Recent Related Items:

114 Comments


Ken J says:

Wow, I agree with just about none of that… Guess I’m no film snob…

Longshanks says:

I just find it to be really funny (not funny ha ha) that the second highest grossing movie of all time could only muster up 2 awards.

The Oscars are a joke.Slumdog was good,but definitely NOT the best movie of the year.

mart09 says:

Hugh Jackman was terrific

Oscar! says:

@Rob, wow. Its good to have someone that knows about films talk about films. Any other website would have writers saying “OMG The Oscars suck! TDK got robbed!!!!!111!!!1 I really enjoyed The Oscar’s this year. All the awards were given to the rightful winners. The Dark Knight won the awards it should have won, and Heath Ledger deserved the win. I really wanted to see Iron Man win atleast one award but that was just wishful thinking. Hugh Jackman was funny as hell!!!! He even joked about all the TDK fans complaining about the film getting robbed. The funniest part had to have been James Franco and Seth Rogen laughing away at the not so funny movies. Good job btw, i agreed with everything you wrote.

Heath says:

Boring. Zzzzz… The Dark Knight was shut out of noms, but YEAH, HEATH! for The Joker! Too bad Iron Man lost Best Visual FX… And too bad Rourke didn’t win, but Sean Penn gave him mad props, like Nicholson did for Peter Fonda (for his nominated role in the brilliant Ulee’s Gold) in 1998.

heath

Oscar! says:

@Longshanks, oh, and you actually think TDK was???

Diane says:

The Oscars are such a joke. Honestly it is a night for actors/actresses and everyone involved in film making to pat themselves on the back and tell themselves how great they are. Why the film industry insists on having the awards is beyond me. On top of that their nominees were impossibly predictable. Seriously there are so many good movies out there that never receive Oscar nods.

As for trying to draw in young crowds to watch the Oscars by having stars like Zac Efron and Robert Pattinson present, I am not entirely sure that it worked. Perhaps if the Oscars weren’t so dull and predictable more people would watch.

Congratulations Hollywood on patting yourselves on the back.

Rob Keyes says:

Ledger and Winslet were the sure-things for tonight and both got what they deserved. The acting categories were very well-rounded this year.

Iron Man was fun and one of my favs of the year but it had relatively weak special effects shots in terms of its CGI use in my opinion. The scenes where he’s fighting that tank and fighting Iron Monger seemed a little outdated.

btw, thanks Oscar! :)

Gary says:

I think Aniston was off cue with her lines .
Jack Black did the best he could.
why wasnt Javier bardem part of the Best Supporting Actor segment?
didnt he win last year?
Sorry The Dark Knight didnt win more
but Heaths win is HUGE and I think his family needed that.
I was glad for them more then anything else.
Did any body notice that Angelina was decked out in EMERALDS?
She had an an emerald ring on her finger and emerald earrings as well.
just some random thoughts .

Longshanks says:

@ Oscar
Yes,I do.

Oscar! says:

Your welcome :) , some people let their fanboyism get in the way of realizing who the real winners were. But some people(like you) actually pay attention to other films and not just comic book ones. And understand them. Just like how Vic admitted that although it was a very very very good film, it wasn’t gonna win anything. 2 good writers from one of the best websites on the net. :) Wow, I, I, I love you Rob. Lol jk jk

Oscar! says:

@Longshanks, LOL!

Ken J says:

My issue is not really TDK, you know I’m not a TDK fanboy, but I simply thought movies like Milk and Slumdog Millionaire are not that great… I didn’t see Milk because I can’t stand that snake Sean Penn but I saw Slumdog Millionaire and thought it was ok AT BEST. Probably a little on the boring side, and the whole jumping around the timeline thing is a bit overdone and not really as clever as all of these directors and writers think…

Dutch says:

justice won, slumdog won and marketing efforts lost, which is a splendid sign for any future film which is being done by individuals with hearts, brains and talent.
I can only wish for Rhaman to continue in our lives by creating scores for westernized movies from now on, not just for his home country movies. that score was SO creative, very very juicy…;-)
Yeah!

Oscar! says:

that’s exactly what I mean , how the hell can you say Milk isn’t that great and in your next sentence admit that you haven’t seen it yet?????

Rob Keyes says:

@ Ken,

If it’s not TDK, and you don’t like Milk or Slumdog, what are you 5 top movies of the year?

Milk and Slumdog are two of the best of the year in my opinion. Of the nominees, I only found The Reader and the end of Benjamin Button a touch on the boring side.

T. says:

Milk, I mean Penn’s speech was so arrogant and nsulting to the vast majority of this country it could have made me scream. I and millions of others should be ashamed and our children and grandchildren won’t be able to look at us? What the hell?

Alex says:

Slumdog was great technical movie. It has great editing and camera and music. And great direction. all actors acted exceptional. i don’t like that story. hahaha. i do not think there was any great movie than slumdog. Dark knight was great movie entertainment but not oscar material because there is not much creative work there excep heath ledger.

I still do not know why sean penn keep getting awards. I can’t understand his acting style. Rourke was robbed!.

Gary says:

I saw both Slumdog Millionaire And Benjamin Button Yesterday.
Slumdog was indeed just OK, but I am glad it beat out Benjamin Button.
Button was an interesting technical acheivment but the story was weak,
especially the ending.
I hope we have a higher quality of movies next year.

Ken J says:

Um, I don’t have to watch Milk because I don’t care at all about a movie starring Sean Penn’s mightier than thou self in a movie about a gay person. I am not against them, I just don’t CARE enough to waste 2 hours of my life to see a boohoo feel sorry for gay people movie. Same reason why I had 0 interest in watching Brokeback Mountain…

But nice dodging Slumdog Millionaire though, strawperson usually works pretty well with people who don’t know any better…

Ken J says:

Oops, mightier than thou? I’m on drugs, I meant holier than thou…

Stupid night shift…

Ken J says:

@Rob, all of my top movies are action movies, not really oscar bait movies so I don’t expect them to win big. But that’s why I don’t watch the oscars, I hate oscar bait movies and I’m not a film snob, I go to watch movies to have a good time, but I do have my standards in the action genre.

And about my top movies, the only one that I would think could be considered for oscars would be Gran Torino, but not sure if the official release was 2008 or 2009. I saw it in 2008…

nowhereman says:

In retrospect, perhaps TDK should have been shot entirely on the explosive ferrys and Winslet blown to the bejeezus belt in the warehouse…
I personally switched to the people’s choice awards right about the time they Dissed “Dude, where’s my car?” in favor of “Moulon rouge” (A film that in my mind was every bit as stoopid as “The Spirit” …
@ Diane – I feel your pain. I just can’t justify getting all spun up over decisions made by geriatric bozos with past or current ties to all the major studios, who cast thier “votes” in order that we, the movie going pulic can have their deffinition of value and art rammed down our throats…
Props to Heath!
Bring on Watchmen!
Well covered Rob. Kudos! :)

arrell says:

@ Diane: a quote for you from Richard Dreyfus: “We’ve all participated in two rituals: one is watching the Academy Awards, and the other is putting down the Academy Awards. Both are very sacred and traditional American events.”

Yeah, the Awards are dodgy but they’re so embedded in our society (a necessary evil). Didn’t care much for who won or who didn’t, was more interested in the entertainment via Jackman and other presenters. I was half cringing at all of Jackman’s singing and dancing, but it made for alright viewing.

Daniel F says:

I hate to say it, but I thought TDK was probably the best movie of the year as well. As much as I loved TDK the reason I say this isn’t because of some rabid fanboy issue it’s simply because this was a terrible movie year. Slumdog and Milk in my opinion were just barely ok films. The Wrestler was an awesome film and Curious case was pretty good, but overall this was a terrible year for good movies. I usually enjoy the oscars, but this year i couldn’t support them at all for a number of reasons some of those were the oscars fault and some were just the industry in general.

1. Lack of good movies this year.
2. Not the best nominations they could of picked better.
3. Disagreed with a the majority of winners.

Ken J says:

On top of all of that, I feel that a lot of these award shows are politically motivated. THE most obvious was when Dixie Chicks took home 5 awards in the Grammy’s.
1. Their lead singer can’t sing. Sorry, they pick catchy songs and know how to market them, but if you put their lead singer Nathalie Maines, or however you spell it, on American Idol that English guy Simon would rip her a new one.
2. They won best album when their album was not at all the top selling, top played, or top anything. Frankly, I thought their songs sucked, and apparently a lot of other people felt the same way because everyone bought Rascal Flatts instead, but they lost of course.
3. They won best single, and again, their singles sucked, and again, several other artists had songs that were liked much more, played much more, requested much more, and sold much more than their singles, yet they all lost.
4. I think they won for best female artist, against Carrie Underwood… Sorry, but Underwood has a voice in that cute little package, she can actually sing, unlike that lead singer of Dixie Chicks. Her voice is so high pitched and shrilling that it feels like it’s drilling into your brain at the ears when you try to listen to their garbage.

We ALL know why they won big that day… And it has NOTHING to do with their music.

I kind of feel that the Oscars is no different, I rarely watch it, so I can’t say for sure, but I know the “judges” more or less get to inject their own political opinions into their votes. I don’t know, you guys who watch the Oscars, do you find any kind of weird political pattern in the movies that typically win? Just curious.

nig says:

@ ken

had that feeling when sean penn won
i preferred mickey rourke..
but i think penn won cause of this whole proposition 8 thing
hollywood wants to make a statement of their stand in the situation.

Paul Newman says:

Why did you leave out the tributes to those whose passed away. It wasn’t just a song by Queen Latifah. What did you think about it? I would like to know.

Daniel F says:

You are correct Ken. It’s all very political. What ever movie is pushing the hot topics of the most recent couple of years usually comes out on top. Also usually the more outspoken you are the better the chance of winning. Honestly I watched Milk and it wasn’t very good and no where near Penn’s best performance.

Evie says:

I did enjoy the Oscars this year. The skits and such were very good.

I did find myself more than once going ‘why am I watching this? I haven’t seen most of these movies?’ yet… I was still in front of the TV.

Of the movies up for Best I have only seen The Wrestler. It was a good film. However, I feel Gran Torino was ripped off. Definitely an Oscar-worthy film and I was greatly disappointed it was left off the list.

We all know what to expect out of the Oscars and you have to remember WHO is voting for it. Not the general public, but people in the industry who look more into a film than its entertainment value. Like Schindler’s List: was that film entertaining? Nope, but it is one of the most important films of our time, just to give an example.

The awards given out for entertainment value are the MTV Movie and People’s Choice Awards… So I will continue to watch the Oscars and be happy when films like Lord of the Rings make the inner circle.

Page 1 of 41234»
What's your opinion? Leave a Reply!
GravatarWant to change your avatar?
Go to Gravatar.com and upload your own (we'll wait)!

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (optional)

 Rules: No profanity or personal attacks.
 Use a valid email address or risk being banned from commenting.


If your comment doesn't show up immediately, it may have been flagged for moderation. Please try refreshing the page first, then drop us a note and we'll retrieve it.