Recent Related Items:

33 Comments


Kane Adrian says:

I’m going to be controversial and agree with Ellindar on the LOTR/Star Wars comparison… since I think that’s seriously overestimating the appeal and intent of the Alien/Predator franchises.

But, Ellindar, why are you even posting on a film forum when you clearly miss the point of their existence?

I, too, enjoyed the first AvP film as a fun popcorn flick… but that’s because I was never all that into either franchise to begin with. Unlike you, though, I could see why it upset die hard fans. Alien, in particular, was always an uber-serious sci-fi franchise… and Predator wasn’t far behind.

Thing is… taking these two properties and making nothing more than a fun popcorn flick is like expecting fans of The Simpsons and Family Guy to enjoy a hybrid of those shows in which the tongue-in-cheek comedy is replaced with serious romance and drama.

And, while we’re at it, isn’t it interesting that you clearly have films you dislike – ie. Pathfinder – and tell people they’re being snobbish – in your own high and mighty way – yet, because you personally enjoyed AvP, you have to be ‘right’.

There’s no right or wrong – only opinion. Just don’t be a complete jerk and insult people.

ellindar says:

I never said they were wrong, just that I completely disagree with the way they make it sound that their opinion is of course the right one.

Second, I completely disagree with you on your analysis and here is why:

Aliens was yes, a franchise, of which a couple were pretty bad as it was. But Alien VS Predator… is NOT a part of the alien franchise. I mean seriously, it’s ALIEN VS PREDATOR.

And I’m 37 and have followed the franchise religiously. The difference is, is that I know when a movie is ’supposed’ to be released as a popcorn movie, and when it is supposed to be released as a serious flick.

And sorry to say, but the title itself just screams popcorn guys. It’s really just not as big of a deal as you try to make it out to be. Disagree all you want, I just get a kick out of people who take everything way too seriously.

Vic says:

Dude, whatever. As was stated above, why even come to these sites?

There are plenty of movie sites out there that deliver news without editorial content. I suggest you hang out at movies.ign.com or movies.yahoo.com if you don’t want to hear people’s opinions.

Vic

Page 2 of 2«12