Details on Bryan Singer’s Abandoned ‘Star Trek: Federation’ TV Show

Published 4 years ago by , Updated July 18th, 2014 at 9:56 am,

bryan singer star trek federation Details on Bryan Singers Abandoned Star Trek: Federation TV Show

Hollywood is filled with fascinating “What if…” tales regarding films & television shows that (for better or worse) never came to fruition. Sometimes it’s the simple notion of a different lead actor or director being attached to the production before dropping out. Other times, these stories involve a surprisingly unique approach to a beloved property – one that would have steered the franchise in question down a completely different road.

Last year, we learned a little bit about the Superman Returns sequel Bryan Singer was developing before Warner Bros. decided to reboot the series with Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel. As it turns out, Singer was also involved with another high profile project that ultimately never came together – a new Star Trek TV series set several centuries after The Next Generation.

Earlier this month, Jonathan Frakes (Commander Riker) revealed to UGO that he had pitched a Star Trek show to Paramount that would have centered around Riker’s exploits on board the USS Titan. The studio told him that they were putting the franchise on the back burner for a little while – and that they had also recently rejected pitches from William Shatner and Singer.

The speculation over what Singer’s proposed series might have been about prompted TrekMovie to shed some light on what actually transpired between the acclaimed filmmaker and Paramount. It began in December of 2005 when Singer, screenwriter Christopher McQuarrie (The Usual Suspects, The Wolverine), and director Robert Meyer Burnett (Free Enterprise) met for dinner and started toying around with the idea of pitching a new Star Trek TV show.

By the time their dinner was over, it had been decided that Burnett would draft a series proposal that the team would take to Paramount once Singer was finished with post-production on Superman Returns. Burnett enlisted writer Geoffrey Thorne (Leverage) to help him put together a 25-page long proposal that outlined their approach to the material, the show’s main characters, and the story arc for the first four episodes. They titled their series Star Trek: Federation.

Paramount never rejected their pitch, however – because it was never made. Before Singer and Co. could present Federation to the studio, it was announced that J.J. Abrams had been hired to direct a new Star Trek movie. Realizing that an updated grand design for the franchise had already been constructed, the team abandoned their project.

Star Trek Sequel Details on Bryan Singers Abandoned Star Trek: Federation TV Show

Abrams' film dashed plans for Singer's proposed TV series.

Regardless, it’s always fun to take a look at what might have been and TrekMovie has some interesting excerpts from Burnett & Thorne’s proposal. The main difference between their series and Abrams’ Trek is that Federation would have taken place in the original timeline. Still, they recognized that the Star Trek brand needed to be revitalized and their proposal began with an explanation of how they hoped to accomplish that:

The great strength of STAR TREK is the very Universe in which it’s set. The Characters. The Starships. The Aliens. The stories. Gene Roddenberry himself provided the perfect example how to create a wildly successfully new STAR TREK series…

Acknowledge what’s come before, but then set your stage far enough in the STAR TREK future when everything old is new again.Turn the STAR TREK Universe upside down. Shake vigorously.

Utopia as a goal is like the fire in a nuclear engine. Utopia in practice is stagnation; it’s dry rot; eventually it’s death. Which is precisely where we find the United Federation of Planets a few centuries after the last Age of Discovery.

Basically, this would have been a darker and more dangerous time for the Federation and the idea was that its decay could be used as an allegory for the Fall of the Roman Empire. According to the proposal, “Starfleet has been reduced to a ‘mere peace-keeping force’ protecting fringe worlds from aliens and from fighting each other, with starships that are old and spread out too thin.”

The appearance of a powerful new enemy knows as “The Scourge” would have lead to the creation of another USS Enterprise – the first in over 300 years. On the surface, the Enterprise’s mission would have been one of exploration – but her real mission would have been to investigate The Scourge in order to save what was left of the Federation.

Bryan Singer Christopher McQuarrie and Tom Cruise Valkyrie set Details on Bryan Singers Abandoned Star Trek: Federation TV Show

Bryan Singer and Christopher McQuarrie on the set of Valkyrie.

Continue reading for Singer’s list of characters and more story details…


Here’s a character breakdown of the ship’s main crew:

Captain Alden Montgomery: Human and the “perfect Starfleet officer” who is “The Captain America of the Federation” but who unfortunately gets killed off early on, leaving room for…

Commander Alexander Kirk: (X-O and 3rd in command) Reinstated for the new mission Kirk is described as having a “checkered past” with an “aggressive manner” who is thrust into leading the mission after Montgomery and first officer get killed and is able to deal with it well, but is “total crap at PR aspects of job.” He alone (even though he doesn’t understand it) “possesses information vital to Enterprise’s true mission.”

Lt. Cmdr. Chel Forlaan (Security Chief): A female Ektosi (a feline species) who has “cat-like” grace, temper and insight with natural hand-to-hand combat capabilities akin to Jem Hadar or Klingons. Joined Starfleet for the “fun,” posesses a “mercurial nature” which initially makes her ill-suited to security chief. Biggest flaw is “intense curiosity which sometimes overpowers her.”

Lt. Cmdr. Sergei Kenyatta (Com & Political Officer): A genetically enhanced human “Alpha” from Proxima Centauri, with a perfect physique along with mental enhancements. Described as gifted in math, linguistics, technology, and diplomacy, yet struggles with personal relationships.

The 76th Distillation of Blue (aka Diz) (Chief Engineer): a member of a gaseous species from the gas giant Penumbra who use “motion suits” to interact with the rest of the “solid” universe. For the show Diz would look like “a slender male humanoid” in the suit, but he can also appear in his gasous state or even change to a solid or a liquid, but he is “not a shape shifter.” Described as a fantastic engineer who is more at home with machines than with other people.

Dr. Felicity Chen: A cybernetically enhanced physician based on (now safely evolved) Borg technology. Many medical instruments are built into her, so no need for tricorder. She can use her “nanospines” to heal injuries, but there is a personal cost to her. She still has to wrestle with her own humanity.

M.A.J.E.L.: The sentient Enterprise computer (Multitronic Architecture Junction/Interactive Energetic Library) that runs the ship and has a personality of her own, including emotions.

Admiral Nelscott: Female Starfleet admiral who saw the threat of The Scourge and bucked the system to get the Enterprise project launched. Not on board the ship, but issuing orders from Starfleet HQ.

Honestly, a lot of those character quirks seem incredibly redundant to me – and I think the name of the computer (a reference to Majel Barrett-Roddenberry) is a nice homage, but possibly a little too overt. There’s certainly a lot of variety, but part of the proposal insisted that “audiences must recognize the world they live in today in the far-flung future, then take the show’s concepts and lessons with them back into their everyday lives”.  I’m not saying that Federation wouldn’t have accomplished this – only that the show’s ensemble seems like it might have been too abstract to attract new viewers. Unfortunately, that’s something that Star Trek was in dire need of.

The fourth episode would have resolved The Scourge storyline (temporarily), but as a result:

Frictions between the Federation and the Klingons have never been worse. The internal fissures are growing wider based largely on Enterprise’s secret mission and Admiral Nelscott’s lies to cover up that mission with the council. And, of course, lots and lots of people died.

What’s next for the survivors of these events? Tune in next week, folks.

Star Trek 2009  Details on Bryan Singers Abandoned Star Trek: Federation TV Show

'Star Trek: Federation' would have depicted the adventures of a new USS Enterprise

Be sure to check out TrekMovie for even more details about Star Trek: Federation – including a brief episode synopsis and an explanation of how technology would have advanced since the days of The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager.

I liked Abrams’ Star Trek movie and I’m looking forward to Star Trek 2 – but I still believe that television is more conducive to the property’s original intentions. In my opinion, none of the films featuring The Next Generation‘s cast hold a candle to some of the better episodes of the series (most of them seemed to contradict fundamental aspects of the characters and lose their focus entirely).

The reality is that Abrams’ film probably did a better job of bringing in a general audience and wiping the slate clean than any television series could have. I know fans are still divided on Abrams’ approach – and I miss the intelligent and more introspective Trek stories as much as any longtime fan – but I’m still optimistic that the next film (and future installments) can retain what worked with Abrams’ first Star Trek movie while introducing more of the spiritual & moral dilemmas that previous incarnations were known for.

Either way, it’s intriguing to examine an alternate direction that the Star Trek franchise might have taken.

Source: TrekMovie.

« 1 2View All»

TAGS: Star trek
Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. I really want a new Star Trek TV series on the air soon the CW has expressed interest in a new Star Trek TV series.

    • They really haven’t. At least not yet. The head of CW was asked by a reporter on a press tour whether they’d ever be interested in doing Star Trek. He said he’d love to do Trek and is a fan — but that as far as he knows there’s been zero talk of bringing Trek back to TV. It’s kind of like someone asking me if I’d ever want to go to Europe, me saying sure, and then they start telling folks that “hey, Jack says he wants to go to Europe!” And then everybody starts asking me about my itinerary and where I’ll be staying — and I don’t have one because it was a completely general question.

      So unless that reporter had secret knowledge of secret plans for a series, it was just kind of a ‘what if’ question, no?

    • I certainly hope so! Star Treks needs to get the ball rolling, I’m talking about a series not a movie. Right now I’m enjoying Star Wars Rebels the animated series. Now the balls in Star Trek’s court to make another TV series. It could be animated, a web series, whatever I’m kind of desperate for a Star Trek series now!

      • I’ll even settle for a returning Star Trek series.

  2. you know what makes me sick of TNG that crew was so positive and smiling and peacful YUCK that;s why DS9 rukes DS9 was the Darker side of the Federation it had a War Arc it had interpersonal conflict among the crew alot of blood bath episodes in fact DS9 season 4 Epissode 1 the way of the warrior that was a great blood bath episode as I call it because they killed more Klingons and destroyed more Ships in that episode alone then the entire TNG series just that episode alone because the sation had to defend themselves against a Klingon armada so they destroyes many ships and when the Klingons beamed on the station alot more Klingons died and also even Micheal Dorn said this but DS9 more realistic cause they acted like normal people with Problems what you call Cave men Walter is none other then people Acting Normal of today, also if you compare the TNG series premere to DS9 series Premere you would notice that in TNG’s series premere they were all smiling everyone was happy and positive YUCK but in DS9 series premere they were on Edge no one wanted to be there the Commander Sisko told Picard off the first time he saw him well in a way he told him off but he hatted Picard I don’t blame him and to top things off the cardassians were threating to take back the Staition I love DS9 a big Improvment to TNG and this Star Trek Federation Pitch would be a bigger improvement for the Star Trek series.

  3. Well now that Orci has evicted the big chair along with writers JD Payne and Patrick Mackay and installed Justin Lin in the big chair and brought Simon Peg and Doug Jung to write the new Pitch for the movie I feel better cause the Script I heard that Orci JD Payne and Patrick Mackay Wrote was too much like a TOS episode or worse a TNG Episode they wanted to make the Audience think it was supposed to be more thoughtful Story telling and less Action and Paramount Kicked them off the Project cause modern day Audiences won’t like that they want ACTION and thank god they got Justin Lin as the Director he did a great Job as Director of the Fast and the furious movies he is a great Action Director.

  4. The problem with a new series is that to capture the Trekie audience you have to change with the times and be creative in new ways that that are risky.

  5. Sounds like it would have been a flop, like he was trying to hard. I would rather see Riker as captain in a Titan series.

  6. I’m still crying about the demise of Enterprise many years ago. It was dark and primitive space exploration. Scott Bakula was well cast, as were they all. But I agree, we need a new Star Trek. It’s time !!