‘Banshee’ Takes a Detour Into What Could Have Been

Published 1 year ago by

Antony Starr and Ivana Milicevic in Banshee season 2 episode 5 Banshee Takes a Detour Into What Could Have Been

[This is a review of Banshee season 2, episode 5. There will be SPOILERS.]


Creatively speaking, it’s a welcome sign when a show like Banshee demonstrates the willingness to take some risks with story and format to deliver an episode that is such a stylistic departure from the norm; one that turns the already modish sensibilities of the series into a striking kaleidoscopic dreamscape where editing and sound design play as integral a role as any of the main characters. And it’s especially a good sign when it all comes together this well.

The premise of ‘The Truth About Unicorns’ is fairly simple: Carrie is released from her 30-day sentence, stemming from last season’s brouhaha at the steel mill, and finds Hood (not her husband) waiting to take her back to Banshee. They stop for a bite to eat in a neighboring town; Carrie finds a unicorn lamp that Deva used to be fond of as a child; she and Hood flirtatiously case a jewelry store while snacking on some ice cream.

The idyllic scene serves as the first real moment they’ve had to try and pick up where they left off 15 years ago, but that moment is spoiled when Hood notices a suspicious car that’s been tailing them since they left the prison. Initially, it seems as though Hood’s paranoia gets the better of him, as it turns out the car belongs to a rather nondescript woman who is more than happy to have Hood help with her groceries. Upon that discovery, Hood takes Carrie on a “detour” to the a house he’d bought with the hope it might be enough for her to one day walk away from everything and possibly start over with him.

Their surprisingly chaste interlude is interrupted when Hood discovers Agent Racine hiding in the woods, hoping Carrie’s release from prison will lure Rabbit out of hiding. Things become slightly more complicated when, seconds after revealing his plan to bring down Carrie’s father (and that he knows the real Hood is dead), Racine takes a sniper’s bullet to the back of the head. A terrifically staged and filmed shootout later reveals the assassin to be none other than the grocery-carting woman from before.

Meanwhile, Hood and Carrie have no choice but to return to the reality of Banshee, as their dream of a quiet and blissful future together literally goes up in smoke.

Ivana Milicevic in Banshee season 2 episode 5 Banshee Takes a Detour Into What Could Have Been

Aside from the editing choices and Michael Mann-esque musical cues, what makes the episode so absorbing is how it presents Hood and Carrie with a persuasive “what if?” scenario, in which they briefly play out the fantasy where whoever Hood really is didn’t wind up incarcerated for 15 years, and Carrie didn’t marry Gordon Hopewell and start a family. We see a potential outcome for the would-be lovers that’s as dreamy as the structure of the episode (and the season) itself.

And yet, within that framework there emerges an important question: Would the Carrie and Hood be the contemplative individuals they are now if their circumstances before were sunnier?

So far this season, we’ve seen how Hood and Carrie are forced to deal with the ramifications of the lives they once led, and how that’s come back to threaten their future – since the present has them on a path they likely never though possible. But without going into some great detail about what we already know about Carrie (and hopefully will never know about Hood) the episode manages to tell the audience why that history has made them who they are now.

Rather than delve into the facts of the situation, writer John Romano (as well as the continually impressive performances by Antony Starr and Ivana Milicevic) manages to convey a convincing emotional connection with the characters’ loss of the previous 15 years, as well as the loss of the dream Rabbit’s assassin took from them.

It wouldn’t be ideal if every episode drew from the same creative well, but for an interlude that also acts as the bridge to the second half of the season, ‘The Truth About Unicorns’ is a welcome detour that offers some engaging insight into who Carrie and Hood are now and why they can’t leave Banshee, while accompanying that illumination with some visually and aurally compelling flourishes to help it all resonate a little bit more.


Banshee continues next Friday with ‘Armies of One’ @10pm on Cinemax.

Photos: Gregory Shummon/Cinemax

TAGS: Banshee
Get our free email alerts on the topics and author of this article:


Post a Comment

GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.

If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it. Keep in mind that we do not allow external links in the comments.

  1. Beautifully directed and shot, even though there were not many things happening. Bravo.

  2. I didn’t really care for this episode. Mostly because not much happened. But also because I’m rooting for Hood and Siobban, rather than Hood and Carrie.

  3. Stylish episode yes. And I agree not much happened. I feel a bit let down the FBI agent explained his plan and then immediately killed. We haven’t even seen the guy in 3 episodes. Now we wait for the Native American gang to come back around. There is too much happening in this small town

  4. Wow This is one of my fav episodes. I just love how the writers really develop the characters and show the consequences of the characters actions. This show is full of 3D characters and I appreciate how much talent you have to have as a writer to develop all of the major characters. Luved the “what if ” scenarios. Especially the burning house. Great action choreography as always. Masterful storytelling at its best. Banshee is up there wiht GAme of Thrones and Justified for consistent storytelling and not insulting their audience intelligence. No wonder it was renewed after 3 episodes this year.

  5. I was disappointed in this episode after having waited all week. It’s my fav show. I 2 am not a fan of Carrie, but do like the dark hair deputy. Bring on Hood and his gang (the Asian guy is the coolest) and keep-up the quota of violence please.

  6. This episode was so horribly directed that I almost stopped watching the series. Half of the episode was made up of multiple camera angles and piano music. Oh Yay! The plot was barely advanced and other than one somewhat significant character dying, this episode could be omitted.

    I have never been compelled to review an episode of any show I have ever watched. That’s how bad this episode was. The director needs to get away from this look-how-artsy-I-am mentality and learn how to tell a damn story. This is an action/drama show, not an audition for another Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind movie.

    • Reading this review as just seen this episode.

      Differing tastes: I thought The Truth About Unicorns was by far the best episode of Banshee so far. Wouldn’t work if every episode was like this. But it was totally compelling, in a different league to the rest, and serves to make the rest of the series better by providing an emotional core. Really stunning work.