DC Comics’ New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Published 4 years ago by , Updated March 3rd, 2014 at 7:06 am,

Week Four: September 28th, 2011

Superman (EH)

Superman 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: George Perez, Art by: Jesus Merino


“The new adventures of Superman begin here! What is The Man of Steel’s startling new status quo? How does it affect Lois Lane and The Daily Planet? There’s no time for answers now, because Superman must stop a monstrous threat to Metropolis – one that he somehow is the cause of!”

Man, am I sick of fanboys (and girls) complaining about Superman losing his red trunks. They’re gone. The trunks are dead and gone. Let’s please, collectively, get over it right now, because the part they play in whether or not these comics are any good is well and truly nonexistent.

I’m almost tempted to call this book a buy just to enrage the embittered fans, but as much as I adore George Perez the artist, I’m indifferent to George Perez the writer. And while I’m interested to see what Superman’s new status quo is – you know, now that he’s not married and all – I can get all the requisite information from Action Comics, Justice League, and Wikipedia.

Now, had George Perez been on penciling duties – instead of just cover and breakdowns – this book would’ve been a BUY, without question. But since he isn’t, it’s just an EH.


Aquaman (BUY)

Aquaman 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Geoff Johns, Art by: Ivan Reis


“The superstar creators from BLACKEST NIGHT and BRIGHTEST DAY reunite to take AQUAMAN to amazing new depths! Aquaman has renounced the throne of Atlantis – but the sea will not release Arthur Curry so easily. Now, from a forgotten corner of the ocean emerges… The Trench! A broken race of creatures that should not exist, an unspeakable need driving them, The Trench will be the most talked-about new characters in the DC Universe!”

DC released a four-page preview of this book about a month ago and it was gorgeous, entertaining, funny, and best of all, fun.

Despite being a household name, Aquaman is the most widely-mocked mainstream superhero in all of comicdom (the butt of many SNL, Family Guy, and Entourage jokes, amongst others). Now, Geoff Johns and Ivan Reis are using that unfortunate reputation as an integral part of the book’s appeal. See, even the citizens of the DCnU think Aquaman’s a joke! Hilarity ensues.

The goal of this book – beyond pure entertainment value – seems to be the return of Aquaman’s superhero stardom without having to cut his hand off and shove the blunt-end of a harpoon inside the stump. The preview, the talent, and the villains of the book (carnivorous sea creatures reminiscent of H.P. Lovecraft’s worst) all indicate that he’s well on his way, in my opinion.


The Flash #1 (BUY)

The Flash 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato, Art by: Francis Manapul


“The Fastest Man Alive returns to his own monthly series from the writer/artist team of Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato! The Flash knows he can’t be everywhere at once, but what happens when he faces an all-new villain who really can! As if that’s not bad enough, this villain is a close friend!”

Francis Manapul drew Geoff Johns’ recent Flash run and it was beautiful, so this book is bound to be beautiful, too. The writing, on the other hand, has no such guarantee. Despite what Manapul and his co-writer Brian Buccellato would have you believe, their writing is completely untested as far as mainstream comic books go.

As such, I’m reluctant to recommend this book as a buy. “But it looks so good!” I hear you say. It looks like comic books should. It embraces the unrealistic nature of the medium. I mean, all I have to do is stare at this cover and suddenly I’m having fun.

So okay, I’m going to call this book a BUY. But it’s a buy with massive reservations! Keep that in mind, please! And don’t blame me if the writing doesn’t quite stack up to the stunning, colorful imagery that will doubtlessly come with it.


Fury of the Firestorm: Nuclear Men #1 (EH)

Firestorm 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Ethan Van Sciver and Gail Simone, Art by: Yildiray Cinar


“Jason Rusch and Ronnie Raymond. These two high school students are worlds apart – and now they’re drawn into a conspiracy of super-science that bonds them forever in a way they can’t explain or control. The dark secrets of the murderous Dog Team and its Firestorm Protocol force them to put aside their differences to confront a threat so terrifying that it may lead to a new Cold War! Welcome to a major new vision of nuclear terror from writers Ethan Van Sciver and Gail Simone with astonishing art by Yildiray Cinar!”

If you ask me, this is just a really strange comic all around.

Ethan Van Sciver is one of the most unique artists working today; indeed, he redefined the way Green Lanterns are drawn company-wide (via Green Lantern: Rebirth). Slow as he is – ironically, his Flash: Rebirth was continuously late – he’s a name talent and can sell books based solely on his art. Which is why, when you see his name on a comic, you assume he’s going to be drawing more than just the covers.

Not so with Firestorm. Indeed, Sciver is drawing the covers (to trick me into thinking he’s drawing the interiors, I guess?) and he’s also writing the book with the help of Gail Simone – but Yildiray Cinar is drawing the interiors.

The whole thing just seems too messy – too many cooks artists in the writing kitchen and what have you – to be a guaranteed homerun. On the other hand, if Gail Simone weren’t assisting, I almost definitely would’ve listed this as a DO NOT BUY, despite the intriguing synopsis. We’ll know for sure soon enough.


The Savage Hawkman #1 (DO NOT BUY)

Savage Hawkman 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Tony Daniel, Art by: Philip Tan


“Carter Hall’s skill at deciphering lost languages has led him to a job with an archaeologist who specializes in alien ruins – but will the doctor’s latest discovery spread an alien plague through New York City? No matter the personal cost, Carter Hall must don his wings and become the new, savage Hawkman to survive! Witness the start of a new action series from writer Tony S. Daniel and artist Philip Tan that will take Hawkman where no hero has flown before!”

Try as I might, I just cannot get excited about Tony Daniel writing Hawkman. And Philip Tan? No way, man, forget about it. His arc was the only weak link in an otherwise (nigh-on) perfect Batman and Robin run by Grant Morrison.

In fairness to Philip, the art on this book looks leagues better. And in fairness to Tony, the synopsis looks intriguing enough, what with all the archealogy, adventure, and, uh, intrigue. But the problem is, there are just far more, far better-looking, comic books in The New 52 to risk wasting money on this. Sorry, guys.


Voodoo #1 (EH) 

Voodoo 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Ron Marz, Art by: Sami Basri


“Who is Voodoo? Is she hero, villain – or both? Learn the truth about Priscilla Kitaen as she leaves a trail of violence across America. Discover the new DCU through her eyes, because the things she sees are not always what they seem…”

To be honest, I have next-to-no interest in Voodoo as a character, but the art on this book is very, very pretty and Ron Marz – despite being missing-in-action from both DC and Marvel for years – was responsible for some great books in his heyday, including Green Lantern: Emerald Twilight.

Does that make this book a BUY? No, it does not. But it’s not a DO NOT BUY either, and that has to count for something.


Blackhawks #1 (DO NOT BUY) 

Blackhawks 1 Cover 280x420 DC Comics New 52 Reboot: The Complete Guide

Written by: Mike Costa, Art by: Ken Lashley


“Welcome to a world waging a new kind of war that’s faster and more brutal than ever before. It’s fought by those who would make the innocent their targets, using computers, smart weapons and laser-guided missiles. The new enemy is hard to find – and closer to home than we think. Between us and them stand the Blackhawks, an elite force of military specialists equipped with the latest in cutting-edge hardware and vehicles. Their mission: Kill the bad guys before they kill us.”

Honestly, I can’t point to a single thing that makes me want to buy this book.

It’s not that Mike Costa is a bad writer – he’s just not a known quantity, writing-wise, as he’s written very few things so far in his career. Secondly, while Ken Lashley’s an okay artist, he’s only drawing the first book. For as yet unknown reasons, the art team on Blackhawks continues to change with every issue, which is never a good sign. And lastly, the synopsis reads like it’s actively attempting to be unoriginal and uninteresting.

Call me predictable, but I’ll be passing on this unless I hear it’s awesome.

Week 4 Part 2…

« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10»

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. I am one of the fabled “New Readers.” Thus, I am not biased in my review of the New 52 because I don’t have a history of how things were. I read: Justice League, Action Comics, Batman and Robin, Green Lantern, Wonder Woman, Aquaman, The Flash, Detective Comics, Superman, Firestorm, Suicide Squad and Supergirl. After three months of issues, here is my verdict:

    Top Tier
    Suicide Squad
    Justice League

    Middle Tier
    Green Lantern
    The Flash
    Detective Comics

    Bottom Tier (and will not be buying more)
    Action Comics
    Wonder Woman
    Batman and Robin

    • How could you possibly think that Wonder Woman is bottom tier? I’m loving this run so far. Action Comics has been good as well, this last issue was a bit of a miss, but I’m interested to see what the next issue brings because, honestly, the first two were really good. I haven’t read Batman and Robin, so I can’t really say about that one. Also, I think that Green Lantern, Aquaman, Batman, Captain Atom, and Flash are really good so far and I can’t wait to see where they’re going. Have you read the solo Batman title?

      • I’ve read the first 3 issues of Batman & Robin and it isn’t as great as I’d hoped for. There has been a lot of setup, but not much else. I’m still hoping it will improve–I think Damian Wayne is a great character, and he and Bruce definitely need to get to know each other!

    • Action Comics have been underwhelming so far…Superman Unchained has been great. I’ll probably check out Suicide Squad because of this post though – I’d neglected it before.
      You should realize though that Superman New 52 is the driving force behind the reboot and should give it more credit.


  2. I have been reading DC since the 1970s but I somehow became excited by this reboot. I realized it was because the continuity was a mess and this simplified everything. I collect 9 titles only. Aquaman is out in front to my own surprise. After 3 issues. This is my tier list:

    Aquaman (beautiful art, reads like a movie)
    Justice League (fun, camraderie between heroes, Superman kicks everyone’s butt)
    Green Lantern (artwork and Sinestro)


    Batman ( great storyline)
    Green Arrow

    Flash (art ok but dull, not easy to follow)
    Savage Hawkman (becoming silly after okay first 2 issues, weird artwork)

    My 13 year ol son loves Flash but thinks this series is dull. Might pick up All Star Western too; looks like a good series.

    Aquaman (

    • I loved the Flash, I found the art very unique.

      • Yeah, Flash is beautiful.

  3. Dear DC-Kid okay you may be right but in the revamped Teen Titans there is A group called N.O.W.E.R.E. using the kids as lab rats. And I still want to know what happened to Donna Troy. Did she just vanish along with Wall West,Jade and A few others. Because with the story arc in Wonder Woman her take and reactions would be interisting.

  4. Honestly, I’m loving the New 52. I’m really only following Aquaman, Batman, Batman: Dark Knight, Green Lantern and Green Lantern Corps, but still I look forward to release day every week.
    I wish I could read the new run of Swamp Thing, but after re-reading Alan Moore’s run of (Saga of the) Swamp Thing, I can’t find myself to pick it up.

    • Dude its is really good. Moore’s Swamp Thing is epic though.

  5. I would actually be kinda excited for the roboot is i wasn’t busy freaking out over Robin(Dick Grayson). I don’t know how much there redoing and i would be seriously pi**ed of if they messed with my two favorite characters (Bat and Rob) or even made it so he didn’t exist.

    • I hope by now you’ve realized Dick Grayson is doing just fine in the reboot but as Nightingale, not as Robin. Tim Drake is Red Robin, and Damian Wayne is Robin.

      • You mean Nightwing, right?

        • Yes, of course…damnable predictive text :P

  6. I found the Teen Titans extremely disappointing. They just thought it was okay to delete Tim Drake’s entire history with the Titans and Young Justice?? I liked Red Robin’s solo comic and Stephanie Brown as the new Batgirl. Is she going to be Spoiler again? And what about Cassandra Cain, did she just disappear? Urgh, I hate when DC does this…if they wanted to relaunch they could have at least finished the stories they started

    • Yeah I agree with you. In reverse order: Cassandra Cain was two scoops of AWSOME! Where the Fobart did she go? Stephanie Brown had finally started to come into her own and I was following her storyline avidly… What?… Was she abducted by evil editor aliens?! And, of course saving the best for last, RED ROBIN: WHAT WERE THEY THINKING!?!?

      The Evolution of Tim Drake through the years culminating in his debut as Red Robin was EPIC!! LEGENDARY!! The costume was superb and his demeanor… It was Blessedly and Wonderfully Unique. Born from the Batman persona he grew into his own brand of hero. One that went up against Rahs Al Ghul and Won!! (as much as anyone can truly win against Rahs)

      I practically Drooled in anticipation of each new Red Robin comic. Heck I’d almost given up comic books completely until his series came out! The Red Robin Title renewed my love of the genre. And while I was saddened when the Red Robin title was discontinued I took comfort in the fact that he would show up as the wonderful character that brought me back to the table in other titles. (as well as harboring hope that his title would be picked up again)

      Now look at what’s been done to him! oajdhfopwf oiqkjfdhfdoi ;owjfho[wfijqw (bangs head into keyboard in frustration)

      All the uniqueness, the Verve, the… the… Chutzpah! It’s all gone. All that’s left is a former sidekick putting together and leading a team for the first time. It’s not epic… It’s not legendary… It’s not Red Robin. It’s just an teenage ex-Robin who put a color in front of his name.


      I’ll will, however, continue to read the Teen Titans title with the hope and prayer that DC will make something unique of him again.

      (Sigh) I Hope.

      • PREACH!!!!!!

  7. Anybody read Wonder Woman #7 it seems about every 35 years the Amazons put to sea naked. Then pay A booty call on the first ship they find. And after A party that would make Hugh Heffener blush. They kill the poor guys and probly sink the ship. Nine mounths later they celebrate A daughter. Or are saddened by thr birth of A son. And we are suposed to belive Diana never noticed any of this. Realy she never heard any babys crying,never saw any little girls on the island.

  8. I’m love the new 52, anyone reading these comments, the first 8 issues of the new 52 seem to set up the series, so we’ll have to wait till the 9th to see if I’m right, but it seems that way in a lot and I read 80% of them. This is also a woman’s perspective, so if anyone reading this is a woman, they may be more inclined to agree, I tend to see the magic comics more so liked by female audiences.

    Top tier:
    -Wonder Woman (it get’s really good, read it for yourself and see if you like it or not)
    -Batman Inc (Batman is so crazy, love other bats)
    -Green Lantern New Guardians (for light lovers, all lights, plus kyle rayner is so imaginative, makes you hate guardians more too)
    -Green Lantern, (wtf Sinestro O.o, but I’m digging it)
    -The Justice League Dark/ I, Vampire cross over was good, I like how they played off of each other, and you had to read both to get the full story, shows the new 52 universes are interconnected, you got gotham and bat family action also.

    Mid Tier
    -Demon Knights, I’m liking it, could be top tier with more development to me
    -Red Lanterns, I like the direction they are going.

    Bottom Tier
    -Justice League International, I was pumped at first, then it just got boring imho.

    All the others I’m still making decisions about as I’m reading, I’m not too attached.

  9. The more I read it, the more I hate the New 52…with the exception of Aquaman and The Justice League and that is only because of the Shazam mini-series in it. I am the biggest Batman fan and now can’t stand it. Shame on you DC >:(

    • I have to agree with you about Batman. In the old DC universe he was LEGENDARY!! almost like a mortal GOD in the fact even when bled he still went at it, and he NEVER did it stupid.

      Now he seems… I’m not sure how to accurately describe it… Inept? Yes, Inept. He makes rooky Robin type of mistakes. And now he’s sleeping with Catwoman AND letting her get away with her particular brand of mischief?! Heck, he’s even covered for her!

      No. Way.

      I don’t know what kind of Mishigas they’re up to over at DC but I hope they’re able to pull it together and get him back into true Batman Fighting trim soon. (and this court of owls thing does NOT count)

  10. I am abandoning dc. Marvel is my favorite now, Dc has taken a trip to the parallel universe of Bizarro World. Superman should be the flagship character, but he seems wayyyyyyy too mediocre now, and it is sad to say but his lame superman Tshirt with jeans looks 10 times better than his Kryptonian Supersuit which looks way too much like Japanimation inspired crap now, it was iconic, looked like a glorious flag, it looks like they removed some stars and stripes from the American flag now, it just looks like something is missing. The loss of the red shorts was bad enough, but the red belt looks terrible and so does a suit of armour on Superman. And Flash looks like he was stolen from Disneys Tron. Yuck. Make mine Marvel now. I’ll still cherish Dc pre- new 52 however. But this new Dc universe sucks, as I’m sure will the new Superman movie, which I hope doesn’t because I would love to see it be successful, which so far looks like they are using the basis for “The new 52″ as its backdrop, as the movie suit looks like the new suit without shorts.

    • I agree with everything you just said about superman except the shorts… I always thought the shorts were fugly.

  11. I forgot to mention that it is pretty sad that Aquaman seems to be the best hero DC has to offer now. Like I said earlier… Bizarro World!

    • How sad…I, on the other hand, am quite impressed with the recreated universe DC has managed to create with the New 52. I think they have maintained (and, in some cases, improved upon) the essential natures and elements of the heroes and villains…particularly Superman. I look forward to seeing how the various series develop.

      As for you two, enjoy your Avengers and X-Men…oh and Spider-Man, of course. DC will be just fine…

      • Yeeeeaaaaahhhhh… DC 90210.

        • No…just DC evolving in the new millenium. I didn’t comment trying to get you to agree with my opinion. Just as I think you two are wrong, I’m fine with you thinking the same about me.

          In my opinion, it’s your loss…

          • Relax,
            If you’ll read my first post here, you will see that I intend to continue to read the DC in the hopes that it will improve. But yes, as it stands, right now I am very disappointed in what I’ve seen so far. You have to understand, a lot of what made the characters so unique to me seem to have been so completely scooped out it was like they were never there. I love that they brought back certain characters like Grifter and Gen13, but how they did it leaves me cold and disappointed.

            Still it could get better.

            • I was not stressing about it…merely pointing out my different perspective. Fair enough about your disappointment, but remember that at this point in Batman’s comic (for example, and I am talking about the amount of time from 1939 on), Batman was still a killer, so I think there is still plenty of time and opportunity to develop the various series quite a bit more…

              • And THAT’S why I’m still reading DC. b^^d

  12. Relax,
    If you’ll read my first post here, you will see that I intend to continue to read the DC in the hopes that it will improve. But yes, as it stands, right now I am very disappointed in what I’ve seen so far. You have to understand, a lot of what made the characters so unique to me seem to have been so completely scooped out it was like they were never there. I love that they brought back certain characters like Grifter and Gen13, but how they did it leaves me cold and disappointed.

    Still it could get better.

  13. I liked the idea of reinventing and improving on the characters and storylines, modernizing it. Before it didn’t feel like the comics were in the new millennium it still felt very 90s but now I think it’s quite modern. So I picked up the comics I usually read JLA, Superman and Batman. So far…

    JLA = Thank god WW has a new uniform (though I ignore the chocker, armband, and miss the old wide front belt, ignore the eagle at the top of corset, and prefer the old style tiara) basically I just like that’s she’s in trousers. Love the new S costume, no more wearing underwear on the outside of his trousers, I know everyone hates the collar but I kinda like it, the red belt is growing on me I think it would have been better yellow since Red/Blue/Yellow are his colours but yellow seems to be on vacation. (Though it looks like it’s armoured pieces stuck together, like Bats.) Though I do wonder how he gets in and out of it. Like the Hal Jordan, arrogant and cocky, you know oneday that power will go to his head and he’ll do something stupid, especially like the bit where he touches WW lasso and tells her that he is all about impressing people. Flash is good, Aquaman good too. Good look for Cyborg but I’ve never been interested in the character (except in Smallville) and that hasn’t changed. I really like seeing the team come together though I am missing Martian Manhunter.

    Superman = They killed the Kents, who will he go to for advice? No Lois… hmmm we’ll see. Heard rumours of having a thing with Diana, hmmm we’ll see. (I rather liked her flirting with Batman but getting nowhere with him.) Running round in jeans a t-shirt and a cape… okay… no. Too Superboyish and I never read that. Though I did look at the bit of memory he had of Krypton, World Against Superman Part 3.

    Batman = I like this new Bruce, he’s using a bit more of his brain instead of his brawn which is the whole point of Batman he uses his brain to outwit Supers. Though not sure of Batman Inc and getting others all over the world to be Batman too. Love Dick. A bit disappointed with the new Red Robin, he was becoming his own hero and then 52 happened and he’s …. Flopped is properly the best word. I don’t like Damien, I don’t know what they were thinking when they invented him? I don’t like the lesbo Batwoman mostly because I never got Batwoman or Batgirl if I’m honest – It feels like they’ve just copied him and want to be him, why can’t they be inspired by him but come up with their own identity, like Huntress. Didn’t Stephanie Brown die and where’s Cassandra? I was hoping they would start from the beginning, the journey to becoming Batman, (like their doing with Superman), kinda like Batman Begins (though no Rachel), Dick joining Batman (though no kid would let anyone call them Dick, Rick would be better, which also a nickname for Richard, and less old fashioned), reintroduce all the villains and the history between him and Talia, Catwomen, Viky Vale (I really liked her in the Road Home), and all the other women who have come close but never quite reached that guarded heart of his, but maybe in the future they’ll do a few stories of that.

    • Excuse me? Lesbo Batwoman? Why do you feel the need to point out the fact that Batwoman is a lesbian? It’s obvious you haven’t even read the comic, yet you feel the need to point that specific trait out in such a negative light? Batwoman, at least in my opinion, is the best character in the New 52, and it’s due in part to the fact that she’s not hyper-sexualised and made into a whore like most of the other New 52 females. But I’m sure that’s what you like.

      • Agreed – that’s like saying “this is my gay friend Dave” instead of “this is my friend Dave.” It’s not their identity, jeez. Doesn’t make any more sense to say “lesbo Batwoman” than it would to call me “Straight Tom”.

        For shame, “J”.


  14. The Flash has been the best of the new 52, and one of the best runs of the character ever. I have complete faith in the writer and artist on it. Great job, DC! :-D

  15. I have always loved comics, but I have never subscribed to a comic book series…I want to subscribe to the new 52…I know I am really late on subscribing…My biggest interest is Wonder Woman, Superman & Justice League & Young Justice…I am a little confused if, when I subscribe would I need to subscribe to “4″ different comic subscription? Thank you for your help…and I hope my noviceness is not too novice for this forum.
    Thank you,

    • Just visit dccomics.com and go to their subscriptions page. You can just check the boxes on the titles you want and pay for them all at once. It should be easy. And Wonder Woman is phenomenal! You definitely won’t regret it!

  16. Can anyone explain why there are several versions of the Batman Comics? There’s Batman, Batman: Detective series & Batman: The Dark Knight. oh and Batman and Robin. Do any of them inter-link? or do you just follow the one your more drawn too and like the look of. New to comics so to have this clarified would be appreciated!

    • He is popular and DC’s flagship character. Batman is just your run of the mill Batman story, while in the past Detective had been more of the detective aspect of Batman. Batman and Robin is focused on the relationship between Bruce and his son Damian. And as for Batman The Dark Knight according to DC it is about Bruce and his relationships to Gotham City, which I know seems redundant. Then Finally we have Batman Incorporated which is about Bruce Wayne revealing to the world that he bankrolls Batman and his plan to have a “Batman operative” in every country in the world. They do cross over occasionally. So it really a matter of picking which book is for you. I would recommend Batman and Batman and Robin as in my opinion they are the strongest of the Batman titles.

      • Thanks! :)

        • No problem man,always a pleasure to help out a fellow fan :)

    • Well, it’s quite simple. It’s because Batman is DC’s most popular character. After him is Green Lantern, which is why there are also several books that revolve around the Green Lantern mythos. Also, as Big B said, each title also shows a different aspect of the Batman mythology and character. But I would also add that Detective Comics is there because, along with Action Comics, it’s one of DC’s flagship titles. I actually think it was the first title launched by DC comics…ever. It was originally an anthology title, but for a long time now, it’s focused primarily on Batman stories due to the fact that he was first introduced in Detective Comics #27. However, the title has introduced several other important DC characters. For example, Martian Manhunter first appeared in Detective Comics #225.

  17. Hello dudes. I have always been into marvel mostly. I read fair bit of Vertigo and some topcow and a few mish and mash of other brands, the only DC i really read is Green Latern (Geoff Johns), and not much of it. Trying to get into DC, but like the Marvel Universe it as an epic headache, hence why I am just going straight for DC 52. I’m going to try them all out, and then decided which ones I will actually read. So far, I have been reading in Alphabetical order:

    New 52 comics to collect

    The Good
    >Aquaman (number one, straight off the mark I was interested, but then again I grew up around the water)
    >Batman (starts well enough)
    >All Star Western (pretty cool, easier to get into than that other vampire western)
    >Animal Man (unexpected interest, since i could not care less about greenies)
    >Batman and Robin (the son is a lil #$#@)
    >Batwoman (just for the art, a real fan)

    >Action Comics (will try second issue, last chance)
    >Dark Knight (nothing happened)
    >Birds of Prey (ponderous so far, though I like canary, her costume sucks)
    >Catwoman (Is there even a story? Hope she gets a better writer, I should apply)

    >Batgirl (was cheesy so far)
    >Captain Atom (boring, boring, scientific mumbo jumbo with a fake Stephen Hawking, heard it got cancelled anyway)

    The Bad
    >Green Arrow (won’t try, never liked his character)
    >Hawk and Dove (look like a couple of gay dude dressed up for the marti gras rather than heroes), they were lame in JLU tv show, no way.

    I would like to see other list, because I have only read the first issue of most of these. Right now I am also trying to catch up in the Marvel Universe, backtracking before civil war, and going through all the way to the current, mainly focusing on x-men(mostly offcuts, not uncanny as its lame), spiderman, avengers. It is so tough, i give up for months at a time, all the research is beyond, and that is why I like this relaunch. Saves time which I don’t have, since I am a writer and should be writing my own.

    • Dude if you like Animal Man then Swamp Thing is a must. Also I would Highly recommend Demon Knights. And if you like Green Lantern Corps and New Guardians is very good. And imo Wonder Woman is at her best right now. Outside of those few Justice League Dark is a fun read, and pick up OMAC. I loved it even though it got cancelled that book was just fun. I never expected to like it. Now if you are into events if I am not mistaken all the Justice League books will be crossing over next summer for Trinity War which looks like it could be good. Oh and Rise of The Third Army throughout all the Green Lantern related titles should be good. As far as Marvel I dropped them after Secret Invasion. Just not for me and I love spidey Iron man and Thor.

      • Yeah I have now tried a few more, and they are good suggestions I agree on since I read:

        > Justice League (very good start)
        > Justice League Dark (great choice in some characters)
        > GL, GL/NG, GL C (though corps in the first issue isn’t much to go on)
        > Frankenstein (monster team is pretty fun)
        > Demon Knights (starting to like the different kinds of teams, this era is a good change for me)
        > I, Vampire (actual interesting vampires, could be interesting later on)

        > DC Universe Presents (I figure this is one shots?)
        > Detective Comics (no rising all falling action, straight typical run of the mill kind of effort here)
        > Red Hood and the Outlaws (unsure on this, could go well with something fun, or could bomb with silliness, have to test again)
        > JL International (Nothing interesting so far, and some characters that I don’t like, plus cheesy dialogue)
        > Voodoo (need to read second issue to judge, does it finish properly? since I know it is getting, or got axed)

        > Death Stroke (Cliche, heartless and lame, would rather read “The Boys” for some blood thirsty mindless action.
        > Legion Lost (not sure what is going on here, has not intrigued me to know more at all)

        Still a fair few more comics to try like flash and wonderwoman, not sure if i should bother with the cancelled men at war…

        • I’m on the fence about Red hood also. Don’t waste your money on Men At War. Flash and Wonder Woman have been great, Although I must say the first arc of Flash is kinda slow but it gets awesome once they bring in the Rouges. Its one of those books I cannot wait for every month. And Dc Universe Presents will be short arcs featuring different characters from across all of DC. Kind of like a spotlight book.

  18. This list went wrong so badly at some comics…
    Suicide Squad has got one of the best writing of all new 52.And personally my favorite one.

  19. I’m coming back to comics after 18 years so I started with what was familiar to me, I’m loving Grifter,Voodoo and Stormwatch. I will be checking out Suicide Squad,Dark Knight and All-Star Western as my next 3 titles.

  20. Just got back into reading comics, Spending the last 5 years playing golf until my son brought home the new Nightwing. Alas the fire rekindled!!! I went out the next day and bought JLA, by chance the owner of the store recognized me and hooked me up with all the JLA books from the 52…on this he told me to get with Batman,JLA,Dark Knight, those are the only ones he feels are worth it and will have a long strong run.. Now, i need thoughts and other views on what i should start collecting…

    • Well, we all have different tastes, but I also love the new Batman and Nightwing series! Aquaman is also surprisingly excellent, and Batgirl has been amazing, but DC just fired the writer (which I am very upset about), so the quality of that title may wane. I have also been enjoying Green Lantern starting with issues #0 and #13, as they have focused on a new Green Lantern, but I’m sure the previous stories were excellent as well!

  21. Characters that I will like to see and I list even though they might never get shown are A.J. The son of Aquaman and Mera he is a great character who has this Damian look could also have that quicker dimension aging but know growth spurts if placed in regular earth second would be Koryak another son of Aquaman who like Jason ironically died and came back I would actually add him to outlaws due to his rage. Third is Geo-Force and his nephew Gregor Jr. Who could be a younger hero. 4th Lor-Zod back to the Damian thing I would like to see a team with Damian Wayne,Iris west 2, Lor-Zod, and A.J. 5th Impulse Iris west 6th Lorena Marquez really like the character and brings diversity 7th Hotspot enjoyed him in TT 8th Thanatos would be great for why A.J. Was born and raised in that realm. 9th Lagoon boy brings a different aspect on atlanteans 10th Cassandra Cain completely epic. my list

  22. Characters that I will like to see and I list even though they might never get shown are A.J. The son of Aquaman and Mera he is a great character who has this Damian look could also have that quicker dimension aging but know growth spurts if placed in regular earth second would be Koryak another son of Aquaman who like Jason ironically died and came back I would actually add him to outlaws due to his rage. Third is Geo-Force and his nephew Gregor Jr. Who could be a younger hero. 4th Lor-Zod back to the Damian thing I would like to see a team with Damian Wayne,Iris west 2, Lor-Zod, and A.J. 5th Impulse Iris west. Lorena Marquez really like the character and brings diversity. Thanatos would be great for why A.J. Was born and raised in that realm. Lagoon boy brings a different aspect on atlanteans. Cassandra Cain completely epic. my list

  23. Im trying to get some new 52 comics but I don’t have that much money so I can like concentrate on 2 characters, I know I wanna get justice league but not sure f I should get Batman,Action Comics/Superman,Aqua man, or the flash

  24. urm War of the green lanterns a miss???

  25. When does the flash new 52 take place?

    • It’s current continuity.

  26. I used to buy DC comics regularly but the New 52 thing offended me on a number of levels to the point where I stopped buying DC titles cold turkey and with the sole exceptions of the occasional issue of Mad Magazine (which I don’t consider a DC thing anyway) and the Batman ’66 title which stands alone from anything else, I’ve kept to my decision and haven’t regretted it. I was offended not by the decision to reboot characters and the like – that’s happened before – but by things like DC turning its back on history by resetting the numbering of Action and Detective comics, denying long-term fans of ever seeing a 1000th issue and also abandoning 75 years of legacy. The new Detective Comics just published its 27th issue and no one cares. Do a Google search about why the original Detective 27 was significant. I was also turned off by them deciding to “fix” Oracle and make her Batgirl again, denying disabled fans of a role model. And they cancelled most of the titles I was following. Occasionally I will thumb through New 52 titles at the store out of curiosity and the first thing that strikes me is how ugly they are. Ugly in art, ugly in story, ugly in characterization. As I said earlier, I’ve kept open minds about reboots before (I was there for Crisis on Infinite Earths) but what DC pulled with this (and the fact creators have told them to go to hell means it’s not just my personal taste being offended) basically has killed DC as far as I’m concerned. If they went out of business tomorrow I wouldn’t care.