-of-wedlock dad (rape?????) in Superman Returns and they continue to crap Superman up weekly with their alternative version of him in Smallville. Over the past decade,outside of animation,WB has done nothing good for Superman,IMO.
OFF SUBJECT: Jon Peters should be fired!! That or dragged into the street and shot.
Why do all people want smallville to follow the superman mythos according to the comics and the movies?Smallville has definitely created its own universe and is not about superman, but about Clark Kent. THe differnce is that in the comics, suprman is the hero,and Clark Kent more just like a disguise. But this is not the case here. It’s all about Clark. We shouldn’t stick to the comics. And by the way, the performances from the actors are great!
QUOTE FROM HELENFROMGREECE: “We shouldn’t stick to the comics.”
Umm….why? They’re COMIC book characters! Everything that we know about ANY of them came from a COMIC! Why in the hell would and should we forsake the source material?
Smallville having its own universe and being “Ultimate” Superman is fine,just don’t expect longtime Superman or comix fans to like it for obvious reasons.
“THe differnce is that in the comics, suprman is the hero,and Clark Kent more just like a disguise.”
That is true in SOME versions,in the comix it often depends on who is writing him. For instance,the John Byrne version (the best and my fave) has it so Metropolis Clark and Superman are more facades and Smallville Clark is the real person. Superman is just something he does,in this version Clark is clearly the more dominant persona,and although both Superman AND Clark are one and the same,it isn’t like when he’s Clark his morals and ideals suddenly change,he just downplays his abilities and pretends to be human. Of course there are other versions of Superman that have Superman/Kal El being the dominant persona and Clark as just something Superman does,which,IMO,doesn’t really make sense,as Clark was raised here on earth and assumed he was human like us until his teens when he learned about his homeworld which is long dead,so why he would then suddenly get a mentality that’s like “well…I’m not Clark anymore,I have to be and think like an alien now” and just forget his being raised as a human being,as a Kansas “born” Kent,makse no sense to me. It should always be CLARK from Smallville,who doesn’t have to pretend to be “normal” or wear a costume and be on patrol all the time,that is the “real” person. Smallville Clark is the Clark who can be…er…for lack of a better word “honest” about everything and who he is. He doesn’t have to keep secrets there so it makes sense to me that THAT Clark is the “real” person.
Shoot….I just went on a rambling rant again…

Point being,that Superman in the comix isn’t ALWAYS written as Clark being a facade and that he IS written as Clark being the “real” person and Superman just being something he does,depending on the writer.
“And by the way, the performances from the actors are great!”
I agree. I think Welling is great and so are Rosenbaum and Durance. I also liked Brandon Routh as Superman,I hope he gets a chance to play him again cuz he was the best thing about Superman Returns.
Kel, I think you need to get out more often.
It’s a STORY-FICTION! It’s not like they’re George W. trying to re-write the Constitution! They’re taking the basic premise of Superman and exploring it. I have no problem with that, in fact I really enjoy Smallville. The only thing that gets me is that Clark should be FLYING already!!!
Ha! LOL,Andy. I get out plenty…. .:-D
I’m just a bit of a Superman purist,so Smallville annoys me a bit.
I don’t usually don’t like reinventions of things,especially my fave comic book characters.
But kudos to you if you like it.
And I don’t think Dubya realizes there’s a Constitution….
I like the show, and although they aren’t connecting as much to the comics as some fans would like, they’re just trying to make it their own at the same time. Give them a break.
The Black Canary did look a little skanky, though.
Kel: We actually did see a cape–the movie starlett who filmed in Smallville gave one to him as a token of gratitude (I know, it’s not the real cape from his baby blanket or whatever).
Two questions.
The first season had a few scenes of Clark floating above his bed. As soon as he awoke, he would fall onto the bed. Was this a precursor to flying, or was this some Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex stuff at work
The opening montage has Jimmy Olsen lunging for a falling kryptonite crystal. Can anyone recap for me what this scene was from–or has it aired yet? (I don’t need details, just the basic.)
Ahhh,but a cape non the less,eh,Jim?
That’s interesting,bud.
And yeah,that’s one prostitutey lookin’ BC. Blehh……
What was wrong with her comix look anyway?
Thanks KEL you totally took the words right off my keyboard on this post.
^
Bad dirrection (IMO), also too OC for me, and by the way they don’t call it the OC in Orange county. (The buffy/OC plague must be stopped!).
Kel,
(And yes, I hope the creators change their mind and make Clark fly because I’ve been waiting this for years!!!)
I understand why you want smallville to follow the comics, since you read them. But the truth is, that I didn’t got hooked on Smallville only because of the superman mythos,but also because of the relationships, the plot, the actors and the great quality of the show.!
Vic,
That alright, I know you try hard. Nobody is right all the time. You keep it pretty close, but I understand. We will keep you in our prayers while you recover from this laps in judgment.
Vic keep it rockin, keep it straight, and keep it pumpin. We love you out here, so stay off my Smallville. lol
Smitty, you’re funny.
But if a show loses it, it loses it. Even if a Star Trek show stinks I’ll say so, and I’m a huge Trek fan.
Best,
Vic
Vic,
We will see, I hope your are wrong. It seems everything is swirling after the crazy writer’s strike. I hope they can pull back off of this nose dive some seem to be seeing. Even my my Fav Jericho seems to be off target, so I have no clue what the future holds for our favorite shows.
Thank you for being able to appreciate mt humor. Outside of Myspace I spend most of my time here. Thank you for all of the time you spend to help keeping nerds like me well informed.
Smitty
Kyle,
The Black Canary has always looked like a “street walker” or a little skanky as you put it. That has been gone over and joked about many times in the comics. So no true issue there.
Smitty,
The Black Canary in the comix may have had SLIGHT hookerish overtones,namely because of the fishnet stockings but she NEVER looked like a damn skank like she does here in Coolville. She doesn’t even look hot….can you say el dyke-o much?
BC in the comix,specifically in the Silver Age stories,always looked like a superhero even with the fishnets. She had bucaneer high heeled boots with fishnet/gray pants,black shirt and blue over jacket. She looked hot. She looks best in the JLU cartoon,IMO,cuz the fishnets (dumb idea) are non existant because they didn’t translate well into animation. No one’d mistake her as a ho. Now currently she looks a bit more “street walker-ish” in the comix but it isn’t completely overboard like here in Smallville. Short hair with big dude burns and painted mask (WTF???? BC doesn’t wear a mask!!!),WB has dropped the ball AGAIN in translating another classic comix character to TV (they do it with films too,mostly because of Jon Peters,IMO. See here:http://singerssupermansucks.blogspot.com/2007/12/jon-peters-is-class-act.html).
http://singerssupermansucks.blogspot.com/2007/12/jon-peters-is-class-act.html
Sorry,the link wasn’t “linkable” for some reason.
Stargate SG-1 shouldn’t have just ended after RDA left. The Ori arc was needed to hopefully bring further trust from the ascended Atlantians in the story line. The execution of it, however, was not up to par. Season 10 seemed abbreviated because they knew it was the last season.
In any case, Smallville jumped the shark with me 2 seasons ago because it is a-number one the most stretched and milked and bilked storyline in the history of TV serials. They needed to have had Clark become more like Superman by now and also finally make some decisions about his future long ago. I don’t care about the exact comparison to the comics, thats just silly. There are many different re-tellings of the Superman story. However Smallville just doesn’t know when to quit and arc and move on with some real closure, results, or upgrades in Clarks’ abilities. I still watch it “just in case” but I realize that is what they have been banking on for at least 2 seasons because they don’t have anything else.
Vic
I agree with you about smallville going beyond the stopping point. It has gotten harder for me to even watch the show because the plots have become so far fetched that its downright stupid! Now dont get me wrong, initally the show was a hit with me and my children, but I believe that they have left the point where the show was simple to follow and led it down a road that is winding and possibly leading to a dead end! I mean veritas! what the heck is that all about, now we have a group of people waiting on supermans arrival! that really changes the story line, and almost makes it into a Christ like figure, u know the wise men awaiting the messiah!
If CW and the new producers of smallville are smart they will run two more seasons( 9 & 10). Tom Welling should be given one heck of new contract besides letting him direct more episodes. Smallville as well as tom welling have a HUGE fan base – so CW make a smart move and keep tom welling for two more seasons!!!
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!