Comments on: Heroes’ Sylar To Play Spock? http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/ TV and Movie News, Reviews & Trailers Sat, 26 May 2012 04:26:28 +0000 hourly 1 By: Melly http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5054 Melly Wed, 19 Dec 2007 14:30:40 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5054 Oh! I apologise for misunderstanding you. I guess that's how certain actors stick in our memories, for example, in a few years time when we see Masi Oka in a leading film, to us he'll still be the loveable man who can bend time and space. I see what you mean now. Sorry! Oh! I apologise for misunderstanding you. I guess that’s how certain actors stick in our memories, for example, in a few years time when we see Masi Oka in a leading film, to us he’ll still be the loveable man who can bend time and space. I see what you mean now. Sorry!

]]> By: Philip Harewood http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5053 Philip Harewood Wed, 19 Dec 2007 11:42:26 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5053 I'm truly sorry that you seem to misunderstand me. It's because I think Zachary Quinto is an excellent actor he to me will be Sylar. Whenever I've seen him on the screen be it interviews or whatever, be it with or without Vulcan ears, he is Sylar. I really don't see myself as being negative, I have never been that, maybe just too much into Heroes. I don't see Zachary Quinto as a dissapointment, I see casting him as Spock as a dissapointment. What may seem unusual is that of the many people I know that have followed Heroes and also love Star Trek are of the same opinion. I’m truly sorry that you seem to misunderstand me. It’s because I think Zachary Quinto is an excellent actor he to me will be Sylar. Whenever I’ve seen him on the screen be it interviews or whatever, be it with or without Vulcan ears, he is Sylar. I really don’t see myself as being negative, I have never been that, maybe just too much into Heroes. I don’t see Zachary Quinto as a dissapointment, I see casting him as Spock as a dissapointment. What may seem unusual is that of the many people I know that have followed Heroes and also love Star Trek are of the same opinion.

]]> By: Melly http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5052 Melly Tue, 18 Dec 2007 20:03:29 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5052 But Zachary Quinto is an excellent actor; therefore able to adapt to the role of Spock? Honestly, don't be critical - you never know, Zachary will most likely be excellent as Spock - but if you continue to see him through your own, somewhat negative opinion, I guess you'll still see him as dissapointing. But Zachary Quinto is an excellent actor; therefore able to adapt to the role of Spock? Honestly, don’t be critical – you never know, Zachary will most likely be excellent as Spock – but if you continue to see him through your own, somewhat negative opinion, I guess you’ll still see him as dissapointing.

]]> By: Philip Harewood http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5051 Philip Harewood Tue, 18 Dec 2007 18:57:21 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5051 I am 59 years old and a long time fan of Star Trek. When Star Trek Started I was just coming out of high school so I watched it from the beginning. As a long time fan I really wanted to see a movie beyond Voyager. I was hoping for some type of merge with characters from Voyager and TNG. Well beyond that disappointment there is a greater disappointment for me. How could Abrams cast someone as creepy and villainous as Sylar to play our beloved Spock. Zachary Quinto is obviously great as Sylar which makes him the worst choice for Spock. After 40 years of watching Star Trek I may not be able to watch this one. I am 59 years old and a long time fan of Star Trek. When Star Trek Started I was just coming out of high school so I watched it from the beginning. As a long time fan I really wanted to see a movie beyond Voyager. I was hoping for some type of merge with characters from Voyager and TNG. Well beyond that disappointment there is a greater disappointment for me. How could Abrams cast someone as creepy and villainous as Sylar to play our beloved Spock. Zachary Quinto is obviously great as Sylar which makes him the worst choice for Spock. After 40 years of watching Star Trek I may not be able to watch this one.

]]> By: melly http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5050 melly Sat, 03 Nov 2007 21:56:38 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5050 I think Sylar is creepy anyhoo. I think Sylar is creepy anyhoo.

]]> By: Jae Senn http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5049 Jae Senn Thu, 26 Jul 2007 18:09:38 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5049 Maybe Nimoy might cameo as Sarek? Damon as Kirk = dumb idea. Shatner was smooth and flirtatious in TOS. Damon will have a hard time matching that. Maybe Nimoy might cameo as Sarek?

Damon as Kirk = dumb idea. Shatner was smooth and flirtatious in TOS. Damon will have a hard time matching that.

]]> By: Shane http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5048 Shane Wed, 25 Jul 2007 18:47:17 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5048 Kane, I totally agree with your take on growing up with Star Trek, it just never grabbed me. Okay, Wrath of Kahn was actually pretty good, but the rest I could take or leave. I hope JJ does well with this, I found Mission Impossible 3 to be blah. I have always found Star Wars more enjoyable and even though I am not a trekkie, I hope their prequel is a lot better than my Star Wars ones. Kane,
I totally agree with your take on growing up with Star Trek, it just never grabbed me. Okay, Wrath of Kahn was actually pretty good, but the rest I could take or leave. I hope JJ does well with this, I found Mission Impossible 3 to be blah. I have always found Star Wars more enjoyable and even though I am not a trekkie, I hope their prequel is a lot better than my Star Wars ones.

]]> By: Kane http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5047 Kane Wed, 25 Jul 2007 02:18:29 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5047 Pretty sure he's not... though the rumour had been that William Shatner gave his blessing for Damon to take on the role. Me? I've never been much of a Matt Damon fan. I find him kinda boring and he seems to just play Matt Damon in everything he does. Still... 'The Bourne Ultimatim' looks pretty cool. Pretty sure he’s not… though the rumour had been that William Shatner gave his blessing for Damon to take on the role.

Me? I’ve never been much of a Matt Damon fan. I find him kinda boring and he seems to just play Matt Damon in everything he does.

Still… ‘The Bourne Ultimatim’ looks pretty cool.

]]> By: Gary http://screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-kane-852/comment-page-1/#comment-5046 Gary Wed, 25 Jul 2007 02:11:09 +0000 http://dev2.screenrant.com/heroes-sylar-to-play-spock-852/#comment-5046 is damon the only one rumored for kirk? Is damon a lock? is damon the only one rumored for kirk?
Is damon a lock?

]]>