News has been released that is sure to please anyone who values quality film criticism: At The Movies, the film review show that started with Siskel & Ebert then moved onto Ebert & Roeper after Gene Siskel sadly passed away, is now having its current hosts, Ben Lyons and Ben Mankiwicz, replaced by The Chicago Tribune‘s Michael Philips and The New York Times‘ A.O Scott.
Lyons (from E! Entertainment) and Mankiewicz (from Turner Classic Movies) took over from Roger Ebert (who hadn’t appeared on the show for a while because of health problems) and Richard Roeper last year in some sort of futile attempt by Disney-ABC to make the show appeal to a younger audience (how else can it be explained?).
The move was met with much outrage from the movie community (those who like to hear in-depth film discussion, that is), particularly towards Lyons because of his style of reviewing, which is anything but intelligent (he actually called I Am Legend, “One of the greatest movies ever made,” a blurb which was then used on one of the film’s promo posters). Here’s the Daytime Disney-ABC Television Group press release about letting go of Lyons and Mankiewicz:
“We tried something new last season and we think the world of Ben Lyons and Ben Mankiewicz. They did everything we asked of them and they have been complete professionals. However, we’ve decided to return the show to its original essence – two traditional film critics discussing current motion picture and DVD releases. We thank them for their hard work and dedication this past year and wish them nothing but the best on all of their future endeavors.”
Ben Lyons and Ben Mankiewicz on 'At The Movies'
Phillips and Scott were two of the most frequent guest hosts who stood in for Ebert because of his health problems, and they’ll bring back a lot of the credibility that At The Movies lost when Ebert and Roeper were replaced. I read Philips’ reviews regularly, Scott’s occasionally, and both evidently really know what they’re talking about when it comes to films and getting into the nitty-gritty of the details of them. Part of the press release about them reads:
“Both of these seasoned and influential film critics, who have appeared on the series repeatedly as guest co-hosts, will bring their extensive credentials and respected personas to the program.”
Even though the merit of a movie review show like At the Movies – which crams numerous reviews into a single half hour – can be debated, I think it’s definitely good news that these new hosts have been brought on board.
Do you watch At The Movies? Do you like that Lyons and Mankiewicz have been replaced?
Michael Phillips and A.O Scott will start hosting the show on September 7th, 2009. Quick note: If you want to view almost the entire back catalog of At The Movies reviews, you can visit the official website (warning: addiction may occur).
Source: /Film, The New York Times and Chicago Tribune
‘Anchorman 2′ Trailers Tease the Return of Ron Burgundy’s News Team [Updated] 
Hugh Jackman Reveals Summer Start Date for ‘Wolverine 2′ 
Chris Hemsworth Talks ‘Thor 2′; Mads Mikkelsen Circling Villain Role [Updated] 
‘Walking Dead’ Season 3 Preview Reveals The Prison & Michonne [Updated] 
Loading ...
I watch the show, but I haven’t been watching them so in depthly because Lyons just doesn’t have that good of opinion on movies. When they changed, i was a bit shocked since I had no clue who these two were.
The switch is cool though, this time. I know the names A.O Scott, and Michael Phillips. Maybe the show will be more interesting to watch now.
I’m certainly happy they’re gone–I tried watching it a couple of times but was very disappointed. When they first announced Ebert and Roeper were leaving, I was very sad. Big fan of Siskel and Ebert (and later E&R) since I was 14 (1990).
They got some great new critics. GREAT NEWS!
Heath
To be honest, I find that films that mainstream critics rave about usually bore me to tears. I just finally had a chance to watch “No Country for Old Men” and I was extremely disappointed with the ending of the movie. How in the world did that film win an Oscar for best film and get rave reviews? No offense to the reviewers here at this site, with whom I generally agree with, but most critics have no idea what the general public really likes. IMO, Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel had an idea about this, and while I disagreed with them frequently, I enjoyed their show. I have not watched the latest incarnation, and to be honest, with the internet and sites like this who really needs to?
Both Mt. Scott and Mr. Phillips are top notch…..In my market “At the Movies” comes on at 11:30 Sunday night. ( now that sucks) but I watched and hardley ever agreed with the commentary. I did agree with them on many terrible, terrible films….”Observe and Report” for example….. but honestly, anyone that knows anything about film making and the ability to percieve actual talent can come to the same conclusion. ” I am Legend” was so over-rated and when Lyons made that comment, is as it he was being paid to do so…. .. CRazY TAlk! I am glad they are being replaced!
I continued to watch the show out Of loyalty to Siskel& Ebert .
These are great choices .
I wish them both the best of Luck.
At The Movies is BACK !
WOO HOO!
Hey,what can i say?
I am a FAN!
I was pissed with Ebert and Roeper were replaced with the Bens. I respect Ben M. that he works for TCM. The other Ben is a target.
I watched the show occasionally.
I’m glad that the Scott and Phillips are headlining the show now.
I heard rumbling that E & R were developing a new show to compete with the Bens.
This is good news all around.
I was deeply puzzeled with ABC about there decision with Roger Ebert and richard roeper.
And at first I hated the bens, but I got used to it.
But now I think ABC needs to pick two critics and stay with them as long as possible.
Hopefully scott and phillps will last longer then the bens.
And maybe they can be the real deal that this show needs.