Recent Related Items:

62 Comments


Dang Mike, phenomenal first article. Nicely done!

Vic

Eric Rosenberg says:

How is Armageddon not on this list absolute great movie with a great cast

@Eric Rosenberg

PLEASE tell me that’s a joke. 8)

Vic

Sock Monkey says:

@Eric
Armageddon was fine, but it is purely an action flick. These movies are about space and our exploration of it.
@Mike
Along that note your list is good enough for me Mike, although I would have placed Apollo 13 a little higher. (Perhaps because I grew up with that being one of my family’s favorite movies.) I’ve also seen From the Earth to the Moon, and I’d have to agree with you completely that Spider is the best episode of the series. (A side note, maybe if you spent seven strait years working on a project, you’d see progression. :) )

On the subject of space, I believe that no matter how, or why we go back into space, the ultimate goal should be simply to just GET BACK INTO SPACE. As long as we progress in the exploration and colonization of outer space I’ll be happy. Specifically, an innovation that could rocket us (pardon the pun) into outer space; at far cheaper cost than blasting shuttles from ground level, is the space elevator. Using the nanotube technologies space exploration would turn into a far more common, and commercial practice. Anyway, just adding my “two scents”. Both of which keep people at bay. ;) Oh, and by the way, great article Mike.

Stephen says:

I think Armageddon is more about the action and Bay’s graphic fest than really about astronauts or feats in space. Not that it’s a bad movie, but it’s just not really fitting for this list. It’s odd that Apollo 13 is the only one on that list that I’ve seen, guess my “movies to rent” list just grew a little.

Jago says:

Just a quick question… And not trying to be mean or anything but at the top it says the top 5 astronaut “movies” of the year… Yet for your number one pick you have a hbo series. I mean i agree with the list except for the number one just for that fact alone. Not saying that i didn’t like from the earth to the moon just asking why is it on the list…?

bengibbard says:

you should go watch moon

though that could fall under scifi but im not saying it falls in this category.

I just think you would appreciate sam rockwells acting and a simple yet intriguing story about certain things.

Gary says:

Wonderful article Mike.
Welcome to Screen Rant.
I love the personal element too.
Never shy away from that.

Gary says:

I LOVE From The Earth to The Moon.
HBO just doesnt show it often enough.

Ross Miller says:

Couldn’t 2001: A Space Odyssey be counted as an Astronaut movie? I mean, it’s not set on the Moon, but…

Great article, Mike. I, too, would have rated Apollo 13 higher.

I loved From the Earth to the Moon, except for the episode dealing with the Apollo 13 crisis. Somehow, the fake “drama” between the fictional anchorman and the TV reporter didn’t do the rest of the series justice.

And Armageddon is one of the biggest turds I’ve ever had the displeasure of smelling.

One more thing to add – Clint Howard played a NASA flight controller in two of these movies. I’ll give a cookie to the first person who names the two OTHER movies where he plays a flight controller (and no fair looking at the IMDB).

The Big Dentist says:

Great piece, Mike. I’d like to add Countdown from `67 with Robert Duvall and James Caan, and Marooned from `69 with Gregory Peck and Gene Hackman. They might seem a little pedestrian now in terms of their scripts and special effects, but both attempted an almost documentary feel, and captured without the standard Hollywood fanfare the dangers involved in the embryonic business of spaceflight in that decade. Not to mention the bravery and dedication of all those involved, both on the ground and strapped into those capsules.

You’ve definitely made me want to hunt down From The Earth To The Moon, and as a similar testament to the teamwork involved in the Apollo missions I’d like to recommend Norman Mailer’s A Fire On The Moon: a stunning work of journalism, documentation and contemplation.

gottarhyme says:

I mentioned this elsewhere, but ‘The Dish’ is a fantastic little Aussie gem of a movie that centres around the Apollo 11 moon landing, and The Parkes Radio Telescope’s hand in beaming the first pictures back to earth.

It’s a very funny film about not taking yourself too seriously.

aGeneral says:

@gottarhyme

It was actually “Honeysuckle Creek Tracking Station” that transmitted the first images, it was 5-10min into the transmission that USA realized they forgot to flick a switch(literally) which transferred the signal to the more sensitive “Parkes radio telescope”

nowhereman says:

Firstly Mike, I congratulate you for an exceptional article. ScreenRant really has a knack for bringing forth talented and imaginative writers. Kudos to them for bringing yet another on board!
As a child of the sixties, I was lucky enough to have parents that made sure to interest my brother and I in the seminal efforts of man to explore our little slice of the universe. We would get up very early to watch the mercury (an subsequent Apollo) astronauts as they were launched from Florida, and the spectacle (even on a tiny black and white screen…) left an indelible mark on my earliest imaginings of what we could achieve given the opportunity.
Looking back now, I can’t express how fortunate I feel for having witnessed the “New Age” explorers that dared to dream, and in achieving their dreams made us all feel like not only the sky, but our future, was limitless!
I pray that in the very near future the children of this generation will be able to witness and capture the same sense of wonder and excitement.

steven the git says:

The Dish is brilliant. I love that movie.

As for astronaut movies, did think of 2001, and also the Planet of the Apes.
Ok, more about weird obelisks and talking apes, but very good films with astronauts in. ;)

Bob Dashman says:

Great article, but I have two disagreements. First, I would put Apollo 13 ahead of The Right Stuff. And, like some others, I loved From the Earth to the Moon (even own it), but am not sure that a series can count as the best movie. I agree with Scott’s comment about the Apollo 13 episode on FTETTM; it was so soon after the movie I guess Hanks did not want to do another version of the movie, so they come up with that. The only poor episode in an otherwise brilliant series!

Tim "Cloverfield" says:

Good job Mike….but where is my Pal 790? Remember there are many of us who do not believe this happened. Rather impossible to have happened.

John "Kahless" Taylor says:

I don’t know Vic; I may have to give the best writer cookie to Mike. :-)

Wonderful article Mike, and welcome. I agree that The Right Stuff is the best, followed by Apollo 13. I haven’t seen the others. Some are commenting that movies like Moon and Armageddon should be on the list but I think you are refering to movies based on historical events, which those movies aren’t. Everytime I see The Right Stuff, I just get goose bumps and that feeling of something great happening. A truly stellar cast and movie.

irishscribe says:

Great article, and though I agree with most of your picks, I’m surprised that there was no mention of “For All Mankind”. Not quite as good as “In the Shadow…..” but a tunning piece of documentary making, and oh, that soundtrack………

And I concur. Armageddon……ya gotta be kiddin!!!Sheeesh!

irishscribe says:

Uhhh…………Stunning piece of documentary making. ;)

Ken J says:

That’s so weird, I made a few posts yesterday with my blackberry and the posts actually showed up and everything after I posted them. Now they are all gone. I didn’t curse anyone out, lol. I made one here saying I want to see “The Right Stuff” now due to this article’s recommendation and the fact that it has Ed Harris and Dennis Quaid. I made a comment in the fan made avengers trailer post about how it looks like a bunch of randomness thrown together and doesn’t really make much sense, and some others… Now they are gone… Vic must be deleting my posts because I made fun of his bald head… :-D

Gottarhyme says:

Why isn’t ‘Space Cowboys’ with Tommy Lee Jones here?

OK, it may be a LITTLE fictional, but the scene where he is sitting on the moon looking out at the Earthrise for eternity after crashing his rocket is just amazing!

Ken J says:

Geez, thanks for giving away the ending of Space Cowboys… Now I’m not going to watch it… :-D

Gottarhyme says:

LOL! Everyone has seen that movie, surely?

Pretend I never said it. ;)

Ken J says:

I’ve never seen it, but now I might as well consider that I have… :-P

gottarhyme says:

Boo hoo!

Sorry. Although it is fantastic. One of Tommy Lee Jones’ best roles.

@Ken J

I haven’t deleted a single one of your comments, dude.

Vic

jthomas666 says:

You forgot “For All Mankind”, a magnificent 1989 documentary by Apollo 13 co-writer Al Reinert. Definitely better than In the Shadow of the Moon (which is very good, btw).

Page 1 of 212»
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.