• greenknight333
    I am really looking forward to this film!!

    What is it with films with nine in the title this year:

    District 9
    9
    Cloud 9
    Nine

    That's gotta be some kinda record...
  • MCat
    I agree totally. Movie was awesome!
  • Ken J
    For some reason it never caught my interest. Maybe it's subconscious because I know Tim Burton is involved and I'm pretty sick of the Tim Burton stuff myself... Maybe I might see it one day if there's nothing else to watch (and it looks like that's the case)
  • 790
    9 is also the number of death,,,
    ??? 8-)

    4 out of 5,? Hmmm
    This looks like a video game to me. Kinda like Oddworld Munch's Oddysee or Strangers Wrath.
    I might give it chance on dvd...
  • SK-47
    Haha, Oddworld, I would like to see a full CGI film of that...but honestly, how refreshing is it that so far three of the best films this year, in my opinion, are not full studio films:
    The Hurt Locker
    District 9
    & 9
  • Luipaard
    It looks quite fascinating to me, and I'm going to check it out as soon as I'm able. As for how the dolls were created, I thought that was detailed in the viral website?
  • Andy S
    2 things:

    First, we shouldn't HAVE to go to a viral website to figure out something in the movie. I feel that a movie should be able to tell a story on it's own without having to hunt all over the place for background information. It's cool if there are sites out there to give MORE info, but something as integral as the creation of the characters shouldn't be required homework.

    Second, I thought the animated short was awesome and really whetted my appetite for this film. I will probably be seeing this tomorrow night. A 4 of 5 from Vic on this film cemented that decision.
  • Wickamo
    I think the addition of dialog was a must for this film. No dialog in a short is one thing, but a full length movie with no dialog would be a bit too much. I also think there is nothing wrong with the lack of explanation as to the creation of the characters. Again we don't have to have every detail for a story to be told. A scientist created them...thats all we need to know. I'm hearing complaints that the addition of dialog might ruin the "awe and mystery" yet the "awe and mystery" of not having their exact origin explained comes under attack. After seeing this film, I actually thing 80 minutes was too short, I couldn't get enough of it. It was fantastic.
  • hud
    i totally disagree with this review while most of the time i like vics reviews. i give it a 1/5. it was pritty bad big plot hole and what was with the end retarded and made no sense
  • @Wickamo

    Oh, I know they couldn't have made the full length film without dialog, but the short film had much more impact.

    @hud

    Actually Harry Knowles over at AICN made a comment related to yours - he said that in the end, the movie was pointless.

    Vic
  • @hud

    The movie's ending is only "pointless" depending on your belief system. What '9' did for his friends could be seen as a very heroic to some who believe in the soul. Also,the bit with the rain suggests a rebirth of sorts. It's a science mysticism metaphor mix. Just go with it.

    Overall the movie is unique, beautiful to look at, thrilling and scary. Fun Time and I'd be surprised if September offers anything better.
  • And I thought it was pretty clear how the dolls were given life. In fact - isn't that the big reveal of the movie?

    The explanation is rooted in mysticism, but that's ok when dealing with a fantasy world, IMHO.
  • SIN187UM
    Good movie, and very good CGI/Animation. I'd like to see this movie get a sequel.
  • Andrew
    @Those Wondering About the Making of the Characters

    They DO reveal how the dolls come alive very clearly (in the world of the film) and succinctly. I saw the movie yesterday and was impressed, not only with visual presentation but also with the (surprisingly) non-preachy manner in which they show redemption and portray the human soul...two subjects that, if overblown or forcefed to an audience, can create a horrid movie-watching experience. I thought this film was wonderful and look forward to seeing it again.

    BTW--I agree that it's great that the makers of the film kept it out of the 3D arena; it actually feels somewhat unique among recent animated films because of this.
  • Chiguy
    I enjoyed the animation and the action of the movie, but for me the story was pretty weak. Without making this a spoiler, if 9 avoids one action, there is almost no movie. As was said before, I liked that it didn't get all "preachy". I think in the end I would have preferred seeing this either on DVD or on TV as it felt pretty short for a movie ticket price.
  • darthbalo
    The visual element was great but the story was a little weak.
  • Brett
    I saw this movie this past Saturday with my 9 and 11yo boys. I loved it as did they. I typically let my ex take them to the animated movies so there half-sister can take part. She's five and this film would've definately scared the you-know-what out of her. Personally I think the big screen enhances the film due in part to the great sound the theater imparts.
  • It would have been more appropriate to call it 4, because that’s what it would get out of 10, and most of that would be for the animation which, irritatingly, is jeffing marvellous.
blog comments powered by Disqus