Related Posts:

19 Comments


TheMantis said,
February 19th, 2008 

I couldn’t agree with you more. The only “potential” reason I’d go to this is the new HULK trailer that may or may not be attatched. This movie looks like a made for tv mini-series.

“Why so Serious!”

Ed said,
February 19th, 2008 

I’m predicting it’ll be a miss with this film.

It looks too serious to be fun, and too dumb to be an intellectual stimulator. It just feels no good all around and will be forgotten quickly.

Jim Carey said,
February 19th, 2008 

Vic, how many uber-geeks are there who will decide to see a movie because of the trailers?

Surma said,
February 19th, 2008 

Hey Mystery Science Theater(or all the same guys at least) are still around. Just now they are called riff trax and instead they make fun of really popular movies.

Andy said,
February 19th, 2008 

All those Emmerich movies you mentioned I happen to like…even Universal Soldier. True, they’re not cinematic legacies, but they were entertaining and fun. Isn’t that what they were meant to be? I’m still not sure about this film and trailers will NOT drag me to a film-especially since I know they will be on here the next day. :) Depending on the buzz, I might go check it out, but it sure seems like a rental already because the trailers have done NOTHING to get me interested in this film. As I pointed out in another comment somewhere, you only get ONE first impression….

February 19th, 2008 

Actually of all the Emmerich movies you listed, I only truly enjoyed Stargate. The only one I haven’t seen is Universal Soldier.

Independence Day was barely tolerable due mostly to the scenes of the Aliens attacking than for anything the rest of the movie did (which was laughable) while The Day After Tomorrow applied the same ham-fisted logic to global climate - with even duller results. The Patriot was okay, but it’s overly melodramatic plotting sucked the life out of what was otherwise a pretty good opening act.

Godzilla - rarely has a huge city stomping monster film managed to be so dreadfully dull and plodding. So unconcerned with the poor pacing were Devlin/Emmerich, that they still found time to retaliate against Siskel & Ebert for trashing (rightly) Independence Day.

Roland Emmerich is the master of taking epic scale material and wasting its potential with unfocused storytelling and laughable logic. Needless to say I’m not interested in his newest effort.

February 19th, 2008 
Jim,

There are probably people who would be on the fence about seeing it and that might tip the scales to get them to go.

Vic

steve adams said,
February 19th, 2008 

Big Elephants and little people. Weeeeee
^
I’m sure there’s a story but I’m no where near this film.

steve adams said,
February 19th, 2008 

Wow Jersycajun we finnally agree on something.
^
Stargate could have been better bigtime but it was ok. (They should have stopped there).
But I totally agree that Emmerich is a hack beyond all hackyness.
^
Your post was a
perfect discription of his failures. I loved reading it.
Good job!

John "Kahless" Taylor said,
February 20th, 2008 

Well, I liked all those movies mentioned except for Godzilla (could someone call Megalon to beat the crap out of him LOL). I’m not too sure about 10000 BC myself; the trailers are not too appealing to me.

WartyHogger said,
February 20th, 2008 

Heh, i knew this would have good previews. And when they said that we would expect Incredible Hulk previews in early march, my mind went straight to 10,000 bc.

steve adams said,
February 20th, 2008 

Its kinda funny if they want me to see this film they wouldn’t tell me in the tv commercials that its from the producer of “Independance day” and “the day after tomarrow”…
^

M-E said,
February 21st, 2008 

I personally want to go see this film. But I must admit that the big dissapointment for me was seeing in the trailer that they speak english. I seriously doubt that english was around, or even spoken in 10,000 BC.

John "Kahless" Taylor said,
March 7th, 2008 

Well, Rotten Tomatoes’ critics seem to hate it; it’s at 9% on the tomato-meter.

790 said,
March 7th, 2008 

Hey John I think Vic is going to have a review later today.

March 7th, 2008 
Yup, got my tickets. I’ll be sitting down to watch it 4 hours from now.

It’s now down to 8% at R/T. :-)
Vic

790 said,
March 7th, 2008 

Bac bac baack. SuperChicken!!!
^
I’m predicting a 2 star Vic rating.

Sara said,
April 14th, 2008 

I saw this movie and if you tend to take things overly seriously, I don’t recommend it. But if you respect classic legends from people of a time long before our own then I highly recommend it. Sometimes classics can seem stupid to those who have no respect.

April 14th, 2008 
So let me get this straight: If someone “respects classic legends” then they shouldn’t take a movie about a classic legend too seriously?

I’m sorry but that makes no sense at all.

Vic

What's your opinion? Leave a comment!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.