10 Differences Between the ‘Carrie’ Remake & Original 1976 Movie

Published 8 months ago by This is a list post.

10 Differences Between the 'Carrie' Remake & Original 1976 Movie

Carrie Differences Remake Original Carrie may have taken her telekinetic wrath from the 1970s to modern day, but beyond that, Kimberly Peirce’s Carrie falls right in line with the Brian De Palma original. However, even though the films hit all the same beats, share character names, and even some dialogue, the 2013 version isn’t a total copy and paste job. The structure stays the same, but by using a little modernization, additional character details and new scenes here and there, Peirce essentially recreates the same experience while trying to make it her own (read our Carrie remake review). Whether or not that remake technique works for you, if you’re a fan of the original, it certainly makes pinpointing those differences an entertaining game. Check out all the changes we caught in the new Carrie and let us know which ones you spotted, too. It goes without saying that the following post contains SPOILERS for Carrie and the 2013 Carrie remake.

More Margaret White

Carrie Remake Movie Julianne Moore The moment Peirce and Co. cast Julianne Moore as Margaret White, you knew momma was getting more screen time. In fact, screenwriters Lawrence D. Cohen and Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa even gave Moore the first scene in the movie. In Stephen King’s book, there’s talk about Margaret’s confusion regarding that enormous (pregnant) mound in her midsection, but here, we actually see that scenario play out. The blood continues to flow for Margaret thanks to her self-mutilation habit. If she’s not bashing her head against a wall, she’s looking for the sharpest object in the room to give herself a quick jab. On a lighter note, whereas Margaret is mostly homebound in the first film, here we also get to see her hard at work as a seamstress, and according to Sue Snell’s mother, she’s a very talented one, too.

Sue Snell’s Expecting

Carrie Remake Sue Snell One of the biggest differences between the 1976 release and this new edition is the big finish. Carrie still stabs her mother to death before literally tearing down the house, but before she’s buried alive, she comes face to face with Sue Snell. Even though Sue just watched Carrie murder half of her peers, she’s still hell-bent on doing her good deed, so tries to coax Carrie out of the home before it crumbles. Carrie refuses, but before giving Sue the boot, she informs Sue that she’s having a baby girl. On top of walking away from this rendition pregnant, Sue Snell also walks away with her sanity. Whereas Sue Snell #1 is left broken and disturbed, Gabriella Wilde’s version struts off with a bun in the oven and enough composure to leave a flower at Carrie’s grave.

Chris Hargensen is Pure Evil

Carrie Remake Movie Chris Hargensen Nancy Allen’s Chris Hargensen was your typical high school mean girl. She was popular, had a big mouth, and took pride in torturing girls like Carrie. Not only did this Carrie come with a blonde/brunette swap – Sue Snell becoming a blonde with a heart and Chris turning into a sassy brunette – but the film also turned Chris into a deeply malicious person. Back in 1976, John Travolta’s Billy Nolan took care of business and beat the life out of a poor pig with a sledgehammer, but the 1976 Chris didn’t then hop over the fence and enthusiastically slit the pig’s throat. Portia Doubleday’s Chris does exhibit inklings of thoughtfulness, like when she gets a look at the gym all decorated for prom and realizes that she won’t be there to enjoy it, but considering that Chris ultimately demands that Billy run Carrie over with his car, those moments wind up feeling a bit out of character.

Welcome to the 21st Century, Carrie

Carrie Remake Movie Chloe Grace Moretz It’s a new Carrie for a new generation. There’s no modern movie without modern technology, and Moretz’s Carrie certainly feels that wrath. Instead of the pad and tampon-throwing incident becoming a thing of the past, a little cell phone recording and YouTube uploading lets the event plague Carrie throughout the movie. The camerawork even gets a 21st century twist by adopting a shaky camera, POV perspective during the prom sequence. The term “dirty pillows” didn’t seem to appease a contemporary audience considering it gave the large majority a case of the giggles, but a Tim Tebow reference wasn’t particularly well received either. The modern spin on the classic tale also turned the original film’s score on its head. There are no foreboding orchestral tones here, just unexceptional background music that transitions to soundtrack-friendly tunes like Vampire Weekend’s “Diane Young” during prom time.

Fewer Taboos

Carrie Remake Movie Alex Russell Billy Stabbing a character with a dozen knives and having another smash through a windshield is cool, but a couple face-slaps here and there is not. Ms. Desjardin still gives Carrie a good smack during her shower meltdown, but other than that, all violence beyond the horror-themed set pieces has been removed. Ms. Desjardin keeps her hands to herself when punishing Chris for the tampon incident as does Billy when the couple is driving along - but perhaps that’s just because Chris doesn’t call him a “stupid sh*t” in this one. Alex Russell’s Billy also takes a pass on drinking and driving this round, which is somewhat surprising considering the new Billy has lost all of Travolta’s goofiness and instead comes across as an all-around bad kid with zero compassion and a reckless reputation.

More Gore

Carrie Remake Movie Blood Chloe Grace Moretz Both versions of Carrie rock R-ratings, but the 2013 film really takes it to heart. Other than a very graphic version of the pig-killing scene, Peirce’s Carrie stays pretty tame until the grand finale – but at that point, all bets are off. Kids are going to die and you’re going to see it. Carrie’s victims aren’t just dragged around the gym and sprayed with a hose. Moretz’s targets are vividly electrocuted, crushed in bleachers, and more. And the massacre doesn’t end there. This time around, Carrie doesn’t just flip Chris and Billy’s getaway car, watch it explode, and call it quits. She tortures them. Carrie bashes Billy’s face in - right in front of Chris - and then locks her in the car and hurls the vehicle into a gas station. However, even though those stunts run red to the max, it’s the unnervingly intimate and thorough presentation of Margaret’s self-mutilation routine that’ll make your skin crawl the most.

Foreshadowing

Carrie Remake Margaret White Julianne Moore In Brian De Palma’s original, when Carrie is about to boil over, you don’t see it coming. Here, however, Peirce is constantly dropping hints that Carrie is prepping to put her abilities to use. Before Carrie smashes Principal Morton’s water cooler to bits, the water bubbles in the background. There’s also an instance involving a paper cut hinting at the bloodshed to come - and then one during which Chris sends a text message to Sue from the prom, boasting that something terrible is about to happen to Carrie. If you’re someone who’s seen the original film dozens of times over, these moments are bound to feel heavy-handed. Peirce’s film sticks so close to the progression of the original narrative that you always know what’s coming, making this technique (for many) unnecessarily repetitive.

Carrie Speaks Up

Carrie Remake Chloe Grace Moretz Julianne Moore Not only is this Carrie only a smile away from coming across as a pretty young woman, but she’s far more eloquent, too. Gone are the days of Sissy Spacek’s eerie whispering. Moretz’s Carrie is still a total outcast with a preference for sticking to corners, but when Carrie does feel the need to speak, she does so with far more confidence. Yes, she still begs Tommy to stay in the car for a moment longer because she’s nervous to walk into the prom, but when she does, Moretz’s intonation implies that she’s doing so with a hint of self-assurance. We also see quite a bit of this during Carrie’s conversations with her mother. Spacek’s character was clearly more comfortable talking to momma than the kids at school, but Moretz takes that one major step further by essentially bossing her mother around. We get a handful of scenes during which Carrie cowers as her mother raises her voice and gives her a good smack, but beyond that, Carrie’s running this show.

Carrie’s a Telekinesis Pro

Carrie Remake Movie Telekinesis Chloe Grace Moretz Carrie’s newfound confidence is likely directly connected to the fact that in Peirce’s film, she’s a telekinesis whiz. Spacek’s character slowly becomes aware of her abilities after putting them to use involuntarily. Moretz’s version, on the other hand, makes tampons float, demolishes a water cooler, does a bit of light reading and then is ready to crack mirrors at will, float furniture, and banish her mother to the closet. To go with her more deft telekinetic control, Moretz also utilizes a far more defined physical form to make those things happen. Spacek just stands there with a blank stare on her face, merely eying a target before harming them. In the new Carrie, Moretz is literally moving her body with the action, controlling objects as though one would move things around on an iPad.

No Red Baseball Hat

Carrie Remake Norma PJ Soles Whether you’ve seen the 1976 Carrie once or dozens of times, I’d like to bet you remember P.J. Soles’ Norma. No? Can’t recall a Norma? How about the character wearing a red hat? You absolutely cannot have a female character strut around throughout an entire film donning a bright red baseball hat and not have people notice. Norma even wears the thing to prom while in a dress! Sadly there is no red hat-wearing character in Peirce’s film, but there is one quick glimpse at a character donning a white one that somewhat resembles the original accessory.

Conclusion

Carrie Differences Remake Original What other differences between Kimberly Peirce’s 2013 Carrie remake and Brian De Palma's original 1976 movie (not to mention Stephen King's novel) did you notice? As mentioned the list is not all-inclusive, so share your picks and reactions in the comments. Still undecided about the film, read our Carrie movie review or go discuss Carrie Spoilers with those who have already seen it! For an in-depth discussion of the film by the Screen Rant editors check out our Carrie episode of the SR Underground podcast. ___ Carrie is now playing in theaters.
TAGS: carrie

48 Comments

Post a Comment

  1. G’DAY TO WHOM THIS MAYBE ONE THING CARRIE MOIVE FIRST 1976 2 THE CARRIE 2 HAD OTHER KIDS WITH POWERS LIKE THE X MEN 3 THIS ONE ONLY ABOUT CARRIE WHITE LKIE OLDDER PITCHER SCREEN FROM 1970′S SAME PLOT 4 THERE WAS NO INTERNET AT THE TIME NO VIDEOS ON INTERNET POSTED NO MOBILE PHONE AT THE TIME 5 CARRIE MUM MOER CRAZY IN THE NEW ONE THIS NEW VERSION IS ALL MOST LIKE THE FIRST 6 THERE WAS 3 MOVIES ABOUT CARRIE WHITE IT THE NEW THEY BILLY THE b**** GIRLFRIEND UP IN CATWALK IN THE OLDDER VERSION THEY UNDER THE TABLE 7 THIS NEW ONE 2013 – 2014 IS MUCH AWESOMER THEN THE FIRST THE CARRIE 2 WITH KIDS POWERS LIKE THE X MEN CARTOON TRY TO STOP HERE CARRIE 3 YOU WILL KNOW HER NAME HER MUM WAS MORE TWISTED THEN THE FIRST

  2. A whole lot of what I read put down Carrie II as just a facelift of Carrie I, but absolutely not! If you’re gonna retell a story, then you should retell the story, and Carrie II does that, but with such new features and such a new feel as to make it a wholly new, and in my opinion, much better movie. The cars are cooler, and the bad girls are cooler — great introduction of a pair of bad-girl twins — although I did miss the little jerk i8n the baseball cap not getting put down. Like any movie with Julianne Moore, the damn thing has gone politically correct on us (lacrosse (?) instead of football as the hero’s sport) but I could stomach that…

  3. The remake sucks. Sissy Spacek gave more life to the carácter,

  4. I liked more how sissy spacek portrayed the role..’though as far as effects are concerned, Carrie2 of course nailed it..there were nudity involved in Carrie1..and the boyfriend of sue snell in Carrie2 seemed more sincere and kind despite hesitancy at first to take carrie to the prom.. unlike in carrie1, the guy made the idea appear ludicrous and funny, just doing it for the girlfriend.. he seemed naughtier, which I think is more realistic since he’s a jock and considering the reputation of carrie in campus..sue snell in carrie2 isn’t shocked at all by what happened considering her boyfriend died and of the enormous deaths, even went to carrie’s house without fear..carrie1 was more realistic in this since sue was left shocked and scarred..carrie1 main character chloe, too young compared to her co stars ages ranging to 25 up…they were supossed to be graduating seniors here.,

Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.

Be Social, Follow Us!!