‘Chuck vs the Other Guy’ Pits Hero Against Himself

Published 5 years ago by

zach levi yvonne strahovski brandon routh chuck Chuck vs the Other Guy Pits Hero Against Himself

There is nothing quite like watching an episode of Chuck in a convention hall with a thousand other fans.  Known well for its communal endeavors to keep Chuck on the air via twitter, blog and mail campaigns – from sending boxes of Nerds to NBC executives to flooding  corporate sponsor Subway’s comment card boxes with Chuck related notes – it is a vocal group.   Rarely is this more apparent then when they are gathered en masse and thrilling in perfect unison to one of the strongest episodes of Chuck‘s young televised life.

It takes watching an episode at a convention to truly realize what creators and writers Fedak and Schwartz (and co.) have done with Chuck- there is no division in fan opinion as the episode rolls along. Even when events aren’t foreshadowed so much as fore-broadcast, even when the events aren’t particularly surprising or seem, in fact, inexorable as fate, the gasps, laughs, applause, cries of victory and wordless murmurs of discontent sweep across the audience without a dissenting voice to be heard.  Everyone watching is rooting for the same things, and cannot help but be pleased by the way in which those things are delivered- with intelligence, warmth and humor.

In ‘Chuck vs the Other Guy‘,  we are given a season finale in mid-season. Fedak and Schwartz explained in the Q&A following the episode’s premier that the entire arc of the season had led to this episode and that the final moments of it could well have been the final moments of the show- they have heard no word on being picked up for a fourth season yet. That being the case, the episode delivers in every sense:  We are given closure to characters and events that have been happening all season long, albeit without definitively closing the door on any potential plots. Cleverly, though designed to be a book end, the episode acts as more of a portal, and the possibilities for new storylines spiral outward ad infinitum from it. From here on out, there will be major spoilers aplenty, so consider yourself warned.

The largest obstacles for Chuck Bartowski (Zachary Levi) this season have been The Ring, a shadow agency seeking to do everything the CIA and NSA do but in bad ways, and Agent Shaw (Brandon Routh), the devastatingly handsome, confident, polished spy who does not simply appropriate Bryce Larkin’s monopoly on that role, but brings a new level of gravitas and compassion to it. Bryce was ever the adrenaline junkie- Shaw is the steadfast leader, who nonetheless can kick ass, take names, and weaken the ladies’ knees with a simultaneously more serious but somehow more vulnerable hand. Shaw is Chuck’s real nemesis, being in every way a better spy and more reliable person, a mirror Chuck is none too pleased to have held up before him, but most egregiously by proving a much better match for the smart, tough and wholly self sufficient Agent Sarah Walker (Yvonne Strahovski). In ‘Chuck vs the Other Guy‘, the title alone promises a reckoning between our eponymous hero and the man who has been actively pursuing Chuck’s true love’s heart, but we get so much more than that.

chuck season 3 Chuck vs the Other Guy Pits Hero Against Himself

Shaw is an agent of the The Ring, helping them in their quest to build a better intersect in retribution for the CIA’s contracted murder of his wife Evelyn. The Agent responsible for her death?- Sarah Walker. In an elaborate scheme motivated by the deepest grief and a bone-deep disgust with the games played and mistakes made by the government, Shaw has decided to send a message to his employers: You betrayed the wrong person. He figures Sarah’s corpse will be far more effective than a Hallmark card.  But everyone trusts him, and so Sarah leaves with Shaw for what she thinks is a mission, and no one even thinks to be concerned.

Except Morgan Grimes, portrayed with a staggeringly consistent oddness by Josh Gomez. He adamantly protests the merit of Sarah going anywhere, let alone Paris (Chuck’s dream city, the physical location that manifests his equally, eternally just-out-of-reach life goals), with Daniel Shaw.  In an attempt to sway Morgan’s opinion of the man, Chuck shows him video footage of Shaw taking down enemy agents and saving Chuck and Sarah’s life. Except Morgan knows his HK cinema the way Ben Stiller knows his Star Trek- with an unhealthy degree of devotion and ability to retain details that no human eye should be capable of detecting- and so he points out that the fight was a big old stagey fake. Chuck protests that he witnessed Shaw shooting people Morgan prompts him, “Did you see blood? Did you see viscera?” Brain matter, et all, were in fact significantly lacking from the shoot out. Chuck is given no choice but to respond in the negative, the delivery of which is pure hilarity.

And so begins the mad scramble to find Sarah Walker. Finding no help from his ever-doubtful NSA General, he turns to the action man himself- John “I Will Kill You With My Awesome” Casey. No, that nickname isn’t canon, but it’s totally applicable.  At first resistant, due to his soul-crushing assimilation into Buymoria and civilian life, John of course steps up to help his team- now his friends- and even wears a nice suit while doing do.

En route to Paris, panicked by the seemingly endless crawl of the minutes spent helpless and in the air, Chuck gets a sharp reminder from John about who he is, why he’s our hero, and the audience gets a simply worded but extremely poignant remind of why Chuck is a good show, why the fans are devoted fans, why the team deserves to stay together and get as many seasons as they want to tell stories like this. John says, and I’m sadly paraphrasing, forget the spy stuff, forget the intersect. Before all of that, you were smart.

It is then those smarts that save the day.

Continue reading “‘Chuck vs the Other Guy’ Pits Hero Against Himself”

« 1 2»

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. This episode is why I love Chuck. Enough said

  2. Honestly, this may have been the high water mark of the series. To expect it to maintain these standards would be unrealistic. If this had been the final episode, WOW! It would have served well.

  3. I would have been happy with this being the final episode, but I am happiER that it isn't. I know each episode after this can't pack the same emotional punch or important moments, because this episode had a whole season building up to it, but I believe that they can match themselves in that way, at least- they can build important storylines, and reach this sort of point again.

    I just loved this episode. And I have to say, watching it with a big audience was extremely rewarding.

  4. Nice review. A few points, though. Shaw TURNED into a Ring member. When he sent Evelyn in undercover to the group, Graham figured she was a true agent. Sarah then ordered to kill her. When they hinted a Team Bartowski member would be turned, they went after Shaw. Showing him that video of Sarah killing Evelyn probably did it.

  5. Yes, absolutely. The review is operating from this episode's get go, at which point Shaw has already become an agent for The Ring, but you're right, I didn't mean to make it sound as if he always had been one.

  6. best episode.it more action than comedy

  7. Fantastic!

    I'd say for me “Chuck vs. the Colonel” is right up there with this one, perhaps even better as far as excitement goes, and even though I knew he would likely get it back, I'll never forget the immense relief I felt for Chuck when he got his wish of removing the Intersect from his head, but… “The Other Guy” has SO many satisfying moments, too — funny (drunk & despairing Chuck tying up Morgan with his video game controllers), silly (Chuck cancelling the tank), poignant (Casey's talk with Chuck on the flight to Paris), sad (Sarah realizing where Shaw had brought her and that it was all a lie), monumental (Chuck shooting Shaw) and of course, romantic and sweet (Chuck and Sarah's final scene). What an episode. Great job by all.

    I hope NBC keeps this show. It has so many stories yet to tell, for all the characters involved, and I really want to see them!

  8. And because I forgot to say it before… terrific article, Amanda. Love the analysis of Chuck vs. Shaw and Chuck vs. himself. I find that kind of discussion fascinating. *applauds*

  9. Good review. I'm pretty sad Agent Shaw died. :( Loved him.

  10. Best chuck episode ever! and great review! I seriously hope it gets renewed

  11. I know. His tragic past made me love him more. If only he hadn't been such a douche about it…. :(

  12. Awe! ohmigosh, thank you kindly! Chuck vs the Colonel is ALSO a fave, and I'm glad you liked the article!

    Yvonne had some really beautiful moments in this episode, my heart kept breaking for her. Tear!

  13. Thank you! Yeah, my fingers are crossed, too…

  14. I am so disappointed with this episode. I was hoping for some reason why Sarah chose to be with Shaw, and why she came up with ridiculous reasons not to be with Chuck. That was what bothered me practically this whole season. I thought there might be something deeper there, like perhaps she suspected Shaw was a double agent, and had to sell that she had fallen for him to figure out what was going on. We were promised over and over that there would be an explanation and closure, but I got none of that from this episode. The entire season has been one giant mess, I'm sorry I've been watching all this time and that I took the writers word for it that there would be a payoff.

  15. Awe :(. Now I'm just sad that you aren't happy.

  16. This episode was everything I'd hoped for out of Chuck and had, after some of the weaker 'will-he/won't-he-flash' episodes of the earlier season, despaired of ever seeing; but then just as you said, Chuck finds them not because of some piece of tech, or plot device… he saves them because he is a SMART MAN. It was that fact that I worried, pre-season, that the new Intersect 2.0 would take away from the show, and to see it back in force, as the saving grace, was such a relief.

    Now to just find a bad guy he can't intersect beat up. Well, Shaw in this ep, like you say – he shoots because he has the emotional resolution to shoot (almost a nice call back to the 'no flash required' moment of the previous ep, with a tranq gun), but in the earlier fight there was still the 'emotions, intersect no worky.' I just want to see elite training beat the stuff implanted in his head. Is that weird? It may be weird.

    Mostly, though, I am glad to see this episode. It would have been a great ending, and I'm excited to see where they go. I would have been worried, but… it was phenomenal. It was everything I wanted.

  17. Sarah was with Shaw because he was safe.
    He did not have the power Chuck has to hurt her.

    Remember in Pink Slip Chuck did not run away with her and that probably made her realize how easily Chuck could hurt her. At one point she tells Chuck that he can't hurt her (Three Little Words).

  18. The intersect did work, Shaw was just better. He also threw Chuck off balance by trying to use Chuck's defensive energy to stab Sarah. Chuck gave up some of his position by trying to prevent the knife from getting either him or Sarah and then Shaw knocked him wonky. Sarah and Casey can tell when Chuck flashes, Shaw apparently can”t. This was part of the theme of the episode: The intersect does not solve all problems!!

  19. To me Sarah was with Shaw because he was emotionally comforting, they had so much in common, and she was physically attracted to him too. The man was HOT. He was her perfect match… in another reality, under different circumstances. I actually wanted her to stay with him, but things turned out different. Plus this is Chuck's show. ;)

  20. yeah, Shaw was really badass. :D

  21. Exactly :(

  22. On E Online, they said this season is going for another 6 episodes yeah? I don't want Chuck to end, it's an emotionally packed, extremely funny show and I think there is quite a base of fans not ready to see it go just yet.

  23. Fantastic review!