Recent Related Items:

33 Comments


Bencherstyle says:

personally, im in it for the robots. man i do love my robots. don’t really care if Fox is there… she is NOT hot. there. i said it.

although i think Shia is funny cuz he hates the wii.

Emma says:

I love robots but without Shia, I think they’d get old pretty quickly. Too much of a good thing can give you a bad headache. Shia complements the CGI perfectly. Wouldn’t see it without him. Megan’s probably replaceable.

SpaceCowboy1701 says:

Absolutely … assuming I would see TF3 at all … the overarching story is about the Transformers themselves; the humans are there as touchstones and nods to the original continuity. Megan and Shia did their jobs, but their characters are “disposable” as far as the continuing story goes, unless something changes in this movie.

Transformers is unabashedly primarily a “visual spectacle” movie, not a (human) character drama. Sure, the old comics and cartoon had recurring human characters, but they were pretty much secondary to everything going on with the robots, particularly after the first season or two, if I’m remembering correctly. I’m not super-hyped for the movie myself (visually spectacular, but …); still, I’ll probably end up going to see it with some friends anyway — and just for the spectacle.

Doogey Howser says:

CLEARLY WE WANT BOTS!!! although I haven’t seen Revenge of the Fallen yet but, TF3 I want to see all bots, as if I were watching G1… Ultra Magnus, Hot Rod, More Aerial Decepticons, , Prowl,

elrey908 says:

megan who?

Matt Keith says:

I want to see more robots not Lebeouff’s and Fox’s horrible acting.

Voice of Reason says:

Robot battles is all I’m looking for, nothing else.

Hadron Collider says:

If you’re lucky – and this is rare – you can figure out which robots are fighting and, eventually, who won.

790 says:

If I gave a cog, I would say I agree with the “Voice of Reason (Played by himself).”

Swurl says:

I’ve seen the film now and i absolutely loved it, obviously i prefered the robots but i dont mind there being humans in it aswell. The good thing about Transformers 2 is that robots are in it for much much longer and it doesnt go 5 minutes without atleast showing a robot. I do reccommend it (:

robotics says:

It has always been the Robots..the robots are the Actors in this show…what are they thinking?? …

This has been since the very existence of the fandom itself…

Ross Miller says:

I saw Transformers two last Friday (for some reason they released it in the UK five dys before the US. WTF?) and it is fun despite some MAJOR problems: too many human stuff, unnecessary humour, too long, some annoying characters (both human AND robot). But the visual effects are phenomenal and the action is improved this time around, with us actually being able to see what’s going on this time around. Check out my review if you wanna’ know more – http://blogcritics.org/video/article/movie-review-transformers-revenge-of-the/

SK-47 says:

Maybe its because I am old, but this movie does not interest me anymore. In fact this type of movie does not interest me anymroe, the CGI, Explosions, etc.
Guess I am old.

John "Kahless" Taylor says:

There’s only 1 reason Fox is in the movie, so she can definately be replaced. I do like LaBeouf’s acting but he too can be replaced in this type of film. I actually thought the 2 lead marines were the best human actors in the first film, but they too can be replaced. The Bots are the only reason to see the film, and I don’t mean those dumb Jar-Jar Binks-type critters. My oldest son will probably see it tomorrow and I will probably give my daughter and 2 young-uns the money to see it with him. I will wait for the weekend.

Andy S says:

Certain movies, like Transformers, can have the main actors replaced and most people wouldn’t care because the actors are not central to the story. I’m going to see Transformers for the robots and SFx (and maybe a booty shot of Megan Fox). In the case of Transformers, the robots are the stars and the human actors are ancillary characters. They can find another egotistical starlet to take Fox’s place and no one would care. Me included. However, try to take an iconic human character, say Dirty Harry, and try to recast them and it would scream failure. Can you imagine anyone besides Clint Eastwood as Harry Callahan, or anyone besides Harrison Ford as Han Solo??

Michael C says:

I think you would actually have a better chance of me seeing Transformers 3 without Shia, he can’t act to save his life. If Fox was in it or not i’d see it. I go to see Transformers for big shiny talking robots.

John "Kahless" Taylor says:

@Andy S
I remember watching SPace Cowboys and seeing an actor portray a 20-something Eastwood. The actor, I thought, did a great job mimicking Eastwood’s style. If they did do a reboot of Dirty Harry (I know, heresy), I think this actor would be the perfect choice.

I just looked on IMDB and the actor’s name is Toby Stephens.

Voice of Reason says:

@Ross

thx for the review but I don’t except chicken when I buy a hamburger. I use the same thought process when going to a movie.

SK-47 says:

See the review over at latinoreview, El Guapo gave this an F! Now, out of all the reviews out there I trust this site’s and also Latino’s so until I see what the verdict is here, I think I will be skipping this one because Guapo’s was really harsh.
And it also adds to my hate for Kurtzman & Orci, the two braindead noobs who wrote star trek (Lindeloff played a huge role with that I bet fixing their mess).

tasouli says:

Firstly Megan Fox is georgeous and if you dont think so than you likely like men
That being said I think she is a TERRIBLE actress and has no power in the movie, she is highly replaceable and would barely have any effect on the story of the movie or of the financial outcome of teh movie.
Shia IS a GREAT actor in my opinion and having him in teh story maintains a sort of continuity. He is not 100% essential but he is a major aspect of the movie as he is teh person in teh movie that we can attempt to relate to. If the movie solely revolved around robots than they might as well save their money and make it a cartoon.

In addition the first movie was good but NOt great. It was your standard Michael Bay movie—lots of explosions, a cute girl or two, fast paced action, and a bunch of bad acting. Neverthess I still enjoyed it but would not say that the first shoudl be a renoundly cherished movie.

Now, I also believe taht the 2nd will do but here we will lose much of the good story telling and the story will not become less interesting and there will be twice as much action…its going to be probably even more fast paced and there will be twice as many explosions, and Fox will be running around half naked most of teh time…will I see it? Probably, but it comes out tommorrow and I am leaning towards going out to hit up the bars instead

greenknight333 says:

Humans in TF2 are like the guys in the red shirts in the Star Trek:TOS..expendable and not really needed to sell the product..

-jon ^_^ says:

I’d honestly rather see only robots in the film, but I’m especially okay with dumping Megan Fox. She is really overrated physically speaking, and is not that great of an actress. Plus she seems like kind of a … yeah…. Shia is okay, but I liked him better on Even Stevens than anything else, haha. I would totally see it with a different actor… and… director *coughs*.

Foopher says:

i think people don’t give meagan fox enough credit. i mean damn she’s hott, yes, but i think she does a good job acting wise. i think shia is awesome in these movies, but yes even stevens was probably his best

Marcus says:

Revenge of the Fallen is AWESOME
Loved It.. Will see again.

Daniel F says:

To be fair I wouldn’t watch the movie if one of my fave actors was in the lead and Megan Fox was nude for 45 mins of the film….. Ok umm maybe the last one would convince me.

kejaris says:

As a MAJOR TRANSFORMER FAN i would love to see Unicron but it may not happen due to:

1. Bay’s vison of transformers is something that is cool and realistic, for example, other than the allspark he won’t incorporate the “mass shunting” that the tv show and comics use. So something as massive as Unicron, remember Cybertron in the comics is the size of Saturn, would be impossible due to scale.

2. I think Bay would also have a problem with Unicron due to the comparisons to planet killers in sci fi. Galactus (fantastic 4), Death Star (star wars) and a Borg sphere (star trek). Cybertron in the 1st move looked like a rubics cube with heiroglypics i was expecting it to look like Curosant.

3. If the transformers battled Unicron it will have to be a space battle, that is George Lucas arena not Micheal Bay’s. Plus a space battle will now exclude Bay’s hard-on for the military scenes he has been using so for in TF and TF ROTF. The US hasn’t made a space fighter yet so there would be no need for humans in the final Unicron battle.

A better final villian that would work with Bayfromers would be a decepticon city, Scorpinok is now normal sized but you have Tripticon. I have seen concept art for Tripticon as an aircraft carrier but it was not used in Revenge of the Fallen. That most likely will be the closest you will get to Unicron.

kejaris says:

Also maybe the introduction of QUINTESSONS would be fun… Maybe a united Transformer army VS the Quints… I have the prefect title for that, Transformers Till Are One. AHH robot goodness.

Daniel F says:

Bay’s vison of transformers is something that is cool and realistic,

That is a hilarious line. I would say out of every film I have ever seen in my life Transformers is the least realistic. I would believe in Vampires, super heroes and tiny little workers in a candy factory long before I would believe in Alien Robots from another planet coming to earth and fighting while befriending a human.

kejaris says:

“Daniel F says:
July 2, 2009 at 6:14 am

Bay’s vison of transformers is something that is cool and realistic,

That is a hilarious line. I would say out of every film I have ever seen in my life Transformers is the least realistic. I would believe in Vampires, super heroes and tiny little workers in a candy factory long before I would believe in Alien Robots from another planet coming to earth and fighting while befriending a human.”

Well that’s basicly what the man said on the directors commentary, go figure… (I shrug my shoulders)

What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.