‘Gold Rush: Alaska’ Season 3 vs ‘Jungle Gold’ – Which One is Better?

Published 1 year ago by

gold rush jungle gold Gold Rush: Alaska Season 3 vs Jungle Gold   Which One is Better?

After spending three years with the Hoffman clan in the great northern tundra, Discovery is throwing a tropical twist in with their new series Jungle Gold, where the familiar rough Alaskan terrain of Gold Rush: Alaska is replaced with the dangerous African jungle. Both have the same goal. But which one do you think is better?

Todd Hoffman and his (now) divided crew kicked off television’s proverbial gold rush after heading to Alaska as amateur gold miners attempting to bring home money to provide for their families. Though this element has largely been passed over as of recent – likely because the cast is part of one of cable’s strongest series – some additional storylines have been included to help fill the series out.

Parker Schnabel has, for all intents and purposes, taken over where the Hoffman’s family storyline began. No longer a series about just gold mining, Gold Rush: Alaska began to show one of reality television’s most earnest coming-of-age stories, showing the best and worst of adolescent enthusiasm and conviction. Additionally, “Dakota” Fred helps keep track of things back at the original claim. Though short in story, there’s still more to Fred than the villainous character he (sometimes) portrays. Maybe.

But now, three years after the series began, Jungle Gold comes into the picture, serving as a supplemental series to help strengthen Discovery’s hold on Friday night. Jungle Gold tells the same tale that Gold Rush: Alaska began with (see above), but this time they’re taking the mining to the dangerous African jungle, where tribal chiefs are the only ones able to keep the peace and avoid bloodshed.

gold rush season 3 jack Gold Rush: Alaska Season 3 vs Jungle Gold   Which One is Better?

Instead of the rustic touch of Hoffman and Schnabel, Jungle Gold has Scott Lomu and George Wright VI, two former-millionaire realtors now struggling to pay the bills. Lomu and Wright may have a sharper plan with their gold aspirations than the Hoffmans initially had, but their location is 10x as dangerous, and not exactly full of gold.

Lomu and Wright pretty much have the same financial goals as the Hoffmans, except that Lomu and Wright will have to remove almost all of the gold in their claim to reach that mark – while the Hoffman’s limits appear to only be their ability to run as much dirt as possible. Even if the stories may be similar, Jungle Gold is much more of a suspenseful watch, and not just because of the gold mining.

jungle gold premiere Gold Rush: Alaska Season 3 vs Jungle Gold   Which One is Better?

In Gold Rush: Alaska, stray bears and broken equipment are generally the only dangers we’re used to see associated with the mining trade. Now thanks to Jungle Gold, those preconceived notions of flannelled miners are replaced with black market gold buys, armed miners, tribal chiefs and potential bloodshed. And that’s just in the first episode.

Comparing Gold Rush: Alaska and Jungle Gold really isn’t fair as they both present a different point of view in the world of mining, even if that point of view is of an amateur. Still, it’s almost impossible to say that Jungle Gold isn’t a more instinctively compelling series, no matter how strong the cast stories of Gold Rush: Alaska may be.

If anything, story may be where Jungle Gold is lacking most. Everyone can relate to the notion of wanting to provide for your family, and Jungle Gold does a good job of conveying that element. However, the former-millionaire backstory and quick pace in which Lomu and Wright are able to progress in the goals, from small (sending money home) to large (finding a new claim), weakens those emotional ties, relying on the dangerous elements of the African jungle to help fuel its story.

But who’s to say which is better? Viewers are. So we leave the question up to you: Which do you think is better? Gold Rush: Alaska or Jungle Gold.

[poll id="429"]

-

Gold Rush: Alaska season 3 airs Fridays @9pm on Discovery

Jungle Gold airs Fridays @10pm on Discovery

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:
TAGS: gold rush

159 Comments

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

  1. I watched every episode of Jungle Gold and probably would not watch a second season if there is one. Scott and George must both suffer from Attention Deficit Disorder! They lose their first claim to the Chinese then cut a deal on another claim but never actually do any serious work. They quickly lose interest because its not going to be easy (wasting big money on equipment) so they try making deals with other claim owners. At one point they invest in rock crushers but again the work is too hard so they abandon that idea (more money wasted) and try for even richer ground which is out of their league and budget. If they had stayed on their second claim and rolled up their sleeves I think their fortunes would have improved.

  2. I started watching Gold Rush last year during season 2 and have been hooked ever since. The story of everyday normal guys taking a chance and working hard to make some money mining for gold. It is kinda crazy but that is what the show is about. The fans of this show value the dedication, ingenuity, and toughness on display each week. The documentary production is done extremely well and it makes the viewer feel as if they are there with the problems, the tough decisions, and the victories. Since fans have watched these crews for 3 years we have come to some conclusions based on their actions. Some of these conclusions are not positive but they are accurate. First let’s start with Parker. To begin with you hate this little prick, but the more you watch and learn of his family and his background, the more we see how he acts with his crew, the more we want to like the kid. Second we get to the Dakota boys. Now things started out rocky when Fred decided to buy the claim that he worked during the first season with the Hoffman crew. This was pretty brash but Fred doesn’t really care what you think. It now seems that he was right to distance himself from the Hoffman crew in order to actually make some money for himself. He is the definition of a hard worker and he’s not afraid to go at it alone. His practicality is exhibited in almost every episode through fixing a broken part and just finding a way to get it done. Now to the Hoffman crew. There is the dad Hoffman and Todd Hoffman who are the leaders, for some unknown reason, of the crew. There seems to be better qualified members of the crew but we will get to that shortly. So these two Hoffman guys, do they perform a lot of the work, do they have more knowledge of gold mining, do they take the risky tough tasks as an example to the rest of the crew what a good leader should be. The answer to all of these questions is no. Todd, the head of the operation, spends essentially all of his time on the radio telling the others what to do, this season he also liked to boast that his crew was superior to the other half of the team. He creates division when it is unnecessary. He also loves to pull rank on his underlings when he chooses. When there is a very dangerous job, the operator’s life is at risk, does not step up and do it himself, no he yells through the radio to get it done and he doesn’t care if the truck falls over the cliff with the operator inside. He wears a 316 mining shirt all the time but has the twitter hash tag #goldrushmafia. That leads us to the outcome of the current season when we have been promised a mother lode. Discovery was very non specific and I got suspicious the final 2 or 3 weeks that the mother lode might not be a big deal. See there are alot of people and alot of expenses involved in the hoffman gold mining operation. First there are the trailers, probably 8 to 10, to house the workers and their families. Est. $200,000. Next there are the 2 brand new wash plants, est $500,000. 4 rock trucks, est $300,000, 3 dozers, est $250,000, 2 excavators, est $130,000, 2 loaders, est $130,000, diesel fuel, est $100,000, travel for crew and families, est $ 30,000, and leasing the land for mining, est 20% of the profit. So they pulled out $1.26 million worth of gold. How much did they pay to the land owner, est $230,000. Let’s say 1 million remaining. Now we can subtract the expenses of $1,640,000. Wow that means they are in the red by 640,000. Therefore they did not make any profit, but Discovery does not tell us the expenses so I cannot be sure but say I’m off in the expenses by half so the expenses are only 820,000. That makes them a profit of 180,000 evenly divided, which I know it is not, gives each crew member 18,000 for 5 months of work. That does not meet my definition of hitting the motherlode.

  3. Not sure but Todd must have had a serious cold during this last episode.

  4. It’s stupid how Todd Hoffman continually claims that everyone will go bankrupt if they don’t hit their goals. Then, the crew misses the goal by a mile and doesn’t even mine enough gold to cover equipment and fuel costs. But Todd declares every season a victory anyway, and comes back with more equipment and more workers each season.

  5. Jungle gold…lol. These guys have to be the biggest fools ever and have to hold hands to do anything. These dudes don’t have the work ethic to pull this off unless they get completely lucky. I just saw the episode where Scott’s son gets diagnosed with autism. The kid is two years old…no reason to waste time and money to fly home till after the season. Dumb as dirt even to do the tests as soon as dumbo goes to jungle. If I were step daddy I’d cut that boy and daughter off for life. Bud Stoll I think was your name…your daughter could do better than that weasel. Jorge…happy the tree fell on your…..you’re an idiot. I know jack about mining but honestly think I could do better than these dips. Cancel this show already.

  6. Let me get this straight–we’re supposed to feel sorry for these two peckerheads who have 4 children apiece they can’t support? Ever hear of birth control. Oh, I forgot, they’re from Utah.

  7. These men belong in Alaska. I don’t care for the jungle show at all.

  8. I would love to see Todd Hoffman, someone who considers himself a deal-maker more than a miner, link up with the guys from Utah who think they can scheme their way into mining a fortune in gold. The resulting (mis)adventure of this trio of con men and b.s.’ers would top anything else on reality television.

  9. I would go with Jungle Gold, cos the way they presented the real life scenarios and the bond of their friendship that they showed by backing up each other during trouble times.

    I would definitely rate jungle gold better amid whatever mistakes they made.

    Fan from India..

  10. I think that Gold Rush is slow and Jungle Gold is staged. I was a HUGE fan of Gold Rush when it first came out. I grew up in Gresham, Oregon, literally right next to Sandy, Oregon and was rooting for the home town boys all the way. But now it has become a lame, slow moving, soap opera. It’s not about the gold anymore it is about stretching every last second out of the day-to-day BS that is worthless. I was so happy to see Parker the other week trying to spread his wings. He wasn’t a whiny adult trying to keep the spot light on himself, and when trouble faced him, he took matters into his own hands and made things happen on a shoe-string budget, and not with millions of dollars in seed-money backing his world-wide tour of pointless camera filled boredom.

    Here we are, five weeks into the season and even though nothing has even remotely happened, you have to have a show on how things are going? Super lame. The only reason I even visit Discovery.com is to see if the next show is going to be about Parker and the Dakota Boys, I’ve given up on Todd and his bunch. They should just cancel Todd and his bunch’s show, and follow the real Gold Rushers, Parker and the Dakota Boys. Parker is a true Gold Rusher, he’s doing what a lot of us were thinking, and starting way before the spring thaw so he will be up and running when it comes time to mine, smart young man.

    Jungle Gold…. Blah! The guys that were “robbed” in the last episode I will ever watch, were either so stupid they couldn’t see a full speed freight train even if it was only 5-feet away, or it was staged for “ratings” or they were in on it. HOW STUPID do you think we are? “Oh wow! somebody blocked the road after making a incredible gold deal only 10 minutes earlier? maybe I should get out of my vehicle, unarmed, and clear the road because I’m a stupid moron.” ANY sensible person would have taken that four-wheel drive vehicle and drove around that pile of wood and floored it KNOWING that something was up… GEE WHIZ Batman somebody blocked the only road out of here, that wasn’t blocked a half hour ago… RIDICULOUS!!!!!!

    Bering Sea Gold WHERE ARE YOU!!!!!

  11. Both shows I feel are going no place. Same thing week after week. Now I just check to see if the show moved on to getting gold.

  12. Gold Rush is a much better show then Jungle Gold. I cannot stand watching Jungle Gold with these two idiots who lost all their money and now they will lose George’s Father in-laws money. George doesn’t work and they both have no concept on what they are doing!! I liked Gold Rush when they were in Alaska but the new show is kind of dumb and Todd thinks he is Gods gift to mining and knows nothing about it, good thing he has good people with him for he would never have gotten gold out of Alaska. I can’t see either show lasting past a second season the zip is GONE!!

  13. oh, i watch both.
    i am a real jungle gold fan.
    it’s the best thing there is,

    goldrush is slow and for old people :)

  14. OMG !
    How in the world did this ignorant bunch of novices get tv time ?

    AND why don’t they go to a place where they could easily blend in and find gold ? Like Australia , Georgia ( US ) or Canada ?!!!!!

  15. AND I’d rather watch a show with some REAL gold miners like Tom Massie and his whole family whos’ father started gold prospecting clubs all over the US . If you ever see a hat or T shirt with BUZZARD mining or OLD BUZZARD , that’s Mr. Massie Sr. ( rip ) nickname .

    The show is called ” GOLD FEVER ” and features Tom Massie and his family – his baby daughter , Kia could find more gold than THE WHOLE BUNCH OF THESE IDIOTS !!!!

    Why don’t they EVER try to educate themselves on the proven processes of detecting gold, sluicing, placer, history, geology, methods etc. ??!!

    Just the Hoffmans and Jungle gold crew sorely need this education……..
    BTW, theres PLENTY of gold in the good ole USA – why go to Africa or South America ?? To get in trouble with the locals ? Maybe risk getting killed trying to take money out the ground?

    Would love to see these shows go to Australia / New Zealand or Mexico…… maybe not Mexico . I understand going where the gold is , but certain countries should def be avoided and double that if you don’t speak the lingo !!!

    I sometimes watch these shows just to see if anybody on these crews pulls out a chemical / electronic metal detecting kit or tries some kind dry washing, spinning wheel, blue bowl technology or SOMETHING NEW , to see if they are REALLY trying to be gold miners or just stay ignorant ” tenderfoots ” who seem proud of being boneheaded yahoos !!!

  16. DEAR SIR/ MADAM,
    THIS IS A GOOD NEWS TO YOU AS WELL, SOMEONE HAVE A LAND OF GOLD TO MINIG. SO THE OWNER OF THIS LAND NEEDS A GOLD BUYERS WHO WILL COME TO GHANA WITH HIS MENCHINGNERRY,THE LAND HAVE ALL DOCUMENTS FOR THE LAND. WHAT THE OWNER OF THE LAND WANT A SERIOUS GOLD BUYERS TO COME AND MING THE GOLD LAND
    THANKS TO ALL SERIOUS GOLD BUYERS. CALL MY NUMBER 0245440224

Be Social, Follow Us!!