Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?

Published 6 years ago by , Updated August 14th, 2013 at 3:59 pm,

fantastic four reboot cas2t Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?

Ok so I had to redo this intro because as I was writing this MTV Splash Page happened to post (a day earlier than usual) their weekly fantasy casting column about…the Fantastic Four. My goal was to get this up today and scoop the usual Friday, blogosphere speculation fest… but C’est la vie.

Thankfully for me, Splash Page cast their Fantastic Four flick using a mostly older set of actors; I myself have been envisioning a more youthful (not too young, though) version of Fantastic Four. Check out what my vision for this upcoming reboot is, and who I picked to take on the roles of Marvel’s favorite superhero family.

Ok, so before we start I thought I’d talk a little bit about the Fantastic Four, as I have come to understand the characters over the years. The thing that has always stuck with me about the FF is the way that – beyond all the superpowered adventures and exploration that made for pretty thrilling sci-fi – the characters and their powers worked on a whole other level as a clever metaphor for the family dynamic and some all-too familiar roles within that dynamic.

Think about it: Reed Richards’ “rubber man” power is also a great metaphor for his brilliant mind, which is limitless in its creative possibilities (just like his body), but limited by its tendency to forget the basic shape of everyday life (such as family and friends); Sue Richards often feels like an invisible woman to the one person she should matter most to (Reed); Johnny Storm thinks he’s hot you-know-what; and Ben Grimm is that hard-ass “uncle” who has a big heart he hides behind a rocky shell.

fantastic four movie Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?

What I believe the last two Fantastic Four films failed to nail down was that underlying (and very relatable) family drama – lost somewhere in all the flashy f/x, bad dialogue and gratuitous exploits such as having Jessica Alba run around without clothes for no reason (which they SOMEHOW turned into a bad thing). This reboot cannot make that same mistake: family must come first if you want the story of the Fantastic Four to resonate beyond the halls of geekdom. The dynamic between the actors selected to play these roles is going to be CRUCIAL; they need to spark such good chemistry that they can improv their dialogue and still have it sound as real and natural as the arguments around YOUR family’s Sunday dinner table – while still managing to save the world.

That said, I’m making my choices based not only on the usual “he/she looks like a good fit” criteria, but also based on proven history of good chemistry with their fellow actors. I’ve also shied away from any really A-list stars – because let’s face it, with an ensemble of leading roles like this, no egos (or massive paychecks) can be allowed to rock the boat. Also, as I stated, I’ve gone with a more youthful incarnation of the Four: I would prefer to see a newly married Reed and Sue Richards, trying to figure out what shape the next phase of their adult lives should take, while having to deal with the baggage of in-laws (Johnny Storm) and close friends (Ben Grimm).

Without further ado, here is my new Fantastic Four:

(Continue to pg. 2 for the Fantastic Four casting picks)


fantastic four 001 Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?


In what is sure to be the surprise move of the century (I’m going to take A LOT of crap for this, I’m already aware), I’m going to cast Matthew Morrison and Jessalyn Gilsig, who currently play a quirky married couple on Fox’s hit new show, Glee. Both Morrison and Gilsig have had consistent careers on the small screen, with Gilsig in particular having had roles on everything from Boston Public, NYPD Blue, Prison Break, Nip/Tuck and even some superpowered work playing Claire Bennet’s pyrokinetic mother for stint on Heroes.

Morrison’s TV work has mostly involved guest spots on a number of shows, with the notable exception of a multi-episode arc on As The Wolrd Turns back in 2006. However, after just three episodes of Glee, I know Morrison is a perfect Reed Richards: He’s demonstrated on that show that he  has all the foundation needed to make Reed actually interesting for once: A man stradling fanciful dreams and adult responsibilities, deep and sensitive when he needs to be, something of a big geek – yet posessing a charming boyish innocence in those eyes that could make you believe a hottie like Sue Richards would put up with his obliviousness and neglect.

fantastic four matthew morrison and gislig Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?

This pic just screams Sue and Reed Richards to me.

Gilsig has similarly proven that she can go from doe-eyed mother figure to tough-girl in a snap – plus, she’s easy on the eyes in just the right way you’d imagine Sue Richards would be (read: MILF pretty). Jessica Alba, while scorching hot, fit NOBODY’s mental image of Sue Richards, and is still one of the worst miscastings in all comic book movie history, IMO.

Tie this left-field casting nom off with the fact that Gilsig and Morrison have had ample practice nailing down their marital chemistry (it’s more comedic on Glee, but the dysfunctional-yet-genuine love is certainly there), not to mention they’re both currently under contract with Fox, so the studio could easily work in the F4 shoot around their schedules (and sign them for relatively cheap). For two mid-list TV actors, this would be the break of a lifetime, so you know they would put forth the effort to get it right.

Talent, chemistry, motivation to perform well, the look(s)… Need I go on?


Hats off to Josh Wigler over at Splash Page for mock casting True Blood stars Ryan Kwanten (Jason Stackhouse) and Chris Bauer (Officer Andy Bellefleur) as The Human Torch and The Thing. I’ve been WRACKING my brain all afternoon trying to come up with two better picks, but man is it hard…

fantastic four kwanten and bauer in true blood Who Should Play The New Fantastic Four?

Kwanten (L) and Bauer (R) in True Blood.

Kwanten’s True Blood role has demonstrated that he can play the “I’m the man” alpha-male who still has huge pressure points of insecurity, foolishness and vulnerability (plus the ladies thinks he’s hot – get it?); and anyone who saw Bauer on season 2 of The Wire knows that the longtime character actor can hands-down play the tough-guy-with-the-heart-of-gold role that reminds you of a no-nonsense, lecture-spouting uncle you have. Add the fact that Bauer and Kwanten demonstrated some real ball-busting chemistry together onscreen during the final part of True Blood‘s second season (see above), and you’ve already got your legendary Johnny/Ben rivalry.

Added bonus: just on sight alone I can buy Kwanten and Gilsig as brother and sister, and if you’ve seen Morrison deal with his stocky gym coach buddy on Glee, or Bauer lecturing pretty much everybody on True Blood in his gruff baratone voice, it’s fairly easy to buy Morrison and Bauer as old friends Reed and Ben as well.

However, so as not to live TOTALLY in Splash Page‘s shadow, I’ll toss out Domenick Lombardozzi (The Wire) to play Ben Grimm (authentic NYC accent and attitude, plus he definitely has the look ) and Johnny K. Lewis (Sons of Anarchy) to play Johnny Storm – if he hits the weight room, that is. IMO, Lewis has the right kind of hothead smarm to play The Torch.

As for the villains? Well… We’ll save that for another post. Splash Page nominated Stellan Skarsgård to play Dr. Doom (again, great choice) but for my purposes, I need somebody younger.

How do you think our picks for the Fantastic Four reboot stack up against MTV Splash Page’s? Let us know in the comments.

« 1 2View All»

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. Some of the choices here for Reed are pretty good. Like Patrick Wilson and James Badge Dale. I think Reed, Sue, and Ben should remain older. I do agree that Johnny should be younger though. My picks for Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben are: James Denton (Desperate Housewives), Naomi Watts, Ross Lynch (a Disney alum) and (wait for it) Paul Tuttle senior from American Chopper! Yes, if you dye his hair brown and lose the mustache, he would look and totally sound perfect. And everyone knows he is great at yelling. Technically he is not an actor, sure, but reality tv is still acting, and he would be playing himself, personality wise. And, once he turns into the Thing, it would be CGI and he would just do the voice. Andy Serkis, or somebody, could do the motion capture/acting. (Tuttle would not have the patience {or the talent} for that stuff). Alan Rickman would make a good VonDoom. He too would be voice only after his change. (you need a bigger, more imposing guy in the suit a-la Darth Vader. Or you could skip Victor and do the villain that was the FF’s 1st nemesis in the comics: Mole Man, played by Danny DeVito.

  2. My choices are some what better for ben reeves james franco invisible woman oliva wilde or Jessica biel , tourch young actor billy Miller, the thing, the actor who played bane.Those are my picks