SR Picks: Our Favorite Cult Movies

The other day, we Screen Rant writers were chatting online and the subject of cult movies came up.  Immediately I began thinking of all the cult movies I’ve seen and loved (or loathed) – so I thought it would be great to list some of our favorite cult movies individually, and as a group.

As we were compiling our lists, we debated what, exactly, constitutes a “cult movie.”  We talked about different criteria… for instance movies that fail at the box office (or do only modestly well), but then do terrific on home video.  Or maybe they tank overall, but have a small, passionate (and underground?) fan base.  Then there are movies that gain some popularity, but are really, really weird.  SR boss Vic Holtreman even posed the question on Twitter, and got some great answers.

To settle any debates about whether any of our picks were actual cult movies or not, we consulted Wikipedia, and found this definition:

“A cult film (or cult movie/picture) is a film that has acquired a highly devoted but relatively small group of fans.  Often, cult movies have failed to achieve fame outside of the small fanbases… “

They do have a list of exceptions… for example cases where a cult film became recognized by mainstream audiences. Films like Rocky Horror Picture Show, Blade Runner, Evil Dead, and others.  But we’ll still consider those cult films, just ones that are more widely known now.

I also think there are movies that start out as cult films, then become major hits and can’t be considered “well-known cult films” (like the aforementioned Evil Dead).  I’m talking about movies like Austin Powers, which became a cult flick for a very short time on VHS and DVD, before becoming so big, it spawned two major grossing sequels and possibly a fourth film.

And finally, don’t confuse a cult film with a “sleeper” film, which does well in theaters – but only after word of mouth spreads.  There’s Something About Mary can be considered a sleeper hit.

So with that criteria in mind, here are Screen Rant’s favorite cult movies (most of these favorites lists are not in fave to least fave order):

Heath McKnight (in no particular order):

“For me, I saw a lot of these cult movies in the theater and I honestly thought they’d do at least pretty good at the box office.  I still fell in love with them, especially when I could watch them over and over again on DVD.  I know they’re cult films, but I’d name at least three or four as my all-time favorite movies.”

• Blues Brothers - “If this movie comes on, I’ll watch it no matter how many times I’ve already seen it.”
• Office Space – “My best friend and I went to see it when it opened 10 years ago–no one was there, so I thought that was the end of this movie.”
• The Big Lebowski – “Saw it while in film school with some fellow students and we laughed it up in the empty theater”
• This Is Spinal Tap – “Another brilliant comedy. ‘Rock and roll!’”
• Transformers (1986 original) – “My mom took me to see it in theaters when I was only 10 years old.  When Optimus died, I started crying and my Mom said, ‘He’s just a robot.’  When she cried thinking Johnny 5 died in Short Circuit 2, I said, ‘He’s just a robot!’”
• The Three Amigos – “I used to watch this with my friends in high school–lots of laughs.”
• The Thing (1982) – “For me, ‘The Thing’ made me want to become a filmmaker–I’ve seen it probably 50 times since I first saw it 20 years ago.”
• Airplane! – “One of the funniest films ever.”
• Space Balls – “I never get sick of this movie, just like ‘Blues Brothers;’ some of my oldest friends and I still quote this movie.  ‘Give me paw!’”
• Nightmare Before Christmas – “I was in high school and I took a girl to see it.  We were the only ones in the theater, just like with ‘Big Lebowski’ and ‘Office Space.’”
• Mallrats – “I saw this over and over again while working at a movie theater, then saw it a lot on DVD a few years later.”
• Best in Show – “Yet another movie that I thought would rock the box office and sat pretty much alone in the theater, laughing.”

Kofi Outlaw:

“My definition of a cult movie is a movie that I totally get when I see it, even though so many other people in the theater around me don’t seem to get it at all. Until the DVD drops, and then, finally, other people seem to get it too.”

• Ghost Dog
• The Big Lebowski
• Office Space
• Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels
• Belly
• Memento
• American Pimp
  

Vic Holtreman:

“From the definition above, movies that I find I love watching over and over again are often the ones from which you can quote lines of dialog over and over and over again. I’ve included one favorite quote from each film (but there were many to choose from!)”

• Plan 9 From Outer Space – “You humans are stupid, stupid, stupid!”
• They Live – “I have come to chew bubblegum and kick ass.”
• The Princess Bride - “Ah, look who’s so smart? He’s only MOSTLY dead.”
• Monty Python and the Holy Grail - “WHAT is your quest?”
• Ferris Bueller’s Day Off - “Four thousand restaurants in the downtown area, I pick the one my father goes to.”
• Dark City – “SHUT IT DOWN! SHUT IT DOWN FOREVER!”
• Army of Darkness – “Come to daddy.”
• Kentucky Fried Movie - “Nuclear missiles are headed towards the United States… film at 11.”
• Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory - “Invention, my dear friends, is 93% perspiration, 6% electricity, 4% evaporation, and 2% butterscotch ripple.”
  
• Airplane – “Joey, do you like movies about gladiators?”
• Animal House – “They took the bar! They took the whole f$$%ing bar!”
• The Breakfast Club – “Does Barry Manilow know that you raid his wardrobe?”
• The Usual Suspects – “The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he did not exist.”
• Raising Arizona – “I’ll be taking these Huggies and whatever cash ya got.”
• Dawn of the Dead (1978 original) – “The only person who could miss with this gun is the sucker with the bread to buy it.”

Sabrina Cognata

“For me, cult movies are about special moments you can share with strangers.  Not long ago I was talking with a friend when I said, ‘I had the strangest dream,’ when some guy sitting near us leaned over and said, ‘Was it a dream where you see yourself standing in sort of sun-god robes on a pyramid with a thousand naked women screaming and throwing little pickles at you?’  And I knew that guy was awesome.  It’s about minutia and appreciation for things that were overlooked the first time around.  But most of all it’s about being an elitist over something that people, for the most part, do not get or understand.”

Ross Miller:

“I would classify a movie described as ‘cult’ as one which you can watch over and over again, quote lines throughout your daily life (often at the extreme annoyance of family and friends!) and never get tired of them. Alongside my list, I have put just one of my favorite quotes from each of them.”

Rob Keyes:

“I define cult films as movies not made with a massive budget and not receiving a wide successful box office. Cult movies spread through word of mouth, earning their success through a highly devoted fanbase – They become more popular after their initial release. The movies I chose are all movies that I had to watch more than once and ones that are extremely memorable for me.”

• Boondock Saints
• Primer
• Donnie Darko
• Office Space
• The Usual Suspects
• Army of Darkness
• Mad Max 2: The Road Warrior
• Equilibrium

Bruce Simmons

• The Rocky Horror Picture Show - “Was just a classic weekend routine for several years.”
• Harold and Maude – “It makes depression be in vogue.”
• The Shawshank Redemption -  “Just a classic tale of revenge.”
• Dawn of the Dead (1978 original) – “A creepy movie without millions being spent to make it creepy.”
• Faces of Death, Vol. 1 – “There’s a reason my buds put the tape in, said check this out, and left the house!  This vid is scarred on my mind forever.  Wow!!!”

Carl Lee

“Most of my film collection is made of cult films. I originally had listed movies like ‘Boondock Saints’ and ‘Reservoir Dogs’ but the selected ten can be found somewhere near my desk or already in my players. Their subject matter, story arc, or overarching theme has become the unheard second opinion and guiding light against the grain of the mainstream. Yeah, I have blockbusters (who doesn’t) but the discs that bare scratches from being played too often are the following.”

• Belly
• Blood In, Blood Out
• Closer
• Cry Baby
• Hard Candy
• 12 Monkeys
• Fight Club
• Pulp Fiction
• Scarface
• The Shawshank Redemption

Niall Browne:

“My cult favorites are films that I can watch over and over again without becoming bored. Sure they may not be loved by a lot of people – ‘Ishtar’ and ‘The Postman‘ are prime examples but they do have a special place in my heart. They are also films that should (must?) be watched by film fans to really celebrate the true spectrum of the medium.”

• Ed Wood
• Big Trouble in Little China
• Hudson Hawk
• The Postman (with Kevin Costner)
• Ishtar
• Blow Out
• Flash Gordon
• Time Bandits
• Elvis The Movie

Finally, here is our combined Top 10 Screen Rant list of favorite cult movies (in order):

1. Office Space
2. The Big Lebowski
3. They Live
4. The Usual Suspects
5. Army of Darkness
6. Donnie Darko
7. Big Trouble in Little China
8. The Shawshank Redemption
9. Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory
10. Airplane

Now that you’ve seen our favorite cult hits, we want to see yours!  What are the cult movies you pop into the DVD player (or even the VCR)?  And if you don’t agree with our picks, we’d love to hear what you think.

Oh… and a post about cult movies just wouldn’t be complete without at least one image from Army of Darkness.

PR: wait… I: wait… L: wait… LD: wait… I: wait… wait… Rank: wait… Traffic: wait… Price: wait… C: wait…