‘Boardwalk Empire’ Season 3, Episode 8: ‘The Pony’ Recap

Published 2 years ago by

Michael Stuhlbarg in Boardwalk Empire The Pony Boardwalk Empire Season 3, Episode 8: The Pony Recap

As one of the oft-repeated ideas for this season of Boardwalk Empire, there seems to be no end to problems, pending or otherwise, that Nucky Thompson (Steve Buscemi) cannot turn around to better favor his position. This is, of course, referring to Nucky’s rather bold approach to Andrew Mellon (James Cromwell) as a means of circumventing the imminent indictment against him by Harry Daugherty (Christopher McDonald), and making George Remus (Glenn Fleshler) an example of the Volstead Act.

Making moves to better one’s position – or at least alter the course of another’s – is at the heart of ‘The Pony.’ There’s quite a lot happening that helps carry a sense of urgency throughout the episode, which may be linked to the sheer amount of information being pumped out, but by and large, the stage is most certainly set for the season’s climax.

For a short while, things were looking good for Nucky. Sure, he’d managed to get into a fistfight with a young actor who’d been palling around with Billie Kent (Meg Steedle) after the two shared a brilliant screen test for a new movie, but Billie calmed the situation down and soothed Nucky’s ego enough for him to have a frank conversation about his desires regarding her, and just what Billie saw in her future. Ms. Kent explains to her “gangster” that she’s been on her own for a while, and has no intention of letting Nucky – or any man, for that matter – take her away from her dreams, even if that means she won’t be taken care of. If nothing else, Billie’s a woman who likes her independence.

James Cromwell Boardwalk Empire The Pony Boardwalk Empire Season 3, Episode 8: The Pony Recap

Meanwhile, Mellon – a man who enjoys a kind of independence on an entirely different scale – calls Nucky to welcome him into the fold, so to speak. It turns out, Nucky’s proposal to sink Daugherty and Remus, in exchange for secretly running Mellon’s distillery, was right on the money – which makes the sum Nucky paid to Gaston Bullock Means (Stephen Root) a worthwhile investment. At any rate, Mellon accepts the deal and Remus looks to get what was coming to Nucky. All in all, things are looking up, and as such, Nucky deserves a night out with Billie, Arnold Rothstein (Michael Stuhlbarg) and Lucky Luciano (Vincent Piazza).

Then it happens: Small talk actually proves useful, and in this case, saves the lives of Nucky and his gangster friends. Billie, unfortunately, doesn’t appear to be so lucky. A shockingly large blast, courtesy of Gyp Rosetti (Bobby Cannavale,) erupts from inside Babette’s, engulfing Billie and generally laying waste to a significant section of the boardwalk.

‘The Pony’ serves as an awakening for several characters; namely, Gillian (Gretchen Mol), Margaret (Kelly Macdonald) and certainly the woefully underused Nelson Van Alden/George Mueller (Michael Shannon). But most of all, it’s a wake-up call for Nucky, who’s been on a sort of Don Draper-like “love leave” with Billie (or should I say Nadine Beckenbauer?) all season long, and as a result, there are a great many things in his business that require some immediate attention. So now that poor, adorable Billie Kent stands as the first major casualty in the war Joe Masseria (James Ciccone) and Gyp have decided to wage against Rothstein and his associates, it’s safe to say that Nucky’s attention is no longer divided.

Meg Steedle in Boardwalk Empire The Pony Boardwalk Empire Season 3, Episode 8: The Pony Recap

As far as sides go, it’s clear which one Gillian is on after Nucky pays the grieving mother a visit to discuss the recently announced passing of one James Darmody (who happened to be cremated just in case someone thought he resembled a guy named Roger from Indiana). A splash of bourbon in his face is enough to let Nucky know Gillian’s aware the true nature of her son’s sudden disappearance, but she comes right out and says it anyway. For his part, Nucky reminds her that her little “health club” endeavor only exists because he allows it; a fact that likely carried a lot of weight in her decision to pass along Nucky and Rothstein’s whereabouts to Rosetti – Luciano’s presence likely serving as icing on the cake. What’s unclear, however, is just whose side Richard Harrow (Jack Huston) is on, after being the only one to call foul on the mockery Gillian was making of Jimmy’s memory.

At the same time, the non-vaudevillian reference to the episode’s title is the actual pony Margaret is looking at as a gift for her daughter. Since he knows a thing or two about horses – and he can drive – she brings Owen (Charlie Cox) along, and they soon find themselves sitting out a sudden rainstorm in the car. She asks if he’ll teach her to drive…“after,” which is, in Margaret’s own way, her moving on and taking control of certain things in her life. The affair with Owen is clearly no longer a one-time deal, as noted by the afternoon tryst and her interest in procuring a method of birth control, but being taught to drive is in some small way Margaret’s attempt to emulate Carrie Duncan and to grasp the things the late aviatrix represented. Let’s just hope things turn out better for Margaret than they did Carrie.

Finally, back in Cicero, it looks as though Johnny Torrio (Greg Antonacci) is ready to kick back and relax following his rather eye-opening holiday in Naples. Torrio’s full of espresso, sambuca and fond memories of the less-stressful way of life he witnessed during his travels, and seems content to let things stay in the increasingly capable hands of Al Capone (Stephen Graham). For his part, Capone manages to handle the meeting with Dion O’Banion (Arron Shiver) without Mueller having to resort to pulling any of his irons out of the case he carries with him.

Michael Shannon in Boardwalk Empire The Pony Boardwalk Empire Season 3, Episode 8: The Pony Recap

Of course, that doesn’t stop George from going ballistic on his co-worker during a mock sales pitch. After George is relentlessly razzed, he neatly presses his tormenter’s face with a hot iron, and then tosses around a few typewriters for good measure. Later, Van Alden hilariously stumbles through yet another sales pitch, but this time to his wife Sigrid (Christiane Seidel), regarding an impromptu relocation program. For whatever reason, Sigrid seems to be the Van Alden whisperer and sits her husband down to explain that in addition to distilling whiskey for O’Banion, she’s devised a clever cash-making scheme for them as well. It may involve peddling booze to the Norwegian contingent in Cicero and Chicago, but it’s a great deal better than schlepping a case full of electric irons around town.

Boardwalk Empire continues next Sunday with ‘The Milkmaid’s Lot’ @9pm on HBO. Check out a preview of the episode below:

Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. Great episode! Things are really starting to heat up for this season!

  2. Maybe leaving it open for Jimmy’s return at some point??

    • denial

  3. How would Jimmy return exactly?

  4. loved the ending

  5. As much fun as Gyp has been this season (still can’t get the “I’m gonna **** the redhead” out of my brain. It’s an applicable response to all problems in life, whether a redhead is about or not), Meg Steedle was simply hypnotic as Billie Kent. She will be missed. Anyways, always fun to see Michael Shannon go the full mental…

    • agree Michael Shannon was the second best thing that happened even though i wished it had happened sooner.

    • I am in complete agreement with you about Steedle as Billie Kent, too! She was just adorable in the screen test, even more than in the other things she’s done. I don’t get why her hair was bleached in the end, though. I thought it might have been because the character was going to have a film career but, barring some miracle, that wasn’t it!

  6. hypnotic, adorable Billie Kent? Were we watching the same show? Steedle’s been nothing but annoying since her debut on the series. When the bomb exploded, I clapped and yelled YES YES YES. Honestly, she’s been a drag on the storylines and everytime I saw her mouth open, I muted the TV.

    Richard needs to have more quality time, he’s a great character and Jack Huston is sorely underused. I still can’t figure out why he’s been staying with nutjob Gillian, and I would think the way she ‘honored poor Jimmy’ would be the final straw.

    • I’m guessing that Harrow is going to have to choose between killing Gillian or Nucky, and of course, he’ll end up killing Gillian. Like son/ like mother, she will end up being an example of what happens to someone when they betray Nucky Thompson.

      The war is going to be interesting. Gyp narrowly misses AR and Nucky, and will most likely pay for it, just like Capone’s hit man narrowly missed Nucky in season 2, and Jimmy paid for it.

      I agree with Vicki S’ assessment of the Billie Kent character. The one criticism of this show is that they sometimes beat viewers over the head with an aspect of the show that can be made clear far more quickly. For example, Nucky’s smitten with Billie – he wants to be as much of a father figure to her as he wants to be her lover. His infatuation with her is causing him to take his eye off the ball. We get it. That whole thing could have been explained in a few scenes rather than dedicating a quarter of every episode to her.

  7. wtf richard was in the episode for like 45 seconds thats some bs

  8. Does anyone else think that Van Aldan’s wife kicks a$$ over Nucky’s wife? She brains a federal agent, helps hide the body, makes all the booze and then sells some of on the street. All Margaret does is whine about her birth control class and sleep around (ok so does Nucky). No contest!

    • Margaret used to be like Mrs. VanAlden. But she is mad with Nucky for some reason that hasn’t been discussed and keeps him at arms length.

  9. Do you think rosetti really was the one behind the explosion? I really thought that wasn’t Rosetti’s style and thought it may have been someone else. How could he set that much in motion in that short amount of time. The xplosion was huge

    • I think it was Gyp Rosetti, but with guidance from Joe Masseria, as Rosetti isn’t really smart enough to pull off something like that.

      Also, historically, doesn’t the whole Andrew Mellon thing result it Elliot Ness bringing down Al Capone?

      Also, thank god they got rid of the Billie Kent character. Hopefully the writers figure out a cool way to get rid of Margaret as well… the whole thing with her women’s health clinic is getting really annoying and redundant. Maybe Nucky has her offed when he finds out about her and Owen? Maybe Nucky offs both of them?

      • It’s interesting that they show Luciano working a lot with Meyer Lansky and Ben “Bugsy” Siegel. He also worked just as much with Frank Costello and Vito Genovese. It is true that there was a war with Rothstein and Luciano versus Masseria. It was basically the old line Sicilian bosses versus the Young Turks. I guess it all depends on how long they keep the show, how much history it covers to see if the end results of that war play out.

      • Historically, Harry Daugherty does go down, but more for other scandals in the Harding administration (which was likely the most corrupt in American history) like Teapot Dome than for anything involving Prohibition.

    • HUGE? IT WAS FRIGGIN RIDICULOUSLY HUGE… I literally was mouth open thinking the pyro-tech went waaaay overboard.

    • Yes I do. I doesn’t take long to make/set a bomb. (Don’t ask me how I know that!) And Gillian told them when and where they’d be. And they are mobsters. I’m quite sure they have bombers at their disposal.

  10. How was Gyp able to get explosives to Babette’s on such short notice (from the tip from Gillian), considering it is Nucky’s turf?

    And why was he so bold as to set foot on Nucky’s turf (Gillian’s club, in Atlantic City) to begin with?

  11. Gyp is a nutcase. But a great character.

  12. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading?
    I’m trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.