Recent Related Items:

114 Comments


arrell says:

@Evie: Rocky beat Taxi Driver. Kramer vs. Kramer beat Apocalypse Now. Ordinary People beat Raging Bull. Forrest Gump beat The Shawshank Redemption.

So yes, the people voting sometimes go beyond entertainment (wait a sec…), importance and intrinsic value!

No Name Face says:

@ longShanks
You are wrong TDK is third after titanic and LOTR TROTK

Ken J says:

Ah, stop beating around the bush, stop with this “people in the industry who look more into a film than its entertainment value” stuff, just say it, SNOBS, the Oscars are voted by a bunch of movie snobs that think they know what’s of quality better than us lowly “normal” people.

To them I say phooey! :-D

Ken J says:

@ Daniel F

I’m surprised you watched that film at all. When I was deciding what to watch, looking through the list of movies, I passed right by Milk like I would have passed right by The Love Guru. There wasn’t even the shortest bit of contemplation going on in my head when that movie came up…

Daniel F says:

I am a film nut and watch just about any movie that comes out. Including The Love Guru which had two small parts of laughter and the rest was like “who finds this crap funny ?”

Sorry to say it though Ken You might call me a snob with the sort of films I generally prefer. I thought this year the oscars were bad, but usually I semi agree with their choices. I enjoy action, but 90% of the time I don’t consider action films to be great movies their for popcorn not awards.

Shawshank Redemption, Forest Gump and Schindler’s list are three of the greatest movies of all time.

JargonJohn says:

@ Ken J.
If you want to see awards given out by what lowly “normal” people believe is good, then watch the MTV Movie Awards. The Oscars are voted on by industry professional. Always have, and always will be.

@ Longshanks
It’s my understanding that the Oscars are based off the quality of the movie, not how much profit the movie made. Transformers is at 20, Iron Man 21, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull is at 23, and Pirates of the Carribean: At World’s End is at 26 for top grossing movies. They all sucked in my opinion (cept for Iron Man, which I found to be just ok).

Anyway, with Slumdog Millionaire gaining so much praise, I should give it a chance. Only movie I watch on that list was The Dark Knight.

SK47 says:

I liked the format this year with previous winners introduce the nominees, that was a great idea and it really worked well for the Best Actor category with such greats as DeNiro, Douglas, Hopkins, and Kingsley. Adding, Brody, eh, whatever, but it totally worked and with the Magnificent Seven score, that was pure classic! I agree with Ken J, Penn is a snake, but a talented one, and I can’t dog on Pacman really. (Penn in Colors) He should’ve brought up Rourke on stage it would have made the moment better, and add to the 7 motif with the score!
They should do this format every year it is good and keeps the show moving forward.
Some opinions on this years awards:
1-Hellboy 2 should have got a lot more technical awards! Have you seen this movie on Blu-Ray? On 1080p? DAMN! Even the special featurs on the Troll Market? This is a real shame! Hellboy 2 really is the one picture that got robbed and deserves a lot of technical awards!
2-Marisa Tomei is the hottest Milf and I’d most definately be her slave!
3-Alicia Keys is WAAAAYYYY hotter than Beyonce and I’d mos def’ be her slave!
4-Natalie Portman is SOOOO gorgeous and in that pink dress, mmm, I’d like some strawberry pie please ;D. And I’d be her slave!
5-F Anniston, Jolie all the way!
6-Slumdog really deserves this win! Granted it might not be for everybody, but take a look at that film. From editing, to music, cinematography, choice of camera angles, the subject matter, the people involved, the fact that there is no Hollywood star, hell, this movie was close to not being made! And there is child brutality in it! It really is a breakaway for a traditional Oscar best pic and I hope this type of trend continues!

greenknight333 says:

There is a good reason I heven’t watched the Oscars in 12 years and the reason is this award show is supposedly for the best films of any year regardless of genre. That’s not what happens.

These are just awards and in the grand scheme of things they mean nothing..I really could care less about a bunch of spoiled actors, over-inflated egos, who was wearing what, who was with whom, who was funny, who was faking it, who was hamming it, who looked good, who looked bad, what Brangelina were up to, who went where after the awards were handed out, what designer was on whom, who got robbed, who didn’t deserve it, who ate what, who farted on the red carpet, etc, etc, etc,
These awards are self-serving for the industry and it is an overblown night in which all the egos get to sit on their thrones and pat themselves on the back for what is percieved as a job well done, it is actually quite akin to high school and is just a popularity contest to decide king and queen of the prom..

Bollywood sweeps the Oscars…………YEAH!!!!**sarcasm**

I am very happy for Ledger’s family because he is at least acknowledged for his body of work in Hollywood or more so for what he would have accomplished had he lived, by his peers.

Now let’s give ourselves a tremendous round of applause for keeping all these people in jobs that enables them to live the lifestyles and quality of life they have because we put our butts in seats and thereby make a lot of people rich in doing so.

We need an awards show for we the people that are fans of good cinema but that are not influenced to meet an agenda for the politcal issue Hollywood has chosen as it’s hot potato or flavour of the month.

And no the People’s CHoice awards don’t count.. :)

Okeley dokeley..I am done ranting!

Gary says:

greenknight,
There IS such an awards show .
Its called The Spirit awards.

Gary says:

What about the Blockbuster movie awards ?
they are pretty much based on popular choices.

greenknight333 says:

@ Gary

I thought the SPirit awards were awarded to independent films or low key smaller budget really arthouse films..not really what I had in mind..

Blockbuster..have they got anything to do with the movie rental franchise..corporate influenced so doesn’t really count, hey let me revise my post..why do we need award shows at all? I know so the industry can remind us what we should be supporting.. ;)

Gary says:

Icantjudge penns performance because I havent seen Milk yet,
But I am sure the recent passing of Prop.8 here in California which is considered a ban on Gay marriage
played a factor in Seans win,
It may have been just the edge he needed in a tight race against Mickey Rourke.

Gary says:

Greenknight.
Oh,
Then its DEFINITELY the Blockbuster Awards then.

I really wanted to see Mickey Rourke win because I was cringing in anticipation of Sean Penn’s speech – and it was what I expected. When he mentioned “shame” my thought was man does he have it backwards.

Another thing that stood out to me was when they showed the industry people who died last year – NO applause for Charlton Heston.

Cold.

Vic

Gary says:

Vic ,
Yeah , I noticed that too about Heston.
It would have been great if there had been massive applause when they showed the scene of Moses parting the Red Sea.

HOMER says:

i totally disagree with the best make up and best sound mixing
Dark Knight and iron man should have won them respectevely

i am glad Heath won best sup actor, but second to him was RDJ

T. says:

I was doing homework at the same time as the montage nof deceased film stars. No applause for Charlton Hestion? He is the epitome of Hollywood legend. What a shame!

Gary says:

Will Kate star in a Horror or Action film now that she has won?
It seems to be a tradition for recent winners of that category.

SK47 says:

Agree with you Vic, shame on them for not applauding Heston! No matter what, you cannot take away the fact that Heston was a true powerhouse and legend for films! The pictures he was involved in were groundbreaking! Ben Hur, 10 Commandments, Planet Of The Apes, Omega Man, Soylent Green, El Cid, Touch Of Evil, Greatest Show on Earth, and he basically played Nic Fury in True Lies!!!
“Sweet Jesus, Harry, you surely screwed the pooch last night, didn’t you?”

Doom3524 says:

First off, Jackman was awesome last night. Everything he did worked. He is such a great stage talent.

Second, did I miss it, or was Heath not on the montage of people who died last year?

Gary says:

I loved the end of Hughs first number,
I AM WOVERINE!
Very Nice!

Gary says:

I LOVED the end of Hughs first number,
I AM WOLVERINE!
Very Nice!

Rob Keyes says:

Hugh was awesome,

I wonder if he’ll be back next year?

Tricia says:

It’s obvious that we all have our own tastes and opinions about the movies, actors and the awards shows that honor them. I often will not watch certain movies until I have seen the People’s Choice, Golden Globes and Academy Awards (Slumdog). I enjoyed the Oscars format this time, but felt a little sorry for Jennifer having to stand there and try to be funny in front of Brad and Angie. I definitely will see Slumdog because I know that 8 Oscars is not something to sneeze at. And maybe I will see TDK just because all you guys seem to think it’s a great movie. But I have to wonder: would the wonderful Heath Ledger have won if he had not died? I’m happy for his family and I think he deserved an award for all his body of work, esp in Brokeback Mtn. It’s harder for a straight man to play a gay guy (Ledger,Penn) than to play a crazed evil
clown! And since Ken J brought up the D Chicks, I too think it was political when they won. But I also think their music is 10 time betr than Carrie’s. Natalie as a soloist is not as good as Carrie, but the group is awsome. It’s a matter of taste. As for C Heston, I would not applaud him because of his political stand on gun control. And I hate to break it to you but he was not God.

Evie says:

@arrell: I’m not sure of your point. The list you have of movies beating others was more than just entertaining. Schindler’s List was just an extreme example.

@Tricia: Yes, Heath did deserve the Oscar hands down. Once you see it you will know what I (we) mean.

@Doom: I also noticed the omission, but thought I was looking away or something. Was not a fan of how they did it since half the time I couldn’t see them.

Daniel F says:

He deserved the OScar, but had he not died he would not of won. The Dark Knight would of been completely blocked out from any major award for it’s genre alone.

“As for C Heston, I would not applaud him because of his political stand on gun control. And I hate to break it to you but he was not God.”

The funny thing is I don’t really like his movies at all. However his stand on guns is the exact reason I would applaud him. Maybe he was a little extreme, but unlike Hollywood these days he stood up for our freedom and our rights.

greenknight333 says:

A lot of people mentioned there was no applause for Heston and the obvious question I have to ask is why? Anyone have any thoughts on this?

greenknight333 says:

Dixie chicks suck
Carrie Underwood sucks
Country music released past 1980 sucks

remember it’s just my opinion but give me Waylon, Willie, Johnny, Marty, Hank Sr, ALabama Tom T Hall any day over the wussy music that is being passed off for country music these days..

greenknight333 says:

ANy one see the English Patient..that won all kinds of Oscars and IMO was an awful movie..

Evie says:

@greenknight: it is because he was pres of the NRA. In other words: his political views were why. I won’t say more because I don’t want to get in a discussion about politics on my fav entertainment site :)

Page 2 of 4«1234»
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.