Recent Related Items:

19 Comments


Darren says:

All his stories were good.

badlvillemojo says:

I agree on the first three (The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, & Signs) awesome movies. The Village was so-so but I watched. The Lady In Water I really did enjoy, and your right, audiences didn’t get it. But watching the extras on the DVD explained a lot.

What about the other movie that he’s doing? The Last Airbender? Yea I know it’s based off of a Nick cartoon, but it could be good.

Devil does sound interesting though, I hadn’t heard about it until I read your article here. Should be interesting to see what comes out of the collaboration.

Only time will tell.

Mike E. says:

I love ALL of his films.
The “film making” of them is wonderful, the visuals are wonderful, the framing is wonderful, his attention to detail is wonderful.

The man IS a “film maker”.

But then, he can’t please everyone.

I don’t care. I would use his films in a film class as examples of things to DO. I already use the scores of his films in classes on film music.

Steve says:

I liked the sixth sense the first few times. Can’t say I have liked or had an ounce of desire to see any other film. Signs was boring, the Village I predicted the ending with only seeing the preview, Unbreakable eh. I hope this is better then the last ones.

Smike says:

MNS is a great filmmaker. I liked most of his movies so far, not to the same extend than the Sixth Sense, but all of them had their merrits. I’m glad he’s still backed by major studious despite his financial failures…

PJ says:

MNS is an awesome storyteller and director. I have enjoyed every one of his movies. He is one of the most original writers out there and is one of the only people that doesn’t keep regurgitating the same old crap.

Huggybear says:

I like all his films except “(nothing is) Happening”

Andy S says:

His films have all become repetitive and boring. The Village was absolutely one of the worst movies I have ever had the misfortune to sit through. I will NEVER ever spend another dime on any of his so-called “films.” Unbreakable was the last film he made that was worthwhile, and even that wasn’t fantastic. He made a name for himself with “The Sixth Sense” and has been riding those coat tails ever since.

Josh Rose says:

I’m definitely on the fence when it comes to Shyamalan.

The guy is a fantastic visual director. He knows how to frame his shots and set the mood. Even The Happening is not without it’s redeeming qualities, for instance, the scene where the camera is focused on the feet of several pedestrians, and in one long take they each pick up the same gun and shoot themselves in the head.

And he certainly has great ideas for stories. The Happening, again, had an interesting idea behind it, as did Lady in the Water and The Village (though I actually enjoyed that one).

But the guy honestly can’t write. He has no skill whatsoever in getting his ideas on to paper. Sixth Sense and Unbreakable were arguably flukes. He lucked out and was able to effectively tell a story.

That’s part of the reason why I’m worried about Last Airbender (it’s not his idea, but it IS his script), while I’m actually intrigued by this Devil (which is his idea, but NOT his script).

Oh, and he should never, ever be allowed a speaking part in any film ever again.

Lord garth, Formerly of Izar says:

Unbreakable 2 first please

GUNSMITH says:

ID LIKE TO SEE UNBREAKABLE 2…WHAT DOES A REAL LIFE GUY LIKE THAT DO FROM WHERE THE MOVIE LEFT OFF? DOES HE PUT ON A SUIT AND FIGHT CRIME?..DEVIL? I RATHER SEE THE ONE STORY THEY HAD IN DEVELOPMENT PURGATORY SURFACE”I LUCIFER” WICH WAS RUMORED TO HAVE JUDE LAW IN THE LEADING ROLE

Anders says:

every single on of his stories are unique which is needed in Hollywood, i do not wanna see another big cool american Dude who is saving the world.
We’ve seen that too many times.

My personal M Night favorite “The Happening”

Paul Young says:

@Anders – wow really? you might be the very 1st person I’ve ever heard say that about The Happening. I consider it to be his absolute worst work.

angel of light says:

I should say, enough promoting the Dark Side, we don’t need to educate the public with satanic orders, and their evil agenda promoted by the NWO, I pray to beloved Father God, this movie never to be made, and I hope Hollywood criminals will go down the pit where their god was thrown, and now they want to resurrect that evil mischief rebellious culprit. No people he is not an angel anymore he has fallen from Heaven and grace, and he deserves it. He will never be forgiven in the eyes of his Creator, from what he has done wrong to the entire Universe that cause the rebellion to take 13 millennia, and now is at end.
And to you all filmmakers I say to you find piece in your ego oriented souls and love in your hearts, because you are lost, all of you, and you all don’t know what you are doing.
I pray for all your souls for mercy to be beloved Creator God.
Hollywood folks have sold the soul to the devil, and that is way they are promoting to resurrect the culprit.

Wake up because it’s going to be too late if you all waiting for the rapture, there is no rapture, only cleansing of the fallen once and their minions and followers.
Don’t fall into the trap of the fallen once, they are dammed for eternity.
May peace be with all of you, you re fallen as victims that you don’t deserv.Light is shining strong, and the light is going to triumph over the dark, the dark is loosing their last battle for supremacy on Earth.
There is so many of us here and we will help are Beloved Creator to restore balance and harmony once again as it was envisioned by Heaven.
Heaven is coming soon to bring peace, mercy, balance and harmony to beloved Mother Earth,
The whole host of Legions of Light is coming very soon, lead by Michael Christ

SO BE IT , IT’S DONE!

Manowar says:

@ Angel of Light

And the world was created in 7 days, and the Earth is only 10,000 years old, and we are all decended from Adam & Eve.

Can’t wait for another M.N.S. movie. Hope it’s a good one.

Kofi Outlaw says:

@ Angel of Light

Sounds like you and your friends should get together and wait… wait by “Heaven’s Gate,” if you will…

John says:

Shyamalan is a visionary, and like any visionary, he is often misunderstood, his brilliance underappreciated.

Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, Signs, and Lady in the Water are all utterly unique, fascinating films. Signs is my personal favorite; it’s hilarious, and I love redemption stories. Sixth Sense was a crowd-pleaser, and it’s undoubtedly very creative, but it’s my least favorite of those four.

Lady in the Water is one of the most underrated films ever made, in my opinion. Paul Giamatti’s performance was amazing; I tear up every time I watch the healing scene, when he starts talking to his family.

The Village and The Happening were misfires. The Village was predictable, and The Happening was just awful. The only thing I’m still able to appreciate about The Happening is Shyamalan’s ability to create a tense situation using pretty much anything. A crazed old woman walking around outside a cabin shouldn’t be frightening, especially when we know she’s about to be killed by trees, but somehow, it’s still an intense scene.

I’m curious to see what other directors will do with a Shyamalan script; his directing style is so unique. My only fear is the film will lose that edgy Shyamalan touch under different directors, but I’ll see the film regardless.

Mike E. says:

@ Angel of Light

The “fallen once”? At first I thought to myself; “myself, surely, this is a typo” to which I responded “yes, and don’t call me Shirley”.

But then, you wrote “the fallen once” once again… (hey, THAT felt like a typo on my part!).

I ask of you: what about those who have fallen TWICE? are they safe?

Or those who have fallen THRICE? (hey I don’t get to use that word often in an internet thread!)

Or did you mean “fallen ones”? which, quite frankly, is more boring than your .

Oh, and I’m not an atheist… but dammit, I’m horribly embarrassed by loony fundamentalists like you. And remember, you can’t write fundamentalist without “mental”.

I now return you to our regularly scheduled programming.

/walks away, sloooowly….

Kal_El says:

@ Angel of Light

“Sell crazy someplace else. We’re all stocked up here!”

What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.