Recent Related Items:

42 Comments


790 says:

You take this Twilight stuff WAY to serious BSL, and THAT is my point.

I’m going to go enjoy my world of hate mongering now.
I’m 790,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, good day. :-)

Melissa says:

BSL – I am kind of curious reading your posts… what do you hope to accomplish? Your tone is very attacking and I wonder if you think you can get someone to read a book by attacking them like you are. People are ALLOWED to not be interested in our Twilight world…just as you are allowed to not be interested in…oh I don’t know, The Transformers movie for example. People can think they wouldn’t like it based on some extreme fan reactions or just the fact that really, it’s a romance and not everyone is into that. That’s okay.

You might say something like, I’m sorry you have such a negative opinion but I find it sad that you are missing out on something great… instead of calling people who express disinterest ‘haters’ and ‘ignorant.’

I don’t mean to attack you, heck I am ONE of you… I just don’t see why you are expending so much energy going on the offensive against people who aren’t interested. You are in no way going to FORCE them to be interested… And a lot of people will argue with you just for the sake of arguing… so it is a WASTE of your time.

There’s plenty of internet sites out there where you can express your love for Twilight with other fans who will whole heartedly agree with you…

Melissa says:

P.S. BSL… I just read the first page of comments and see you weren’t as attacking in the beginning… so I apologize if you felt backed up against a wall before you started lashing out…

Melissa says:

For NHOJ & 790:

This is a movie site, Screen Rant… I fully support your right to have an opinion on the movie Twilight and your interest in the movie New Moon without reading the books they are based on. Movies should and do have to be able to stand alone. The first movie, as most honest Twilight fans who aren’t obsessed with Robert Pattinson would admit, didn’t do a very good job. So I would understand your incredulity at the level of our passion.

However, suggesting we read another vampire book that is a “true” vampire book doesn’t mean much to us. In all honesty, the vampire element is not why we love these stories. I could care less about Dracula or how vampires are “supposed” to be written. Meyer created her own world – She made it almost believable, in a fantasy sort of way. She came up with new reasons why vampire legends/myths exist (sunlight doesn’t hurt vampires but it exposes them as non-human – made me think of how the moonlight exposes the pirates as ghosts on the pirates of the caribean movies). She did a very cool and unique thing with the werewolves introduced in New Moon… Just the way they communicate with each other is fascinating… and then she wove it into Native American type ‘magic’ and legend…

But as interesting as all that is, that’s not why we love it. We love the characters, we love the romances, the suspense and element of danger each book holds (and we are all hopeful the next movie gets it right.) We love the family dynamics, the friendships, the sacrifices the characters make for each other… We aren’t really die hard vampire fans.

Also, don’t dismiss us so quickly. To say no one will remember Twilight in 10 years I believe to be highly inaccurate. (Maybe the first movie or the actors, sure, but not the books). Do you believe that no one will remember Harry Potter in 10 years time? I don’t mean to compare the 2 series, as I hate those arguments as well, but both books are similar in the passion they inspire in their readers.. I for one will certainly introduce my future children to Harry Potter and Twilight… and I know those stories will resonate just as much with them as they do with us. The fandom is not going anywhere.

All we can do now is hope that this movie will not lose so much in its translation to the big screen as the first one did.

Rob Keyes says:

After seeing many other panels over the weekend, the panel members for New Moon (aside from the director) did the worst at presenting themselves, responding to questions and simply being able to communicate :(

gottarhyme says:

Well,as you know, Melissa,I have read the books,and poorly written and unoriginal as they are, I understand the allure.

After all, Mills and Boon have just as big a following. It is not ‘high art’, but escapism pure and simple.

OMGaViking says:

This is ridiculous. It doesn’t matter whether or not you like the series (I for one can’t stand it), just because someone does not agree with your opinion doesn’t make them ‘inferior’ or ‘ignorant’ or ‘haters’ and if you don’t like it read/watch something else.

StacyQ says:

In my opinion, no movie will ever live up to the original novel. (Dune, Clan of the Cave Bear, any of the Harry Potters, etc..)

But yes, like Melissa says, hope springs eternal.

As for the popularity and longevety of the series, I believe it will endure. I have been reading vampire novels long enough that I remember when Anne Rice released Queen of the Dammed. And I’m a bookseller at a major chain to boot. A day dosent pass that we don’t sell two dozen of one of Meyers books. Recently I have read many of the other teen books revolving around the paranormal and believe me, Meyers is a better writer than most. Unfortunately, they are still just teen novels and I’m getting really tired of all that angsty moody teenage crap.

And since this is a movie site, yes I will run out to see the New Moon flick. I am a fan (oh horror!) and I am looking forward to it. I don’t bother seeing the Potter films anymore because I’m too tired of being disappointed. Give me a few years, I might burn out on Twilight too.

Ah, but hope springs eternal. (sigh)

Kiki says:

Hi im kiki and im a huge fan of twilight. im going to put out that iam a teen so im reveling in eveything teen right now. any ways ppl who slam twilight have probaly not read it. but just because these vampires glitter doesnt mean it sucks. as some of you may know or not there are several teen vampire novels out right now and the one thing that i have noticed is that evrey vampire IS different and what i mean is one vampire glitters, one vampire drinks true blood to live in society,one is filthy rich living in the upper east side of manhatten(blue bloods by melissa de la cruz, and one is BLADE. Twilight was Stephanie Meyers dream (litterally)so dont bash it. Every1 dreams. MLK had a dream and it came true. No need for example but look around… you are one.

Page 2 of 2«12
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.