Captain America: Chad Michael Murray vs. Ryan McPartlin?

Published 5 years ago by , Updated February 6th, 2010 at 9:27 pm,

captain america casting soon Captain America: Chad Michael Murray vs. Ryan McPartlin?

It’s an exciting time for Marvel movie fans with Kenneth Branagh’s Thor heavy into principal photography having begun last month and Joe Johnston’s The First Avenger: Captain America likely to announce the casting of its lead character Steve Rogers within the next few weeks.

With the casting of superheroes comes plenty of rumors and speculation and we have two names for you of possible leading candidates for the career-defining role of the WWII veteran and later leader of The Avengers in Ryan McPartlin (Chuck) and Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill).

If either of these two choices come to fruition it would appear that TV stars have been recently getting some big attention in Hollywood as Stargate: Atlantis’ Jason Momoa was also just cast as the title character in the Conan remake.

In an interview with Moviehole, Chuck actor Ryan McPartlin revealed that he has read for the part of Captain America, something we expect a plethora of young actors have done in recent weeks.

“The one thing I can’t stand are these actors that are twittering about auditioning for Captain America. It’s really tacky. With that said, it is in the casting process and like many other actors, I read for it, so we’ll wait and see what happens. Regardless, I’m pretty psyched to be Captain Awesome for the time being.”

By his comment about the tweets, I’m sure McPartlin is referring to the likes of relative unknown Johnny Pacar who tweeted about auditioning for Captain America in mid-January.

captain america cast Ryan McPartlin Captain America: Chad Michael Murray vs. Ryan McPartlin?

Ryan McPartlin as Captain America?

So, who is McPartlin competing against? Probably a ton of folks but if this next rumor is true, it might be down to him and Chad Michael Murray. Big Shiny Robot is reporting the following via a forum member who frequents an LA hotspot where Murray was spotted talking about Captain America, possible revealing something very interesting.

So I work in a place outside of LA where some celebrities frequent. Chad Michael Murray is one of these people. He was in the other night and one of his friends with him told me that the casting for Cap is down to Chad and one other person. He didn’t tell more who the other person is perhaps he didn’t know, but I found it interesting. The friend told me that he’d have to lend Chad all his comics and teach him about the background of the character.

Before anyone gets any ideas, this is only a rumor and we have no way of validating it. The timing however, does work and some folks on the internet have thrown out Chad Michael Murray. Then again, what actor hasn’t been talked about for this role?

captain america cast Chad Michael Murray Captain America: Chad Michael Murray vs. Ryan McPartlin?

Chad Michael Murray as Captain America?

If this is true and Chad’s buddy spilled the beans then perhaps the leading two candidates are Ryan McPartlin and Chad Michael Murray. One thing’s for sure; We’ll find out soon.

Who should play Steve Rogers/Captain America? Out of these to, I say McPartlin. He played Captain Awesome in Chuck and it doesn’t get much closer than that ;).

Make sure to check out our posts on director Joe Johnston’s ideas for the movie and a possible design of Captain America’s costume.

Sources: Moviehole, Big Shiny Robot

Follow me on Twitter @rob_keyes

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. I agree. The role definitely needs to be more of a mid-30 type guy. I just don't believe the likes of a God of Thunder and a multi-billion dollar tycoon would listen to anything some young-20-something would have to say.

  2. I hope that neither of these two actors is chosen! The movie is called Captain America, not Dawson's Creek! We need someone who can act! Not a teenage hearthrob to try and get young girls to see the movie!

  3. I think chad is a good choice. I mean C'mon we shouldn't think he isnt fit for it. Remember when we said that heath wasnt good for joker? I dunno maybe chad would be a good fit as cap..

  4. I think chad is a good choice. I mean C'mon we shouldn't think he isnt fit for it. Remember when we said that heath wasnt good for joker? I dunno maybe chad would be a good fit as cap..

  5. hey fri
    I can't watch your movies
    but I like u as my bro.I m in Myanmar
    iI invite u to my country.

  6. This article doesn’t make any sense when it comes to the tweets issue. Every actor updates what is going on in their life and the new projects they are cast in or hoping to be cast in. Also, they said something about “relative unknown” Johnny Pacar. Johnny Pacar is more well known than Ryan McPartlin, who’s statement is speculated as to be aimed at Pacar. Maybe you should find a 10-25 year old girl and ask them who Johnny Pacar is. Chances are they will tell you, he’s currently co-starring on ABC Family’s Record-breaking new show, Make It Or Break It, who comes back for a second season at the end of this month. I had no idea who McPartlin is. As for CMM, he’s an incredible actor but picturing him as Captain America seems that he’d be too pretty boy. I think Chris Evans is perfect to play big screen versions of comic stars – but I highly doubt he’ll do another one after his amazing run with Fantastic Four.

  7. Chad should have been Cap. Chris Evans is an EPIC FAIL