CSI: NY Premiere Recap, Review & Discussion

Published 6 years ago by , Updated September 24th, 2009 at 9:54 am,

As the information unravels, it appears that they’re not so much targeting the police as much as they’re trying scare people away? We find out that the killed informant was not only in the bar with the CSI team the night of the shooting, (she caught some shrapnel in the shoulder) but also worked in the same building.

With a lucky break by some brave, but dead, man named Albert, they have a lot of blood that belongs to the unsub (oops, wrong show. That’s Criminal Minds.). Turns out the guy they’re looking for is named David Wilson. By the time they find him, he’s dead. He was “dropped off” at the hospital and by “dropped off” I mean they threw him out of the car, but at least it was at the hospital. That’s good, right?

Come to find out, it leads back to a guy named Tyson Menlo. As the police bust into his residence we find the mysterious brother Jake standing in front of Menlo with a gun pointed at him. Angry about his sister’s death, he’s threatening to shoot. The police attempt to stop him, but there’s no stopping him. Brother Jake kills Tyson Menlo.

After some questioning by the very angry Mac, Jake confesses that they weren’t trying to target cops or kill anyone, but that they were trying to get the city to work for them? I’m still not sure if I understand that. I guess it’s some kind of power thing? As they review the message that was left on the tip line by the informant we find out that the reason why she was at the bar was to stop her brother and the others from continuing their plan to shoot up the city. She felt that if her brother saw her in front of the bar that they would call it off. Unfortunately, her brother wasn’t in the car at the time.

The episode ended with a moving montage of the team and what they’re up to and we end with Danny in his wheelchair staring at his feet. He’s trying to make them move with all his might and finally, they do. (Told ya 10% is enough)

csi ny epilogue cast CSI: NY Premiere Recap, Review & Discussion


It’s hard to describe how I feel about this episode. On one hand, I really enjoyed it – I thought the story was good and interesting and I’m content with everything that happened. On the other hand, this was an episode that I have been waiting months for. After everything that happened in the fifth season finale, I was expecting some kind of continuation of that. The only continuation apparent is from that of the view. Even the team didn’t think it had anything to do with anyone involved in last season’s finale. Dunbrook isn’t even in this episode. If not for flashbacks they wouldn’t have even said Angell’s name. I feel kind of cheated on that point… It was a false climax. You would think that after being on the air for six seasons they wouldn’t feel the need to do such things.

Ultimately, it was a good episode on its own, but if you view them as marked (Part 1 & 2), then it’s a poor combined episode. I have to say that the best thing to come out of this episode is that Adam and Bonasera hooked up. Yeah, and then Adam agreed with Bonasera that they should never do that again. I’m sure that’s exactly what he was thinking.

What do you think about  this premiere episode? Was it everything you expected it to be? Were all of your questions answered? Are you happy with the answers? Am I wrong? (Of course not, but I just thought I’d be nice and put that.)

« 1 2

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. I didnt watch it.
    I watched Criminal Minds and thoroughly enjoyed it.
    The Adam/Stella pairing went just as I thought it would.
    thats one of the reasons I no longer watch the show.
    Its too predictable.
    Killing Flack instead of Angell in the finale and killing Danny in the premiere ,THOSE would have been risks .

  2. Bite your tounge Gary. If they ever killed off Flack or Danny, I would for sure stop watching. Anyone else is fair game, but those two are the best.
    I did like this episode though. The potiental personal stories that you can see developing for the characters are great – Flack spirling out of control (all those women, you know something is up), Danny fighting to recover, Stella getting jealous when that new girl and Adam hook up (it’ll happen). Can’t wait!

  3. I agree with Sara, Flack and Danny are the best characters of the show. They can’t kill them off or Mack, even though they never give Mack a chance to grow as a character. (It’s too bad because Gary Sense is a great actor) This episode was a huge disappointment. I was really hyped for it with everything they had set up for the season finally but it just let me down. It seems like whenever something titers on the edge of being epic with this show they kill it. And what was up with the overuse of musical montage filler? I hate it when they use it even once in their show but this time it seemed way more than usual, like they didn’t have enough story to fill an hour. This show has potential, but its hitting over their sixth season, someone in the writing/directing category needs to be replaced. Oh well, CSI Las Vegas once again redeems all other CSI’s. Their promos for their season starter sent chills down my spine, can’t wait! (Perhaps they’ll kill off Sara for good, yes?)