Dollhouse Premiere = Creepy Concept (& Characters)

Published 5 years ago by , Updated February 14th, 2009 at 10:20 am,

dollhouse echo sc56pt 0049 Dollhouse Premiere = Creepy Concept (& Characters)

Based on past experience I’ve learned not to judge a new TV series by its premiere episode, but I didn’t really like the opening episode of Joss Whedon’s new Fox TV series Dollhouse.

The concept always sounded creepy: An organization has a number of operatives whose minds are “wiped” in between assignments. They can be programmed with completely different personalities for each new assignment and left with no memory of who they were or what they did.

The premiere episode opens with Echo (Eliza Dushku) in the shortest dress I’ve ever seen on a woman. She’s racing a motorcycle through the streets of LA with another rider – at one point she wipes out but is apparently not seriously injured. Turns out she was on a whirlwind three day weekend with some rich guy.

So right there the show bothered me – is the Dollhouse some fancy, uber-tech call girl ring? Program a hottie to hit it off with a multi-millionare for the weekend so they can tie each other up and the wipe her memory of having done it. Pretty vile if you ask me.

She seems to geniunely like the guy, but bails on the party to go back to the facility for her “treatment.” The dispenser of these treatments (mind wipes, but apparently the patients aren’t aware that’s what’s being done) is a young guy named Topher Brink (Fran Kranz) who frankly, I couldn’t stand. There wasn’t a thing I liked about the character – frankly, the word sociopath comes to mind. He’s in his mid-twenties and apparently either without conscience, or more likely a master of rationalization who doesn’t look at the “agents” as people.

I rolled my eyes at his response to Echo’s handler’s (played by Harry Lennix) concerns about Echo: There is no right or wrong, else our thinking makes it so. Ah, the old moral relativism schtick: I guess the child molester in the episode wasn’t wrong as long as in his head he thought it was OK, huh? Sorry, but what utter crap – but I guess it fit the character. My hope is that this schmuck will come to see that what he’s doing is wrong over the course of the series.

Echo’s next assignment isn’t sleazy like the previous one: A 12 year old girl is kidnapped from her (billionare?) father and he happens to be a client of the firm that runs the Dollhouse. He wants things handled quietly so they program Echo to be a kidnap negotiator. Dushku isn’t very convincing and the whole thing seems a bit ridiculous – in the world of this TV show I’m sure they could have found an actual negotiator with years of experience instead of programming her overnight.

And then there’s the silly concept of having to program weaknesses into the agents to make up for the strengths because “overachievers are compensating for something.” Really, Topher? Maybe they’re just not content to sit around and bitch and whine in dead end jobs and instead DO something about it. (Did I mention I can’t stand that character?)

There’s also Tahmoh Penikett as Agent Paul Ballard (aka “Helo” from Battlestar Galactica) – he knows about this Dollhouse operation but is having a hard time tracking it down or getting solid evidence about it. Rightfully so he equates what they’re doing essentially to murder since the person’s originality has to be wiped out for this to work and they cease to exist as a person.

There were other things that bugged me – a babe who busts in on a house like a bad-ass SWAT team member (Dichen Lachman, playing another programmed Agent) whose arms looked so thin I don’t know how she was even able to hold an assault rifle, much less shoot it. Then they closed the episode with the evening ritual of a large open shower area, where both the buff guys and the hot gals showered together (maybe ol’ Topher wipes their libido as well?).

I’ll give this a chance as the opening episode of a new series is more about laying a foundation and it takes a while to get into the groove and figure out where it’s going. I’ll be curious to see the reaction of Olivia Williams’ character (she runs the operation) and Topher’s as Echo starts to fight the programming and begins to regain her sense of self. If there isn’t some change of heart and self-examination there, I’ll be bagging Dollhouse.

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:
TAGS: dollhouse

39 Comments

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

  1. oh and my prediction:

    Harry Lennix joins Tahmoh Pinikett to help bring down Dollhouse.

    Show will probably be cancelled soon… if not, Fox is just keeping it on to say they’re not cancelled it like they did other great shows

  2. Well, I respect Whedon’s ability to churn out great concepts and stories, but I have to say that I’ve always been a bit weary of this one and I still am. I enjoyed it, and I’ll keep watching it, but there is certainly room for improvement. Joss had better tweak it, or it won’t last. Fox won’t even great shows a time slot, a shaky one is going to get axed quickly. An incredible show is in there, hiding behind some… other stuff.

    I really want this one to make it. I miss Joss on TV.

  3. THERE WILL BE SOMEONE TO ROOT FOR:

    Echo is going to start wanting to figure out who she was and a self awareness comes around.

    I hope they don’t wait too long to start the sub-plot.

  4. This was barely watchable. I like Wheadon’s work but this episode was poorly made. The show jumped the shark when she walked in the door as a hostage negotiator with one button too many undone on her blouse.

  5. I liked it, and like Josh being back on the tube. Yes, I agree with other commentor on programmer character being deeper/smarter/conflicted more than many comments against him, this is a TV show, and you need to give Josh some chance to develop the character.

    You folks are all a bit harsh about the concept, it has yet to gel, but to watch one episode of something very different and to pan it so quickly…???

    I will give it a go. I was not an early fan of Buffy, but it won me big time. And firefly was great. The problem is mainstream TV’s model is broken, not Josh Whedon’s model. He will make it great unless FOX screws him.

  6. Their libido has been erased. Aren’t you paying attention? Its hard to take your review seriously. They repeat the definition of blank slate(tabula rasa) a million times. They tell the audience they are in a child like state. Also, I happen to be very slender and I can beat my brother arm wrestling. My close friend is model skinny, and she is super strong. Muscles are shaped differently in different people. Wiry people are often very strong.
    Stop rolling your eyes. The show is very clear on the fct that the Dollhouse keepers are the villians. Have you even watched the whole show?

  7. If you don’t like experimental shows then go watch the Simpsons. The concept has a great over reaching arc. Its easy to root for Echo. Its easy to feel like you could end up like her if someone doesn’t end that tech. You people are obviusly wrong, because this is looking like a very popular show, and it needs no tweaking. The idea that people should not be treated as ojects is very clearly the big message of the show. So you are feeling exactly how Joss wants you to feel.

  8. @Mari

    This review was written based on the FIRST episode, so lighten up. And where does the review indicate that the “keepers” AREN’T the villains? Of COURSE they are.

    Vic

  9. Yea, that seemed a bit unfair to wait 6 weeks to rip someone who wrote a perspective on one hours worth of experience that had been infected with Fox Network’s interference.

    I guess we should have waited 10 weeks to give a first impression so it could be saturated with a season’s insight of viewing.

    WTH were we thinking?

Be Social, Follow Us!!