The second episode in the Alcatraz double feature doesn’t manage to tie the returned inmates to the larger story of the series like ‘The Ames Bros.’, but it does feature two guest stars in Sons of Anarchy‘s Theo Rossi (as the titular ‘Sonny Burnett’) and Wendy Crewson (Air Force One) as the woman Burnett is seeking revenge on.
Burnett finds himself on Madsen and Hauser’s radar after he murders one man and kidnaps another. It seems Burnett was serving time for kidnapping – which he apparently ran like a semi-successful business – but he was ultimately undone when Helen (Crewson) the young woman he’d been supposedly holding captive/grooming as a lover and partner, escaped and ratted him out to the authorities.
Meanwhile, Rebecca Madsen (Sarah Jones) is still plagued by thoughts of her partner’s death – at the hands of her returned grandfather Tommy Madsen (David Hoflin). During a brief visit, her uncle, Ray Archer (Robert Forster), is quick to warn of the danger Tommy poses, and Madsen is equally quick to realize that Ray has been in contact with Tommy recently. Apparently, Ray has the worst poker face in San Francisco, as Hauser was able to conclude the same thing when he met with Ray earlier in the episode.
The 1960s portion of the episode illustrates Burnett’s transformation from a somewhat soft kidnapping and ransom expert to hardened criminal after he is shanked in the prison playground when payment for his protection doesn’t come through. After Burnett heals, he spends his time punching the cell wall and doing pushups, so he can beat the hell out of some guy to prove how tough he’s gotten. Unfortunately, this earns him all the wrong attention and Deputy Warden E. B. Tiller (Jason Butler Harner) subtly encourages Burnett to take things further – lest the other inmates think of him as weak.
In the present, it turns out that Helen stole Burnett’s earnings after she turned him in, which resulted in him getting shanked and gave him something to do once he showed up in the present. Stage one of Burnett’s revenge was to decapitate Helen’s husband, and leave his head for the cops to find. Stage two involved the kidnapping of Helen’s daughter, Danielle, and burying her in the same field his money was stashed. Not doing much to cover his tracks, Madsen and Soto (Jorge Garcia) are quickly on his tail. After a brief car chase, Burnett is brought into custody, and Danielle is pulled to safety.
The episode flashes back to 1960 one last time, and we see Burnett pummel the guy who shanked him, and send a message to the rest of the inmates by gouging the man’s eyes out rather than killing him. The flashback ends suggesting some discontent is brewing toward Warden James (Jonny Coyne) on behalf of Tiller. The two passive aggressively threaten one another and seem content to leave it at that, for now.
Back at Hauser’s secret compound, his hopes for Lucy’s recovery are dashed after Dr. Beauregard informs him that Burnett’s blood did not contain any colloidal silver – perhaps suggesting other elements are at play in the inmate’s ageless appearance and health.
Alcatraz airs the preempted ‘Clarence Montgomery’ next Monday @9pm on FOX.